Off The Record
My New Neighbor Moved The Fence 41 Feet Onto Our Farm And Sent Me A Lawyer’s Letter Saying My Late Husband’s Pear Trees Were His. Then My Old Collie Kept Digging At One Spot Under The Wire Until She Pulled Up The Iron Pin He Swore Was Never There
Every evening for eleven years my husband Delmas walked our collie to the back corner of the farm and gave her a biscuit.
He never called it anything but “the corner.” After supper he would push back from the table, put on his tan work jacket whether it was July or January, and say, “Brandy, corner.” That dog would be at the screen door before he had his arm in the second sleeve.
The corner is where our sixty-two acres on Holman’s Creek Road meet the old Huffman place, out past the spring and the three pear trees his granddaddy planted in 1938. There was a pile of fieldstone there, waist high, and in the middle of the stones an iron pipe stuck up out of the ground about four inches. Delmas painted the top of that pipe red every spring with the same can of barn paint. He said a corner you can’t find is a corner somebody else will move.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →He worked for the Virginia Department of Transportation for thirty-one years, the last nineteen as a road crew foreman, and he had a road man’s respect for markers. Mile markers, survey stakes, benchmarks set in bridge abutments.
He would sit on the stones and Brandy would sit at his boot, and he would break a dog biscuit in two and give her both halves, one for the walk out and one for the walk back. Then he would look across the Huffman fields to the Massanutten ridge going purple, and he would tell her about his day. I know because I went with them sometimes.

Delmas died two years ago this past March. It was a stroke in the barn, and our neighbor’s boy found him, and I will not say more about that day than I have to.
I am seventy-one. I was a teacher’s aide at the elementary school in Forestville for twenty-six years. I raise a garden, I keep twelve hens, and I have Brandy, who is ten now, sable and white with a ruff like a lion and a gray muzzle she got the winter after he died. I believe that was grief.
For the first month after the funeral, Brandy went to the screen door every evening at six-fifteen and whined. So I put on Delmas’s tan jacket, which still smelled like him and like diesel, and I said, “Brandy, corner,” and the two of us walked out past the spring and the pear trees to the stone pile, and I gave her a biscuit in two halves.
We have done it every evening since. It is the only thing I have kept exactly like he did it.
The Man From Up North
The Huffman place sold the fall after Delmas died. Old Mrs. Huffman went to live with her daughter in Staunton, and the farm sat for a while, and then a couple bought it who had retired from somewhere near Washington. Pierson and Margaux Vanlandingham.
I took them a pound cake. That’s what you do. Mrs. Vanlandingham thanked me at the door and did not ask me in, and that’s all right, people are different. Mr. Vanlandingham came down the steps and shook my hand and asked how many acres I had, and whether I had ever thought about selling. I said no. He laughed like I’d told a joke and said, “Everybody has a number, Mrs. Sprouse.”
They tore down the Huffman farmhouse, which had stood since 1890, and built a house the size of a church out of gray stone. In the spring he walked over while I was hoeing beans and asked about the spring.
Our spring comes out of the hillside between the pear trees and the corner. Delmas boxed it in concrete in 1981. It has never once run dry, not even in the drought of 2002.
“Margaux wants a pond,” Mr. Vanlandingham said. “A real one, with a dock. My engineer says that spring would feed it year round. Would you sell me an easement?”
I told him I was sorry, but the spring was ours, and it watered my garden and my hens, and Delmas’s granddaddy’s pear trees, and I wasn’t going to sell any part of it.
He looked at the pear trees a long while. “Those are on the line, aren’t they?” he said.
“They’re on our side of it,” I said. “Forty feet on our side.”
He said, “Huh.” And he went home.
Twelve Days in Front Royal
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →In September my sister Ocie had her hip replaced in Front Royal, and somebody had to stay with her, and she has no one but me. I asked the Dellinger boy down the road to feed my hens and look in on Brandy twice a day,
Colter Dellinger is twenty-four. Delmas taught him to run a backhoe when he was fifteen, out in our bottom field, and Colter cried at the funeral harder than some of the family did. He was working for an excavating outfit by then, and doing odd jobs on the side.
I was gone twelve days in all.
When I came home, it was almost dark, and Brandy came out of the house past me like she’d been shot from a gun. She went straight across the yard, past the garden, out toward the spring. I followed her with the flashlight.
There was a new fence.
Shiny new woven wire on brand new steel posts, running down the hill on the wrong side of my pear trees. On the wrong side of my spring. It cut off the whole back corner of our farm in a long thin wedge. The old stone pile was on the other side of it.
Brandy was standing at the wire with her nose through it, looking at those stones, whining the way she had whined at the screen door the first month after Delmas died.
I stood there in the dark in my husband’s jacket, and I did not understand what I was seeing.
The Letter From Leesburg
Two days later a letter came, certified, from a law firm in Leesburg with four names on the letterhead.
It said that Mr. Vanlandingham had commissioned a boundary survey of his property by Kesner Land Surveying of Winchester, and that the survey established the true line between our properties at a location approximately forty-one feet west of the “line of occupation.” It said a copy of the plat was enclosed. It said that my chicken coop’s run, a portion of my late husband’s woodshed, the spring box and three fruit trees were located on Mr. Vanlandingham’s property, and that I was trespassing.
It said Mr. Vanlandingham was “a reasonable neighbor” and was prepared to “resolve this matter amicably.” I could remove the woodshed and the coop run within sixty days and pay $18,500 in damages for “years of unauthorized use.” Or, as a courtesy, he would accept a quitclaim deed to the disputed strip, and the damages would be waived.
In other words, give him the spring and the pear trees, or pay him eighteen thousand dollars and give him the spring and the pear trees anyway.
I sat at my kitchen table with that letter and Delmas’s reading glasses and I read it four times. Then I called my son.
“Mom, It’s Forty Feet”
Eston is forty-six. He’s an accountant in Richmond, and a good son.
“Mom,” he said, “I’m sorry, but did Dad ever actually have a survey done?”
“He knew where the line was,” I said. “He painted the corner every spring.”
“Okay. But a licensed surveyor says it’s forty-one feet over. That’s a professional with a stamp. A lawyer will cost you twenty thousand dollars to fight that and you might lose. It’s forty feet of brush, Mom. Sign the quitclaim and let him have his pond.”
“It’s the spring,” I said. “It’s your great-granddaddy’s trees.”
He was quiet. Then he said the thing I think he’d been wanting to say since the funeral. “Mom, maybe this is a sign. That’s a lot of farm for one person. If he wants the strip, maybe he’d want the whole place. You could get something small near us.”
I told him I’d think about it, which is what mothers say when they mean the conversation is over.
That night I walked Brandy out to the corner like always. We couldn’t get to it. We stood at the new wire and I broke her biscuit in two and she wouldn’t eat either half. She lay down with her nose under the bottom wire, pointed at the stone pile, and she stayed there until I picked her up and carried her home.
A Dog Who Would Not Quit
After that, Brandy went to the wire every day.
Not just at six-fifteen. Any time I let her out, she trotted straight past the hens and down through the pear trees to the same spot on the new fence, about six feet north of where the stone pile sat on the other side. She would dig at the base of the post. Steady, like she had a job. Then she’d lie down and look at me over her shoulder, the way she used to look at Delmas when she’d treed a groundhog and wanted credit.
I’d fill the hole back in with my boot. The next morning there would be a new one, deeper.
I thought she was trying to get under the fence to the corner. I thought it was grief, and habit, and an old dog who didn’t understand why her walk had been taken away.
On the fifth day, I looked closer at the stone pile on the other side of the wire.
It was different.
I hadn’t seen it in the dark the night I came home. But in daylight I could see it. The stones had been moved. Somebody had pulled them apart and stacked them back, not the way they’d been for a hundred years with moss on the north faces, but fresh, raw side up, a little lower and wider than before. And in the middle, where Delmas’s red pipe had stuck up four inches out of the ground for as long as I’d been married, there was nothing.
No pipe.
The Surveyor’s Plat
I called the law firm in Leesburg. A young man there said he would have to check with Mr. Vanlandingham, and called me back the next day.
“Mrs. Sprouse, my client says there is no iron pipe at that location and never has been. The surveyor found no monument there. That’s precisely why the line was established where it was. Mr. Kesner’s survey relies on the original 1911 deed calls and a monument found at the corner of the Riddle tract to the south.”
“There was a pipe,” I said. “My husband painted it red every spring for forty years.”
The young man was polite. “Ma’am, I’m sure your husband believed there was a line there. But perhaps he was mistaken about what that pipe was. It could have been an old fence brace. With respect, a surveyor’s plat is evidence. A memory isn’t.”
I hung up and cried. Brandy put her chin on my knee. Then she went to the door and asked to go out. I knew where she was going.
Under the Wire
That afternoon I followed her.
It was the first week of October, overcast, the pear leaves going yellow and the mountain blue behind them. Brandy went straight to her spot by the new post and started digging. This time I didn’t fill it back in. I knelt down in the grass beside her and watched.
She was digging on our side of the fence, where she could reach. The hole was a foot deep already, and slanting under the wire toward the stone pile, and the dirt coming out of it was loose. Not packed clay like the rest of that hillside. Loose, dark, mixed with broken roots, like it had been turned over not long ago.
Brandy put her whole head down in the hole, and when she brought it up, she had something in her mouth.
It was the top of a rusty iron pipe. Red paint flaking off it. She couldn’t get it out, it was too long and heavy, and she was pulling at it backwards with her front feet braced, growling, the way she used to play tug with Delmas’s old sock.
I put my hand down in that hole and closed it around the pipe and pulled.
It came out of the dirt. Two and a half feet of inch-and-a-half iron pipe, rusted, the top crusted with forty years of red barn paint, layer on layer, so thick it was shaped like a little cap. The bottom end was bent, like somebody had worked it back and forth to get it out of the ground and then pushed it into the soft dirt along the new fence line where it wouldn’t be seen.
Delmas’s corner pin.
I knelt there in the grass in his jacket holding that pipe in both hands, and Brandy sat down beside me and wagged and looked up at me like, well, you’re welcome. I said, “Good girl,” and I could barely get it out.
What Delmas Buried
I did not call the Leesburg lawyer back. I called a lawyer in Harrisonburg that the woman who runs the feed store recommended, Arbutus Lineweaver, about sixty, with half-glasses on a chain and the look of a woman who had taken a lot of men’s lunch money.
She came out the next day and looked at the pipe on my kitchen table. She looked at the new fence and the moved stones. Then she asked me, “Who did your husband’s original survey? Somebody set that pipe.”
I didn’t know. I went and got Delmas’s lockbox. Under the deed and the truck title was a long envelope I’d never opened, because it said “LINE” on the front in his square road crew printing and I figured it was something boring.
Inside was a copy of a survey plat dated May 14, 1987, sealed and signed by Alpheus Shank, county surveyor. It showed our farm, with the corner by the spring marked “IPF,” iron pipe found, “witnessed.” And clipped to it, a page of notes in Delmas’s hand.
“Alpheus and I found the original pin May 13 1987 under 8 in. of dirt in the rock pile. Set new 1 1/2 in. pipe on top same hole. Buried 2 witnesses 3 ft. due east of pin. Quart jar with copy of this plat. Old axle from the Ford. If anybody ever moves this corner, dig.”
Arbutus read it twice. Then she took her glasses off and let them hang on their chain and said, “Well, God bless a road man.”

Alpheus
Alpheus Shank is eighty-eight years old and lives with his daughter outside Mount Jackson. Arbutus called him that afternoon. She said later that when she told him what had happened, there was a long silence, and then he said, “Who’s the surveyor?” And when she said Kesner, he said a word she won’t repeat.
He came out on Saturday. His daughter drove him. He walked with a cane, and he had his old brass plumb bob in his coat pocket, and a metal detector his grandson had brought in the trunk.
We also had a deputy from the Shenandoah County Sheriff’s Office, because Arbutus said if we were going on that side of the fence to dig, she wanted a man in a uniform standing there watching us do it. And she had sent a letter to Leesburg that Friday saying exactly when we’d be there and inviting Mr. Vanlandingham and Mr. Kesner to attend.
Mr. Vanlandingham came. Mr. Kesner did not.
He stood on his side of the new wire in a quilted vest and said, “This is trespassing and I want that noted.”
The deputy said, “It’s noted, sir.”
Alpheus looked at the stone pile and the bare hole in the middle of it. Then he looked at the bent pipe Brandy had dug up, which I had brought in a feed sack. He turned it over in his hands. He ran his thumb over the paint cap. “That’s mine,” he said. “I bought that pipe at Hepner’s Hardware in New Market the morning of May 13, 1987, and Delmas paid for it, and I’ve still got the receipt in my files because I keep everything. Eighty-eight years, I keep everything.”
Then he paced three feet due east of the hole with his cane, and the grandson swept the detector over the ground, and it screamed.
They dug down about fourteen inches. The axle came up first, a short piece of an old Ford truck axle, rusted black. Then the quart Ball jar with its zinc lid, packed full of something wrapped in waxed paper. Alpheus unwrapped it with his hands shaking and there was the plat, folded in fourths, as crisp as the day Delmas put it in there.
I had to sit down on the ground.
Brandy came and lay across my feet. She had gotten through the fence somehow, I never did figure out how, and she sat on that stone pile like she owned it.
The Boy With the Backhoe
Here is the part I still lie awake about.
Monday morning, before Arbutus had even filed anything, Colter Dellinger knocked on my kitchen door with his cap in his hands.
He couldn’t look at me. He said Mr. Vanlandingham had hired him the week I was in Front Royal to run his little track machine and “clear some brush and an old rock pile along the line.” He said Mr. Vanlandingham walked out there with him and pointed at the red pipe and said, “That old fence brace has to come out, it’s in the way of the new posts.” And he paid Colter four hundred dollars cash. Colter said he worked it out with the bucket and laid it along the new fence trench and figured it was just junk.
“Then I saw Brandy digging on Thursday,” he said, “when I came to do your hens. And I saw what she was digging at. And I knew what I’d done, Miss Ilene. Delmas showed me that pipe. When I was fifteen. He made me stand on it and he said, ‘That’s a corner, Colter. That’s the law of the land, right there.’ And I pulled it out of the ground for four hundred dollars.”
He put four hundred dollars in twenties on my kitchen table and asked me to give it to the lawyer.
I didn’t. I made him sit down and eat a biscuit with apple butter, and I told him Delmas would have been proud of him for walking up those steps. He cried into his coffee and Brandy laid her head on his knee the whole time.
Then he went to Arbutus’s office and gave her a sworn statement.
What a Stamp Is Worth
It turned out Mr. Kesner of Kesner Land Surveying had a few problems.
When Arbutus filed a complaint with the state board that licenses surveyors, it came out that Mr. Kesner’s survey of the Vanlandingham property “did not locate” the iron pipe at our corner because his field crew went out there on September 22, three days after Colter pulled it. Mr. Vanlandingham had scheduled the survey himself. Mr. Kesner had done three other jobs for Mr. Vanlandingham’s old company back up north. And his plat had used a corner monument a quarter mile south that Alpheus said “a blind mule could see is the wrong stone.”
There was also the matter of the pond. Margaux Vanlandingham, it seems, had already hired a pond builder from Winchester, and the contract was dated August, a month before the survey. The design showed a dock right where Delmas’s granddaddy’s middle pear tree stands. A thing like that is hard to explain when you claim you only learned where the line was in September.
Arbutus filed a suit to quiet title and for damages. She did not have to go very far with it.
In January, Mr. Vanlandingham’s Leesburg lawyers wrote to say their client had “reviewed the new evidence” and would like to resolve the matter. He agreed to a recorded boundary line agreement placing the corner exactly where Delmas’s pipe had been. He paid to have his fence torn out and rebuilt on the true line by a fence company of my choosing. He paid Alpheus’s fee, and Arbutus’s fee, and he paid me $12,000 for what Arbutus called “the willful removal of a boundary monument,” which in Virginia, she told me, is not a small thing at all.
Mr. Kesner surrendered his surveying license in April.
The pond got built anyway, smaller, on his own ground. I hear it’s mostly green.
Brandy’s Corner
Alpheus came back out in the spring, on a warm day in late April, with his daughter and his grandson and a new inch-and-a-half iron pipe. He said he’d been a surveyor for fifty-four years and he wanted to set one more pin before he died, and he wanted it to be this one.
They set it in the original hole. The grandson reset the stones, moss side north, the way they had been. Colter Dellinger came over without anybody asking and helped carry them.
When it was done, Alpheus handed me a little can of red barn paint and a brush. “This part,” he said, “belongs to you.”
I painted the top of it while Brandy sat at my boot. My son Eston was there too. He had driven out from Richmond that morning. He stood off to the side with his hands in his pockets and watched me paint his daddy’s corner, and when I was done he came over and put his arm around me and said, “I’m sorry, Mom. I should have trusted you.”
I said, “You should have trusted your daddy. He’s the one who buried the jar.”
Eston laughed, and then he didn’t, and then he wiped his face and pretended it was pollen from the pear trees. They were in full bloom that week, all three of them, white as a wedding.

Six-Fifteen
We still go out every evening at six-fifteen, Brandy and me. I wear the tan jacket. It doesn’t smell like Delmas much anymore. It mostly smells like me and like dog, and I’ve made my peace with that.
I sit on the stones and break her biscuit in two. One for the walk out and one for the walk back. I tell her about my day.
Mr. Vanlandingham and I wave when we pass on the road. I’m not a woman who holds a grudge forever. I’m just a woman who keeps the receipt.
And three feet due east of that corner, fourteen inches down, there is a new quart jar now. Alpheus’s new plat is in it, wrapped in waxed paper, and a copy of the boundary agreement, and a page in my own handwriting that I am not going to tell you all of.
The last line says, “If anybody ever moves this corner, ask the dog.”
If you have a parent or grandparent who keeps the old papers in a lockbox, and you’ve been meaning to tell them to throw all that out, please don’t. Sit down with them and go through it instead. And if this story made you think of somebody stubborn you love, share it with them. They’ll know why.
Now Trending:
- At My 86th Birthday Dinner, My Son Raised His Glass And Asked, “How Much Longer Are You Going To Sit On Dad’s Money?” His Wife Laughed. The Next Morning I Called My Lawyer
- My Drunk Brother Took My 7-Year-Old On His Jet Ski Without A Life Jacket And Came Back Alone, Laughing. When I Reached For My Phone, My Dad Grabbed My Arm And Screamed, “Don’t Get Your Brother Arrested!”
- My Daughter-In-Law Called While I Was Buying Gifts For My Grandkids And Told Me Not To Come To Christmas. I Said ‘Merry Christmas’ And Drove Somewhere Else. At 7:15 The Next Morning, My Son Was Pounding On My Door About His Late Father’s $31,000
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
