Off The Record
My Son Wanted To Move Me Into Assisted Living Because I Kept Saying I Heard Chainsaws In Our Woods At 2 A.M. So One Night I Sat Up In My Truck With My Old Dog, And At 1:40 He Started Growling At A Trailer Rolling Out Of The Trees With Its Lights Off
My daddy planted the walnut trees in the spring of 1951, the year he came home from Korea. He planted them in rows on the north slope of our hollow outside Paoli, in Orange County, Indiana, four hundred and twelve little seedlings he bought from the state nursery for a penny apiece. He told my mother they were for his grandchildren. He didn’t have any children yet. He said a walnut tree takes seventy years to be worth anything, and a man ought to plant something he’ll never see.
He didn’t see it. He died in 1989. I did.
I am seventy-nine years old. My name is Eudell Bowersox. I farmed that ground for fifty years, corn and beans and a few beef cows, and I drove a school bus for the Paoli schools for twenty-two winters on top of it. My wife Nedra kept the books and raised our boy and made the best persimmon pudding in three counties. She died in February of last year, in her sleep, with her reading glasses still on.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →It was Nedra who started calling those walnut trees “the college fund.” We have five grandchildren. Nedra figured that when the youngest turned eighteen, we’d have a forester mark the best trees and sell them, and split it five ways. She went out the summer before she died with a can of blue paint and dabbed a little spot of it on the north side of the sixty biggest walnuts, waist high, so the forester would know which ones she meant. I carried the paint. She did the dabbing. She said she didn’t trust me to be gentle with it.
“These are for the kids, Eudell,” she said. “Don’t you let anybody talk you out of it.”

The Man From Crabtree Hardwoods
Lavon Crabtree came to the house the week after Nedra’s funeral with a casserole from his wife.
I have known Lavon thirty years. He owns Crabtree Hardwoods over toward Salem, a sawmill and timber-buying outfit, and he is an elder in his church and sat on the county council for two terms. He’s the kind of man who remembers your grandkids’ names. He stood in my kitchen and said how sorry he was about Nedra, and then, while I was putting the casserole in the icebox, he said, “Eudell, I don’t want to bring this up at a time like this. But your daddy’s walnut is about as ripe as walnut gets. If you ever want to turn it into money for those grandkids, you call me first.”
I said I’d think on it.
In April he came back with a number. Twenty-two thousand dollars for the sixty marked trees.
I didn’t know much about walnut prices, but I knew a man in Bloomington who did. I called him. He said a good veneer walnut log, straight and clear, could bring fifteen hundred to three thousand dollars at the mill by itself, and my daddy’s trees, if they were what I said, might be worth well over two hundred thousand. He said, “Don’t you sell those to anybody without a forester, Mr. Bowersox, and don’t you ever sell them on a handshake.”
I told Lavon no. Thank you, but no. I told him I was going to have a state forester out in the fall, like Nedra wanted.
He smiled and shook my hand and said, “You’re the boss, Eudell.”
The Barking
It started in August.
Tick is my dog. He’s a Black Mouth Cur, golden tan with a black face going gray, eleven years old and stubborn as a post. Nedra picked him out of a litter in Shoals because he was the one who untied her shoe. He sleeps on a rug by the back door, and he has slept through thunderstorms, coyotes, and the Fourth of July his whole life.
Then one night in August he woke me up at 1:30 in the morning, standing at the back door, barking at the dark. Deep, ugly barking, with the hair up on his back. I let him out and he ran to the edge of the yard and stood facing the north hollow, barking at the woods, and wouldn’t come back in for half an hour.
The next night he did it again. Same time, give or take.
The third night I went out with him and stood in the yard in my undershirt, and I swear on Nedra’s grave I heard a chainsaw. Way off, down the hollow, faint, like a mosquito. Then nothing. Then it started up again.
I went in and wrote it down on the kitchen calendar, the one from the feed store that Nedra always kept by the phone. “Tick barking 1:35. Saw?” I don’t know why I wrote it down. Nedra wrote everything down, and I guess I’d picked it up.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →What My Son Heard
My son Darrin is fifty-two. He works in the office of a limestone quarry over in Bedford, and he has three of the five grandchildren, and he calls me every Sunday night at seven.
I told him about the chainsaws.
He was quiet. Then he said, “Dad, who would be cutting wood in the middle of the night?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “That’s why I’m telling you.”
“Did you go down there and look?”
I had. The north hollow is steep, and my knees aren’t what they were, and the walnut stand is a long way back. I’d walked the near edge of it twice and seen nothing but walnut trees and poison ivy. I hadn’t gone all the way down to the back fence where it meets Tharp’s Ridge Road. Truth is, I couldn’t.
“Dad,” Darrin said gently, “are you sleeping okay? Since Mom?”
I said I was sleeping fine, except when the dog woke me up because somebody was cutting down my trees.
He said he’d come out on Saturday.
“He Saw You on the Road”
Darrin came out with his wife Shirlene, and they walked the near part of the woods with me, and they didn’t see anything either. Then we sat at the kitchen table and Shirlene brought out a brochure from a place in Bedford called Limestone Gardens Senior Living.
“We’re not saying today,” Darrin said. “We’re just saying think about it.”
“Think about what? I’m not the one cutting down trees at two in the morning.”
Darrin and Shirlene looked at each other.
“Dad,” Darrin said. “Lavon Crabtree called me last week.”
I put my coffee down.
“He said he was coming home late from a church meeting about a month ago and he saw you walking down the middle of Tharp’s Ridge Road at two in the morning in your pajamas, with a flashlight, and the dog. He said he pulled over and asked if you were okay and you told him you were looking for Mom.”
I have never in my life walked down Tharp’s Ridge Road in my pajamas. I have never in my life told anybody I was looking for Nedra. I know exactly where Nedra is. She is in the Lick Creek cemetery under a gray stone that I picked out, and I go see her every Tuesday.
“He’s lying,” I said.
“Dad. Why would Lavon Crabtree lie about something like that?”
And I didn’t have an answer for him. Not yet. I just knew that Lavon Crabtree was the only man in the world who had asked me to sell those trees.
The Calendar
After they left, I sat with the feed store calendar.
I had written the barking down every night since August. I don’t know if I’d have kept at it if Darrin had believed me, but he hadn’t, and I am a stubborn old man, so I kept at it. Most nights, between 1:20 and 2:00. Not every night. Mondays and Thursdays, mostly, and a few Wednesdays. Never on a weekend.
Tick never once barked on a Saturday or Sunday night.
You don’t need to be a detective to figure out that a dog doesn’t know what day it is. But somebody with a job does.
I went down to the barn and got out Nedra’s big flashlight, the yellow one she used for checking on calving heifers. I filled my thermos with coffee. And on Monday night, at a quarter to one in the morning, I put on my brown canvas jacket and my cap and I told Tick, “Load up.”
The Truck
I drove my old pickup down the back field lane with the lights off, slow, the way I used to sneak up on deer when I was a young fool. The lane runs along the bottom of the north hollow to an old gate on Tharp’s Ridge Road that nobody had used since my daddy’s time. I pulled the truck into a gap in the fencerow about a hundred yards short of the gate, where I could see it, and I shut off the engine.
Then Tick and I sat there in the dark.
I’m not going to pretend I wasn’t scared. I’m seventy-nine. Nobody knew where I was. I had my phone in my shirt pocket and Nedra’s flashlight on the seat and a thermos of coffee, and an old dog sitting up on the bench seat beside me with his ears pointed out the windshield.
I talked to Nedra a little. I told her this was probably the stupidest thing I’d done since I asked her to marry me in a hailstorm. I told her if I died out here of a heart attack, it was her fault for buying that dog.
At 1:12 Tick stood up on the seat.
At 1:20 I heard it. A chainsaw, down the hollow, back in the trees. It ran for maybe two minutes, then quit. Then something big went down, a long cracking groan and a crash that I felt in the seat of the truck.
I have heard a lot of trees fall. I knew what that was.
Tick started to growl, low, way down in his chest. I put my hand on his back. He was shaking.
For about twenty minutes there was nothing but an engine, a small diesel engine, grinding back and forth in the woods. Then at 1:40 by the dashboard clock, a shape came up out of the hollow on my own field lane.
It was a skid steer pulling a low trailer. No lights. Not a single one. On that trailer, chained down, were three walnut logs as big around as a fifty-five gallon barrel.
Blue Paint
I don’t know where the nerve came from. I think it came from Nedra.
I started the truck and turned on the headlights, high beams, and I pulled straight across that lane in front of the gate and stopped.
The skid steer stopped too. The driver threw his arm up over his eyes.
Tick went out the passenger window. I had it rolled down a few inches for the air and I would not have believed an eleven-year-old dog could get through that gap, but he did, and he hit the ground and went straight at that skid steer, barking like the hounds of hell. He didn’t bite. He’s never bitten anybody in his life. He just stood in front of that machine with his feet planted, roaring, and the driver sat up there frozen with his hands up like it was a holdup.
I got out with Nedra’s flashlight and dialed 911 with my thumb.
The driver was a boy. Nineteen, twenty, skinny, in a hooded sweatshirt. He was crying before I even got to him. “Please call your dog off, mister,” he said. “Please, I’m just the driver. I just drive.”
I put the flashlight on the logs.
On the side of the biggest one, waist high from where the tree had stood, was a little dab of blue paint.

Thirty-Four Stumps
The Orange County deputy got there at 2:25. Behind him, at a quarter to four, came Officer Dace Ludwick from the Indiana Department of Natural Resources, because in Indiana, I learned that night, stealing timber is a matter the conservation officers take very personally.
When it got light, Officer Ludwick and the deputy and Tick and I walked down the north hollow, slow, with Officer Ludwick holding my elbow on the steep places.
They had been smart about it. They worked from the back of the stand, the far side, down by Tharp’s Ridge Road, where nobody would ever see. They cut low, and they covered every stump with brush and the tops of the trees. They dragged the logs out on my own field lane in the dark and loaded them at the old gate, where they’d cut my daddy’s rusted chain and put on a new lock of their own.
Thirty-four stumps. Thirty-four of Nedra’s sixty blue trees, gone since August.
I stood in the misty light at the edge of the biggest one, a stump near three feet across, with the sawdust still damp on top of it. Tick put his nose down on it and sniffed it all the way around, and then he sat down beside it and looked up at me.
I am not ashamed to say I had to sit down on that stump. Officer Ludwick put his hand on my shoulder and didn’t say anything, which was the right thing to say.
The Driver’s Name
The boy’s name was Brysen Hiner. He lived in a trailer near Livonia with his mother, and he had been paid one hundred and fifty dollars cash a night, he said, to run the skid steer for a man named Rusk, who ran the saw. Rusk had picked him up every Monday and Thursday at midnight. They had a truck waiting at the gate on Tharp’s Ridge Road and took the logs out by four.
“Where’d the logs go?” Officer Ludwick asked.
Brysen looked at the ground. “Crabtree’s,” he said. “To the mill. Mr. Crabtree said the old man sold ’em but he’s got the dementia, and his family don’t want him upset, so we got to do it at night so he don’t see.”
I heard it. The deputy heard it. Officer Ludwick wrote it down.
Lavon Has an Answer
Lavon Crabtree had an answer, of course. Men like that always have an answer.
When Officer Ludwick went to the mill that afternoon, Lavon said I had sold him the trees on a handshake back in April, for twenty-two thousand dollars, and that he’d paid me in cash. He said he was very sorry to hear I didn’t remember. He said my son could tell them I’d been confused since my wife passed. He said he’d only cut at night out of kindness, so I wouldn’t have to watch.
He even had a receipt, he said. With my signature.
For about one day, I think Officer Ludwick wasn’t sure. You could see him thinking about it. An old widower, a son who’d been worried enough to bring a brochure, a well-respected man with a receipt.
So I gave him Nedra’s calendar.
Every Monday and Thursday since August, in my handwriting, the time Tick woke me up barking. Officer Ludwick took that calendar to Cosner Veneer over in Jasper, where Crabtree Hardwoods sold its best walnut, and he got the scale tickets for every load Crabtree had delivered since summer.
Every one of them came in on a Tuesday or Friday morning. The morning after a night on my calendar. Thirty-four logs, plus the tops and the second cuts, over eleven loads. Cosner had paid Crabtree Hardwoods $61,840.
And the receipt with my signature? I have signed my name the same way since 1958, with a big loop on the B that Nedra used to say looked like a pregnant fish. The signature on Lavon’s receipt had no loop at all. It looked like it had been copied off something. Later, the state police lab said it had been traced, slow and careful, from the thank-you card I mailed his wife after the funeral.
My Son on the Porch
Darrin drove out that Tuesday night as soon as he heard. He stood on my porch for a long time before he knocked, which I know because Tick told me.
When I opened the door he didn’t say anything at first. He just hugged me, hard, the way he used to when he was a little boy and I came home off the bus route.
“I’m sorry, Dad,” he said into my shoulder. “He called me and I believed him over you. Lavon Crabtree. I believed him over you.”
“Well,” I said. “He’s a good liar. And I’m an old man who talks to a dog.”
“You sat out there in the truck,” he said. “By yourself. At two in the morning.”
“I had Tick.”
Darrin laughed and cried at the same time, and Tick came up and leaned on his legs the way he does, all eighty pounds of him, and Darrin sat right down on the porch boards and put his arms around that dog’s neck.
He threw that brochure in my woodstove before he left. I watched him do it.
What the Law Says
Here is something I didn’t know. In Indiana, if a man cuts and takes your timber knowing it isn’t his, you can go after him for three times what it was worth. My lawyer, a young fellow in Paoli named Ralston Kite who went to school with my granddaughter, explained it at my kitchen table with a pencil.
Three times $61,840 is $185,520.
Lavon Crabtree’s insurance company, after looking at the calendar, the scale tickets, the boy’s statement, and the receipt, decided they didn’t want a jury in Orange County to look at them too. They settled in June. Lavon pleaded guilty in the fall to timber theft and forgery, and the state took away his timber buyer’s license. The man named Rusk turned out to be his nephew. I’m told the church found a new elder.
Brysen Hiner got probation, because he told the truth from the first minute and kept telling it. I wrote the judge a letter for him. I said a boy who cries when he’s caught is a boy who still has a conscience worth saving. He comes out sometimes now and helps me with the fence. He’s scared to death of Tick, which Tick enjoys.

Planting Day
The money is in five accounts now, one for each grandchild, the way Nedra wanted. It’s a good deal more than the walnut would have brought if I’d sold it standing. I suppose there’s a lesson in there somewhere, but I don’t think Nedra would want me to take any satisfaction in it.
This past April, I bought three hundred black walnut seedlings from the state nursery. They don’t cost a penny anymore, but they don’t cost much.
On a Saturday in April, all five of the grandkids and Darrin and Shirlene and I planted them on the north slope where the thirty-four stumps are. The littlest one, Nedra’s namesake, is seven. She asked me how long before the trees would be worth anything.
“Seventy years,” I said.
She did the arithmetic on her fingers. “You’ll be dead,” she said.
“Yes, ma’am,” I said. “That’s the whole idea. A man ought to plant something he’ll never see.”
She thought about that. Then she asked if she could have the blue paint.
Tick still wakes me up some nights. Not at 1:30 anymore. Mostly it’s a raccoon on the porch, or the wind, or nothing at all. I get up anyway and let him out and stand in the yard in my undershirt and listen to the hollow.
It’s quiet down there now. Just trees growing.
If there’s an older person in your life who keeps telling you something strange is going on, and you’ve been telling them they’re imagining it, maybe go sit in the truck with them one night. And if this story meant something to you, share it. Somebody out there needs to hear that being old isn’t the same as being wrong.
Now Trending:
- At My 86th Birthday Dinner, My Son Raised His Glass And Asked, “How Much Longer Are You Going To Sit On Dad’s Money?” His Wife Laughed. The Next Morning I Called My Lawyer
- My New Neighbor Moved The Fence 41 Feet Onto Our Farm And Sent Me A Lawyer’s Letter Saying My Late Husband’s Pear Trees Were His. Then My Old Collie Kept Digging At One Spot Under The Wire Until She Pulled Up The Iron Pin He Swore Was Never There
- My Daughter-In-Law Called While I Was Buying Gifts For My Grandkids And Told Me Not To Come To Christmas. I Said ‘Merry Christmas’ And Drove Somewhere Else. At 7:15 The Next Morning, My Son Was Pounding On My Door About His Late Father’s $31,000
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
