Connect with us

The Antique Dealer Gave Me $350 For My Late Husband’s Old Fiddle And Said It Was A Cheap Factory Fiddle With A Cracked Top. Ten Months Later A Young Woman Played It At The Courthouse Christmas Concert, And My Old Hound Threw Back His Head And Howled Like He Did Every Night For Cled

Off The Record

The Antique Dealer Gave Me $350 For My Late Husband’s Old Fiddle And Said It Was A Cheap Factory Fiddle With A Cracked Top. Ten Months Later A Young Woman Played It At The Courthouse Christmas Concert, And My Old Hound Threw Back His Head And Howled Like He Did Every Night For Cled

My husband played the same tune every night of our married life, and every night our dog sang along.

The tune was “Bonaparte’s Retreat.” If you’re from these mountains you know it, and if you’re not, I can’t explain it to you except to say it starts slow and sad and low, like somebody walking away from a fire, and then partway through it climbs up high and lonesome, and it stays there, crying, for longer than you think it can.

Cled played it on the porch in summer and by the woodstove in winter, after supper, before the news. And every night, when the tune climbed up to that high part, our Redbone hound Hosey would sit up, put his nose straight at the ceiling, and howl. Not bark. Howl, long and mournful, right on the note, like a second fiddle. Then when the tune came back down, Hosey would lie back down and sigh.

We laughed about it for eleven years. Company would come just to see it. Our grandson filmed it on his phone and said it got a lot of views, whatever that means.

But here’s the thing that nobody believed until they saw it. Hosey only did it for that fiddle.

Cled tried him once with a borrowed fiddle at the fire hall jam in Mill Creek. Same tune, same man, same high part. Hosey lay there under the table and didn’t so much as lift an ear. Cled said it was the voice of the thing. He said his fiddle had a sound in it that got into a dog’s bones.

Sukey

The fiddle came down from Cled’s grandfather.

In the winter of 1931, the story goes, a traveling man came through Leading Creek on foot, sick with a bad cough, and Cled’s grandmother took him in and nursed him through till spring. He had no money. When he left, he handed Cled’s grandfather a fiddle in a flour sack and said it was the only thing he owned worth anything and he wanted them to have it.

Cled’s grandfather named it Sukey, after a mule. He played it at dances for forty years. Then Cled’s father did. Then Cled.

It had a few marks on it from the life it led. There was a little scorch on the top near the tailpiece where it had sat too close to the cookstove one winter in the 1950s. And in 1979, the spring after we were married, it fell off our mantel during a thunderstorm and broke a chip out of the scroll, the curly part at the top. Cled carved a sliver of black walnut from a board out of his daddy’s barn and glued it in himself, and it was darker than the rest of the wood, like a little patch on the knee of a pair of britches. He was prouder of that patch than of anything he ever built.

Inside the fiddle, if you held it to the light and looked through the f-hole, there was an old paper label with some writing in Latin and a date in the 1700s. Cled said every cheap fiddle in the world has a label like that inside it. He said they glued them in by the thousand in Germany a hundred years ago to fool people. He never paid it any mind.

He loved that fiddle because it was his granddaddy’s, and because it sounded like home, and because a dog sang to it.

The Winter Cled Died

My name is Roena Hupp. I’m seventy-three. I was born in Tucker County and married Cled when I was twenty-five, and we lived forty-eight years on his family’s farm on Leading Creek, outside Elkins, West Virginia. Cled was a brakeman on the railroad until they shut the line down, and then he drove a log truck until his back gave out. I worked in the office at the high school. We raised one daughter, Darlis, who is a paralegal in Charleston and is smarter than both of us put together.

Cled died in January of 2024, of pneumonia, in the hospital in Elkins. It came on fast. On the last night he was home, before the ambulance, he was too sick to play. He asked me to bring him Sukey anyway, and he held it on his chest under the quilt, and Hosey lay on the floor beside the bed with his chin on Cled’s slipper.

After the funeral I put the fiddle back in its case under our bed and didn’t open it for a year.

Hosey would go and lie by the bed sometimes, with his nose by the case. I’d find him there in the afternoons.

What a Widow Needs

You don’t know how much a man does until he’s gone. The roof started leaking in the back bedroom that fall. The county raised the property assessment. My little pension from the high school and Cled’s railroad survivor benefit paid the bills, but they didn’t cover a new metal roof, and the man from Belington said it would be $9,800.

Darlis offered to help. I said no. I wasn’t going to let my daughter pay for my roof.

I thought about the fiddle for a long time. It felt like selling a piece of Cled. But it was just sitting in the dark under a bed, and he’d always said a fiddle that isn’t played dies a little every year. I thought maybe it could go to some young person who’d play it. And I thought maybe it would bring a few hundred dollars toward the roof.

So in February of last year I took Sukey to town.

Pennybacker’s

Wick Pennybacker has run Pennybacker’s Antiques and Music on Davis Avenue in Elkins for thirty years. He buys old furniture and quilts and guns and instruments. He came to Cled’s funeral. He sent a card. He had always been friendly to Cled, and Cled had always said he was “slicker than a greased doorknob,” but he said it laughing.

Wick took the fiddle out of the case and looked at it for maybe ten minutes. He turned it over and looked at the back. He shone a little flashlight through the f-hole at the label. He plucked the strings. Then he laid it back in the case, gentle, and took off his glasses.

“Roena,” he said, “I hate to tell you this. It’s a German trade fiddle. They made them by the boxcar load around 1890, and they all have a fancy label inside. The top’s got a crack under the scorch here, see? And that scroll’s been repaired by an amateur, which kills the value. I could sell it for maybe four hundred to a kid starting out.”

I said I’d thought it might be worth more than that. Cled’s granddaddy always said it was special.

“Everybody’s granddaddy said that.” He smiled kindly. “Tell you what. Because I thought the world of Cled, I’ll give you three hundred and fifty. Cash, today.”

I took it. I signed a little bill of sale on his counter. He counted out the bills, and he walked me to the door, and he said, “He’d be glad it’s going to get played.”

I cried in the truck. Then I drove to the hardware store and put the three hundred and fifty dollars down on the roofing screws.

An Old Dog Who Waited

When I got home without the fiddle case, Hosey went to the bedroom and lay down by the bed and stayed there.

He was eleven by then, his red coat going white around the eyes and his long ears gone soft and thin at the edges. I thought he’d get over it. He didn’t, not really. He’d lie by the bed in the afternoons with his nose under the dust ruffle where the case used to be, and some evenings around eight o’clock, the time Cled used to play, he’d get up and stand in the living room and look at the woodstove and then look at me.

I’d put on one of Cled’s old cassette tapes sometimes. He’d recorded himself playing, years ago, on a little machine from the Western Auto. Hosey would lift his head when the fiddle came on. He never howled. Not once. It wasn’t the same thing, coming out of a speaker.

I came to think of it as the sound of my house now. A dog waiting for a tune that wasn’t coming.

Christmas on the Courthouse Lawn

Every year on the second Saturday in December they have a Christmas concert on the lawn of the county courthouse in Elkins. They string the white lights on the big stone steps and sell hot chocolate, and local musicians play, and the high school choir sings, and there’s a tree.

I hadn’t gone the year Cled died. Last December Darlis came home for the weekend and said, “Mama, you’re going, and you’re bringing that dog, because he’s as depressed as you are.” Hosey hates to be left alone, so I put his good leash on him and my long red coat on me and we went.

It was cold and clear, with frost on the grass. We stood toward the back. The choir sang “O Holy Night” and I held up all right.

Then the man with the microphone said they had a special guest home for the holidays, a young woman from over in Pocahontas County who plays in Nashville now. Emberly Waybright. She came up the steps in a white puffy coat with a fiddle and bow, a slip of a girl, maybe twenty-five, with long brown hair. She said she was going to play an old tune her grandpa taught her.

She put the fiddle under her chin and started “Bonaparte’s Retreat.”

The High Part

I didn’t think anything at first. I just thought, oh, Cled’s tune. I squeezed Darlis’s hand. I was ready to be sad.

The tune came down slow and low across that frosty lawn. And then it started to climb.

Hosey stood up beside me.

I felt the leash go tight. I looked down and he was standing stiff, his ears lifted, his whole body pointed at the courthouse steps. Then, right as that girl’s bow went up into the high lonesome part, my old dog threw back his head, pointed his nose straight up at the Christmas lights, and howled.

Long and mournful and right on the note. Like a second fiddle.

People turned around. Some of them laughed. The girl on the steps glanced over and kept playing, and Hosey kept singing, and I stood there in my red coat with my hand pressed over my heart and tears running down my face, because I knew. I knew before I ever saw it up close.

There was only one fiddle in the world that dog would sing to.

When the tune came back down, Hosey lay down on the frozen grass and sighed.

The Walnut Patch

After she finished, I went up to the steps. Darlis tried to hold me back because she thought I was going to make a fool of myself, and maybe I was. Hosey pulled me the whole way.

“Honey,” I said to the girl, “I’m so sorry, this is going to sound crazy. Could I see your fiddle?”

She looked at me, and at the hound, and she was kind about it. She held it out under the lights.

There was the little scorch by the tailpiece. And there on the scroll, plain as day, was a patch of black walnut darker than the rest of the wood, like a knee patch on a pair of britches.

I said, “My husband carved that patch in 1979. Out of a board from his daddy’s barn.”

Emberly Waybright’s face went white.

What She Paid

We sat in Darlis’s car with the heater running, the four of us, me and Darlis and Emberly and Hosey, who would not stop resting his chin on that fiddle case.

Emberly said she bought the fiddle last May from a well-known violin shop in Nashville. Varner Violins. She’d been saving for six years. She’d taken out a loan from her credit union for the rest.

She’d paid $46,000.

It came with a certificate. It said the fiddle had been made in the 1760s by a maker in the Tyrol, in the Austrian mountains, a man whose instruments are rare and wanted. The label inside was real. The crack under the scorch was a “minor, stable, old repair.” The walnut patch on the scroll was “a charming period-appropriate repair that does not affect tone.”

“I never knew where it came from before the shop,” she said. “They said it came from an estate in West Virginia. I thought that was nice, actually. Coming home to these mountains.”

Darlis, who is a paralegal and was getting madder by the second, said, “Did they say who they bought it from?”

Emberly took out her phone right there in the car and called the shop. It was Saturday night, but the owner picked up. She put him on speaker.

He said, yes, he remembered it very well. He’d bought it in early March from a dealer in Elkins named Pennybacker. He’d paid $28,500.

Wick Pennybacker paid me $350 for that fiddle on a Wednesday in February. Twenty-four days later he sold it for $28,500.

The Photograph

The owner of Varner Violins was not a crook. He was horrified. He was the one who gave Darlis what she needed.

On Monday morning he emailed her a copy of the first message Wick Pennybacker ever sent him about my husband’s fiddle. It was dated two days after I signed the bill of sale on Wick’s counter. It had six photographs, including a very clear one of the label taken through the f-hole with a little flashlight.

The email said: “Just acquired from an estate. Tyrolean, 1760s, label original, I’d stake my reputation. Old top crack, stable. Amateur scroll graft but the tone is out of this world. Looking for 30.”

He knew. Standing at that counter telling me it was a boxcar fiddle with a crack that killed the value, he knew exactly what it was.

Darlis took that email, and the bill of sale, and my bank deposit slip for $350, to a lawyer she works with in Charleston named Lemoyne Pritt, who handles cases for older people who’ve been taken. And she also took it to the consumer protection office of the West Virginia Attorney General.

It turned out I wasn’t the first.

The Other Widows

Wick Pennybacker read the obituaries.

That’s what Lemoyne Pritt said, anyhow, after the Attorney General’s investigator got done with him. Every time a man who played music died in Webster, Tucker, Barbour or Pocahontas County, Wick would send a card. Sometimes he’d come to the funeral. And sometime in the next year, the widow would bring him a banjo or a mandolin or a fiddle, and Wick would look at it for ten minutes and tell her, kindly, that it wasn’t worth much.

A woman named Mrs. Hottinger in Parsons had sold him her husband’s 1920s banjo for $200. He sold it in Pennsylvania for $11,000. Another widow in Philippi got $150 for a mandolin that went for $6,500. There were five of us in the end that they could prove.

West Virginia law doesn’t take kindly to a dealer telling an old woman a lie to get her property cheap. Lemoyne Pritt was very polite about it, and very thorough, and Wick Pennybacker’s own lawyer advised him to settle before it ever saw a courtroom.

I got $28,150, the difference between what he paid me and what he got for Sukey. The other widows got theirs. Wick paid a civil penalty to the state, and he agreed never to buy or sell instruments in West Virginia again. Pennybacker’s Antiques and Music closed in the spring. There’s a vape shop there now. I’m not sure that’s better.

What I Told the Girl

Here’s the part people don’t understand when I tell this story.

They ask me why I didn’t make Emberly give the fiddle back.

She offered. That Saturday night in the car, she held out the case to me with her hands shaking and said, “Mrs. Hupp, it’s yours. It was always yours. I’ll figure out the loan.”

I thought about it. Lord knows I thought about it. I thought about putting that case back under my bed where it would sit in the dark again, and Hosey would lie beside it in the afternoons, and nobody would play it. Cled always said a fiddle that isn’t played dies a little every year.

Emberly hadn’t stolen anything. She’d saved six years. She’d paid a fair price to an honest man. And she played “Bonaparte’s Retreat” the way Cled did, slow and sad and then up high and lonesome, like she meant it.

So I said, “Honey, you keep it. On one condition.”

Every Christmas

The condition is that every year, the Sunday after the courthouse concert, Emberly Waybright drives over from Pocahontas County to my house on Leading Creek and sits by my woodstove and plays Sukey.

She came the first time this past January, once the lawyers were finished, and she brought her grandpa, who’s eighty and plays guitar. She has been back twice since, just to visit, and she calls me on Sundays. She’ll be here again three weeks from now, the Sunday after the concert, and I’ve already bought the soup beans. Darlis came home. My grandson came and brought his phone. I made a pot of soup beans and a pan of cornbread, and we pushed the furniture back.

She played some reels and some waltzes. Then she looked at me, and I nodded, and she started “Bonaparte’s Retreat.”

Hosey was asleep in front of the stove. He’s twelve now, and he doesn’t get up much. Emberly’s grandpa sat down on the floor next to him, which took some doing at eighty, and scratched his ears, and told me he’d had a Redbone himself as a boy that used to sing to the radio. “Not to just anything,” he said. “Only to the Opry on Saturday nights, and only when they had a fiddle on.” I told him Hosey only sang to one fiddle, and he looked over at the case on Emberly’s knees and said, “Well, then. He’s got taste.” When the tune came down slow and low, he opened one eye.

When it climbed up into the high part, he sat up, pointed his old white nose straight at the ceiling of Cled’s house, and sang.

I used the settlement money to put on the new roof and to pay off the rest of Emberly’s credit union loan. She doesn’t know that yet. She will when she reads this.

If someone you love has an old instrument or heirloom from a person they’ve lost, and someone’s offering to take it off their hands, please, get a second opinion first. And if this story warmed you up a little, share it with somebody who still has a fiddle under the bed. Maybe it’s time somebody played it.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family

Continue Reading

Jason is a writer and storyteller who focuses on the human side of the stories — moments of kindness, resilience, family, and the turning points that quietly change a life. He writes to inform, engage, and inspire, and believes the best stories are the ones that make readers feel less alone.