Off The Record
A Rival Tree Grower Reported Our Christmas Tree Farm To The State For Bugs Two Days Before Opening Weekend, And We Lost The Whole Season. Then Our Old Bernese Dragged A Burlap Sack Out Of The Laurel Thicket That Showed Exactly Where Those Bugs Came From
For thirty-eight years, the Friday after Thanksgiving has been the biggest day of my life, and I am including my wedding.
By seven in the morning the cars start lining up on the gravel road below our place in Ashe County, North Carolina, with their headlights still on and their kids asleep in the back seats. By nine the lower field is a parking lot. My husband Clell is up on the hill with his bow saw and his tape measure, and I’m in the shed by the road with the cash box, the hot cider and a stack of paper cups, and our grandson Lemuel is running the baler that wraps the trees in netting so they’ll fit on a car roof. Families walk up and down our rows for an hour hunting the one tree that is theirs, and when they find it they holler for Clell like they’ve struck gold.
We sell about fourteen hundred trees a season. Most of them go out the gate in the four weekends between Thanksgiving and Christmas. It is the money we live on the other eleven months of the year.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →My name is Leora Trivette. I’m seventy. Clell is seventy-four. Our farm is twenty-two acres of Fraser fir on a north-facing slope above Grassy Creek, a few miles from Creston, which is about as far into the northwest corner of the state as you can go without needing a passport for Virginia or Tennessee. Clell planted the first seedlings in 1984 with his own two hands and a dibble bar. You don’t get a Christmas tree in a year. You get one in eight to ten, if the deer don’t eat it and the drought doesn’t kill it and the Lord is in a decent mood.

Moss
Our dog is a Bernese mountain dog named Moss. He’s nine, which is old for a Bernese, and his black face has gone gray around the eyes like he’s been out in the frost. He weighs a hundred and nine pounds and moves like a parked car until somebody drops a ham biscuit.
Moss is part of the farm. Children come back year after year to see him, more than they come for the trees, I sometimes think. He lies by the cider table on opening day with his big rust-colored paws crossed and lets toddlers climb him like a jungle gym. There are families in Winston-Salem and Charlotte with ten years of Christmas cards on their refrigerators, and in every one of them, there’s Moss.
He has one bad habit. He’s a digger and a dragger. If something is lying loose anywhere on the farm, a feed sack, a glove, a length of hose, Moss will find it and drag it back to the porch and lay it at the top of the steps like he’s bringing the mail. Clell calls it the lost and found.
The Man Who Wanted Our Hill
Hoyle Vannoy has the biggest tree operation in the county. Four hundred acres spread over three farms, a packing yard, two tractor trailers and a website. He ships trees to Florida and Texas by the semi-load. He was president of the county growers’ association for the past six years and he’ll tell you about it.
We never had a problem with Hoyle, exactly. He’s sixty-six and he’s a hard worker and he grew up poor, same as us. But our little farm has something his doesn’t. We’re right on the paved road below the Parkway, where the city people come up looking for leaves in October and trees in November. You can see our rows from the car. Hoyle’s farms are all back on gravel roads where nobody drives by.
Three years ago he started a choose-and-cut lot of his own, a mile down the road from us, with a big wooden sign, a hayride, a food truck and a man in a Santa suit. And twice he stopped by our house to offer to buy us out.
The second time, he sat at my kitchen table and said, “Clell, you’re seventy-three years old. How many more years you going to be climbing that hill with a saw? Let me take it off your hands. I’ll pay you fair. You go sit on a beach somewhere.”
Clell said, “I don’t care for sand.”
Hoyle laughed like that was a good joke. When he left, he stood a minute on the porch looking out at our rows, and I didn’t like the way he looked at them. Like a man pricing a cow.
Two Days Before Opening
On the Wednesday before Thanksgiving last year, at about ten in the morning, a white state truck pulled into our lower lot. A young woman got out in a fleece vest and work boots and introduced herself as Dossie Penland, from the North Carolina Department of Agriculture, plant protection section.
She was polite. She was almost sorry about it. She said the department had received a report, with photographs, that our trees were infested with elongate hemlock scale.
I’d heard of it. Every grower up here has. It’s a little insect, smaller than a sesame seed, that lives on the underside of fir needles and sucks the life out of them. It looks like a dusting of white flecks. It spreads easy and it’s hard to kill, and buyers in other states won’t take a tree that has it. It’s the thing growers whisper about at the association meetings.
Clell said, “Not on this farm. I walk every row every week.”
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →Ms. Penland said she’d need to look.
She looked. She went up and down for three hours with a hand lens and a clipboard. And at the bottom of the hill, in the last three rows along the fence line by the laurel thicket, she found it. White flecks on the underside of the needles, thick on some trees, starting on others.
Clell stood there turning a branch over in his hands. I’ve never seen his face like that. He said, “That wasn’t there two weeks ago. I’d swear on my mother.”
She said she believed he believed it. But she had to put a hold on the farm. No trees could be sold or moved off the property until the infested ones were treated and destroyed and a follow-up inspection came back clean. She said a follow-up usually took four to six weeks.
Opening day was Friday. Christmas was in four weeks.
A Season of Locked Gates
We put a chain across the gate. Clell hung a piece of plywood on it that said CLOSED THIS YEAR, SORRY, and I watched him stand in the road a long time after he’d hung it.
On Friday morning the cars came anyway, because people hadn’t heard. I stood at the gate in my yellow barn coat and told them one at a time. Some of them cried. A man from Greensboro who’d bought his tree from us every year since his wedding, and whose wife had died in the spring, sat in his car with his head on the steering wheel. Children asked where Moss was. Moss was standing right beside me at the chain, wagging, wondering why nobody was coming in.
And every one of those cars turned around and drove a mile down the road to Hoyle Vannoy’s choose-and-cut, with the hayride and the food truck and the Santa suit.
We lost about sixty-one thousand dollars that season. That’s not profit. That’s everything.
Our grandson Lemuel, who is nineteen and had taken off from his job at the hardware store in Boone to run the baler for us like he does every year, sat on the porch steps that first Friday night with Moss’s big head in his lap. He said, “Grandpa, I’ll stay through Christmas anyway. I’ll help you cut the bad ones.” Clell said there wasn’t money to pay him. Lemuel said he hadn’t asked to be paid. They spent three weeks of December cutting down and burning the trees at the bottom of the hill, the ones the state had marked with orange paint, and every one of those trees was one Clell had planted with his own hands eight or nine years before. He’d say the year out loud before he cut each one. “2016.” “2017.” Like he was reading names off a stone.
What People Say When a Farm Fails
It got around the county quick, the way things do. The Trivettes let their trees go. Clell’s getting too old to keep up with it. They ought to have sold out when they had the chance.
At the association’s Christmas dinner, which we went to because Clell said we’d never missed one and we weren’t going to start hiding now, Hoyle got up to give his president’s report. He said, with a sad face, that the county had a scale problem “that started on a small operation near Creston,” and that he’d personally offered to help the owners, “good people, older folks,” and that one careless grower could cost every farm in the county its out-of-state buyers.
He didn’t say our name. He didn’t have to. Everybody in that fellowship hall turned around and looked at our table.
Clell got up and walked out to the truck. I sat there and finished my banana pudding, because I was not going to let that man see me leave a dessert.
On the ride home Clell said, “Leora, maybe I did miss it. Maybe my eyes are going.”
I said, “Your eyes are fine.”
He said, “Then where did it come from?”
I didn’t have an answer.
The Lost and Found
The week before Christmas, Moss started going down the hill every morning.
He’d never cared about the bottom of the farm. It’s steep and it’s wet, and old Bernese dogs don’t love steep and wet. But every morning now, right after breakfast, he’d go down through the rows to the laurel thicket along the fence line, where the bad trees had been before the state had us cut and burn them, and he’d be gone an hour.
On the fourth morning, he came back up the hill dragging something.
It took him a long time. It was heavy and it kept catching on stumps, and he’d stop and sit down and pant and then grab it again in his teeth and back up the hill with it. I watched him from the kitchen window the whole way. When he finally got it to the porch, he dropped it at the top of the steps, lay down beside it and looked at me like he’d done something.
It was an old burlap sack, wet and black with mud, tied at the top with orange baling twine.
I untied it. Inside were cut fir branches, maybe twenty of them, each about two feet long, packed tight. And every branch was white underneath. Not dusted. White. Thick with scale, so thick that when I ran my thumb down a twig, it came off on my skin like flour.
I hollered for Clell.
Two Kinds of Fir
Clell came out of the shop and stood over that sack a long time without saying a word. Then he pulled out a branch and held it up in the light and bent one needle back with his thumbnail and smelled it.
He said, “This isn’t ours.”
I said, “What do you mean, it isn’t ours?”
“This isn’t Fraser fir. Look at it. Needles are longer and softer, and they don’t have the silver underneath the same way. Smell it. That’s Canaan fir.”
Some growers up here have been planting Canaan fir the last fifteen years or so, because it holds up better in wet ground where Fraser fir gets root rot. Clell never planted a Canaan fir in his life. He’s stubborn that way. He says a Christmas tree ought to be what it’s always been.
And I knew, because everybody in the county knows, who had a whole wet bottom farm planted in Canaan fir down on the river. And who’d had to burn twenty acres of it two years before because of scale.
Clell put the branch back in the sack very carefully, like it might go off. Then he said, “Leora, go get the flashlight. I’m going down there.”

What Was in the Laurel
We went down the hill together with Moss leading. He went straight into the laurel thicket along the fence line, where you’d have to crawl on your hands and knees, and he started digging at the leaves and pulling.
There were two more sacks. Same burlap. Same orange twine. One of them had been torn open, by Moss probably, and its branches were spread out on the ground. The other was still tied. And just above them, the low limbs of the first row of our trees had pieces of the same orange twine still knotted around them, cut off short. Somebody had hung those branches in our trees, right up against our needles, so the little crawling young of the scale would walk right across onto our trees. Then later, somebody had come back, cut them down and stuffed them in sacks and pushed them into the laurel where nobody would ever look.
Nobody but a nine-year-old dog who could smell something that didn’t belong.
Clell sat down on the wet ground in the laurel. He’s seventy-four and his knees are bad, and he sat right down in the mud, and I thought he was going to be sick. Instead he started laughing, a strange tired laugh, and he said, “My eyes are fine.”
Calling the Right People
The next morning we called Ferrel Huckabee, who’s been the county extension agent for twenty-five years and who taught Clell’s Sunday school class for ten of them. He came out with his truck and looked at the sacks and the twine on our branches and took a lot of pictures. Then he called Dossie Penland at the state.
She drove back up two days before Christmas. She took the sacks, the branches, the twine and samples of the scale in little glass jars. She photographed everything. She asked us a hundred questions about who’d been on our property and when.
Then she asked us something I didn’t expect. She asked if we’d ever seen the photographs that came with the original report.
We hadn’t. Nobody had ever shown them to us.
She opened a folder on the hood of her truck and laid them out. Five pictures of fir branches, white with scale, that were supposedly taken on our farm. The report said they were taken from the road along our lower fence, by “a concerned grower.”
Clell picked up the first photograph and looked at it for maybe two seconds. Then he handed it to her and said, “Ma’am, that’s a Canaan fir.”
She looked at it. She looked at the branches in the sack. She looked at the photograph again. And then she sat down on her tailgate.
The man who reported us had sent the state pictures of his own branches. The same branches. He’d been so sure nobody would ever look close that he didn’t even bother taking pictures of the right tree.
The Report and the Reporter
It took the state until March to finish the investigation. The report had come in by email from an account that turned out not to be very anonymous. It belonged to a young man who worked in Hoyle Vannoy’s packing yard, who, when an investigator sat down with him at his mother’s kitchen table, told them Hoyle had asked him to send it “as a favor,” because Hoyle “didn’t want to look like he was going after the competition.”
The orange twine was the kind Hoyle bought by the pallet for his wholesale operation. The burlap sacks were the ones his crew used to haul cuttings out of the burned field on the river. And when the state checked the scale itself, they found it matched what had been on Hoyle’s Canaan fir two years earlier, including the fact that it had already been treated once with a chemical we’ve never used on our farm.
North Carolina has a law against knowingly spreading a plant pest. Most people have never heard of it, because almost nobody is fool enough to do it on purpose. Hoyle Vannoy was charged under it. The association removed him as president at a meeting in April. I’m told it took four minutes.
What He Said
Hoyle came to our house one time, in May, after his lawyer had told him to settle.
He stood on the porch and didn’t take his cap off. Moss lay at the top of the steps and looked at him and didn’t get up, which for Moss is the same as a growl.
Hoyle said, “I never meant for it to get that bad. I figured you’d lose a few trees and get discouraged. I figured you’d sell.”
Clell said, “You figured I’d sell.”
“You’re seventy-four, Clell.”
Clell said, “I’m aware of how old I am, Hoyle. I’ve been here for all of it.”
He settled for the lost season, the cost of the trees the state had made us destroy, and our lawyer’s fees, which came to a little over ninety thousand dollars all told. He also had to pay a fine to the state, and he is on probation, and he has had a harder time than he expected selling trees to buyers in Florida who read the newspaper.
He sold his choose-and-cut lot down the road in August. The man who bought it took down the Santa sign.

The Old Man From Greensboro
We opened this year on the Friday after Thanksgiving, same as always. The chain came off the gate at seven in the morning.
The cars were lined up at six-thirty. The man from Greensboro was the first one through the gate. He’d driven up the night before and slept in his car. He walked right past the cider table and knelt down in the gravel and put both his arms around Moss, and he said, “We missed you, old fella,” and Moss leaned his whole hundred and nine pounds against him and nearly knocked him over.
People had heard by then. Not every word of it, but enough. A woman from Charlotte brought a framed picture of her three kids with Moss from 2017 and asked if she could hang it in the cider shed. I said yes. Now there are eleven of them in there.
Ferrel Huckabee came out and bought a tree, and so did Dossie Penland, who drove four hours on her day off with her husband and said it was the first real tree she’d ever cut.
Moss lies by the cider table with his paws crossed, same as he always did. When he gets tired, he goes and lies on the porch beside the lost and found. There’s an old glove in it right now, and a child’s mitten somebody lost in the rows, and a dog toy that isn’t his.
Clell still walks every row every week. He takes Moss with him, and when they get to the bottom of the hill, by the laurel, Moss always stops and puts his nose in it for a minute, just to check.
If someone you love has been made to feel like they’re too old to know their own business, pass this along to them. Sometimes the people who know the land best are the ones who’ve been walking it the longest. And if you’ve got a dog who drags strange things home, go take a look before you throw them out.
Now Trending:
- My Sister-In-Law Swore She Hadn’t Seen Our Lost Dog Since The Ice Storm And Told The Whole Family I’d Let Him Out On Purpose. At Christmas Eve Dinner My Husband Stood Up, Whistled The Two Notes His Mother Used To Call Him In From The Field, And Something Started Scratching Behind Her Bedroom Door
- The Gas Station Clerk Told My 77-Year-Old Husband His Lottery Ticket Was A Loser And Dropped It In The Trash. Two Weeks Later The Clerk Claimed $1.3 Million, And The Lottery Investigator Wanted To Know Why The Winning Ticket Had Tooth Marks In It
- The Mechanic Kept My Late Husband’s 1971 Pickup For “Unpaid Storage,” Got A Title From The State And Sold It While I Was Still Grieving. At The Fall Car Show, Our Old Weimaraner Jumped Into The Truck Bed And Wouldn’t Let The New Owner Near It
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
