Connect with us

The Mechanic Kept My Late Husband’s 1971 Pickup For “Unpaid Storage,” Got A Title From The State And Sold It While I Was Still Grieving. At The Fall Car Show, Our Old Weimaraner Jumped Into The Truck Bed And Wouldn’t Let The New Owner Near It

Off The Record

The Mechanic Kept My Late Husband’s 1971 Pickup For “Unpaid Storage,” Got A Title From The State And Sold It While I Was Still Grieving. At The Fall Car Show, Our Old Weimaraner Jumped Into The Truck Bed And Wouldn’t Let The New Owner Near It

My husband Alphus bought a brand-new pickup truck in the spring of 1971, two-tone, pale green on the bottom and white on top, with a bench seat and a three-speed on the column. He was twenty years old and had saved for it for two years hauling hay and pumping gas. He paid cash. He drove it home to his mama’s house and she came out on the porch and said it looked like a pickle.

It was the Pickle for fifty-three years.

He courted me in that truck. He drove me to the hospital in Sparta in it twice to have our boys. He hauled every load of firewood, every calf, every Christmas tree and every bag of feed this family ever owned in the back of it. He rebuilt the engine himself in 1988 on a Saturday in the barn with the radio on. He never once let it sit outside a night when it was going to freeze.

My name is Burnice Shoemake. I’m seventy-one years old. We lived our whole married life on sixty acres along the Calfkiller River in White County, Tennessee, on the edge of the plateau where the land starts to roll up toward Crossville. Alphus drove a milk truck for thirty years and then a school bus for ten more. I worked in the lunchroom at the elementary school, so for ten years we went to work at the same place and came home at the same time, and people said it was the sweetest thing they’d ever seen, and some days it was.

Smoke

You can’t talk about the Pickle without talking about Smoke.

Smoke is a Weimaraner, silver-gray all over like a cloud with legs, with pale yellow eyes that look right through you. He’s ten now. Our younger son, Fenton, brought him home as a puppy from a man in Monterey, and Fenton moved to Nashville the next year for work and Smoke stayed with us, and that was the end of any question about whose dog he was.

He was Alphus’s shadow. And the Pickle was where they lived.

Every morning for ten years Alphus would walk out to that truck with his coffee, and Smoke would already be standing in the bed waiting for him with his front feet up on the side rail, like a sailor at the front of a ship. They went to the feed store and the co-op and the post office and the Hardee’s in Sparta where the old men sit, and Smoke rode in the back every mile, nose in the wind, ears blowing straight back. Every fall Alphus entered the Pickle in the car show on the courthouse square, and every year Smoke stood in the bed the whole day and let children pet him and got his picture in the paper more than the truck did.

There’s a place in the bed of that truck, right up behind the cab on the passenger side, where the paint is scratched down to the metal in a circle about the size of a dinner plate. That’s where Smoke lay down when he got tired. Ten years of toenails.

The Spring Alphus Died

In February of last year, the Pickle started slipping out of second gear. Alphus said it needed the transmission rebuilt and he was too old to lie on a cold floor and do it. So he took it to Cullen Brickey’s garage out on the Doyle highway.

Cullen had been working on cars in White County for twenty years. He was about fifty, a big friendly man who went to the Methodist church and coached Little League and kept a jar of suckers on his counter for kids. Alphus liked him. They talked engines for an hour every time.

Cullen said the transmission would be about thirty-two hundred dollars and he’d need to order parts. On March the 3rd, I drove Alphus out there and he paid eighteen hundred dollars cash as a deposit, and Cullen wrote him out a receipt on a page torn off a yellow pad.

Two weeks later, on the 17th of March, Alphus died in his chair after supper with Smoke lying across his feet. He was seventy-four. The doctor said he probably didn’t feel a thing. I’ve decided to believe him.

“Take Your Time, Miss Burnice”

I don’t remember much about that spring. I know there was a funeral, and I know Fenton and our older son stayed a week, and I know the church ladies brought so much food I gave four casseroles to the neighbors’ hogs.

What I do remember is Smoke. He would not come in the house. He lay in the empty spot in the barn where the Pickle used to be parked, every day and every night, with his chin on his paws, and I’d carry his food out there to him. In April it rained for a week, and he lay out there through all of it.

Sometime in April, Cullen Brickey called the house. He said the transmission was done. He said he was so sorry for my loss and that Alphus was one of the good ones.

I told him I couldn’t come get it yet. I said I couldn’t stand to see it.

He said, “Miss Burnice, you take all the time you need. It’ll be right here in the back of the shop. Don’t you worry about a thing.”

I thanked him and cried after I hung up. I thought he was the kindest man in the county.

Six Months Later

It was the end of September before I felt like I could do it. Fenton came down from Nashville to drive me. I brought Smoke, because I thought it might help him, and I brought my checkbook to pay the rest of the bill.

The Pickle wasn’t in the back of the shop. It wasn’t anywhere.

Cullen came out from under a car wiping his hands on a red rag and didn’t look me in the eye. He said, “Miss Burnice, I sent you letters.”

I said, “What letters?”

He said the truck had sat in his shop for months without anybody paying for it. He said that under Tennessee law, a garage that does work on a vehicle and doesn’t get paid has a lien on it, and he’d charged storage, thirty-five dollars a day, and the bill had come to more than eight thousand dollars. He said he’d sent certified letters to my house, and when nobody paid, he’d filed the papers with the state, got a title in his own name and sold the truck at a sale in August.

I said, “Cullen, you told me to take my time.”

He said, “I don’t remember saying that, ma’am.”

I said, “My husband paid you eighteen hundred dollars in cash. I was standing right there.”

He said, “I don’t have any record of that.”

Smoke was standing in the gravel next to me. He walked over to the empty corner of the lot where the cars wait for parts, and he sniffed every inch of it, and then he sat down there and looked at me.

Paper Beats Grief

Fenton took me to see a lawyer in Sparta, a woman named Osie Wimberly who’d been in practice forty years and had handled our wills.

She called the state and got copies of Cullen’s lien paperwork. It was all there. A sworn statement from Cullen that the owner of the vehicle had abandoned it, that no payment of any kind had been received, that no agreement existed regarding storage. Copies of two certified letters to my address. And the little green cards that come back when somebody signs for a certified letter. Both of them signed “B. Shoemake.”

I looked at those signatures a long time. They didn’t look anything like mine. I said so.

Mrs. Wimberly said she believed me. But she said it was my word against a sworn statement, a state title and two signed cards, and the truck had been sold to a buyer who’d paid in good faith. She said a case like that could take years and cost more than the truck was worth. She asked if I had the receipt for the eighteen hundred dollars.

I didn’t. Alphus kept every receipt he ever got. But he kept them all in one place.

The glove box of the Pickle.

What People Say About a Widow

You’d think people would be on your side. Some were. But Cullen had been coaching their children for twenty years, and he told everybody his version first. He said he’d tried and tried to reach me. He said he felt terrible. He said grief does things to people’s memories, and he didn’t hold it against me.

A woman in my Sunday school class patted my hand and said, “Burnice, honey, you were in a fog that whole spring. We all saw it.”

I was in a fog. That’s the trouble. I couldn’t swear I hadn’t missed a letter. I couldn’t swear I hadn’t signed something. The only thing I could swear to was that I’d stood in that garage and watched my husband count out eighteen one-hundred-dollar bills on the counter, and that nobody seemed to care.

Fenton said, gently, “Mama, it’s a truck. Maybe let it go.”

I said I would think about it. I meant it, too. I’d about decided to let it go.

That night I sat out in the barn with Smoke in the empty spot where the Pickle used to park. There’s still an oil stain on the concrete there the shape of Kentucky. Smoke lay with his chin on it. I told him out loud that I was sorry, that I’d tried, that his truck was gone and it wasn’t coming back. He didn’t lift his head. I don’t know what I expected. He’s a dog. But I sat there until my feet went numb, and when I finally got up to go in the house, he didn’t follow me. He stayed with the oil stain.

I lay awake most of that night thinking about the way Cullen had said, “I don’t remember saying that, ma’am.” Not angry. Not nervous. Patient, the way you’d talk to a child who’d gotten confused. That was the part that stuck in me like a splinter. He’d already decided what I was. He’d decided it before I ever walked onto his lot.

The Courthouse Square

The car show on the courthouse square is the second Saturday in October. I didn’t plan to go. It was the first one in twenty-six years without Alphus, and I meant to stay home.

But that morning Smoke went and stood by the door of my car and wouldn’t move, and so I drove him to town. I told myself it was for him.

I parked by the bank and walked him around the square on his leash. All the old trucks were lined up on the grass under the maples, hoods up, chrome shining. People I’d known forty years stopped me and hugged me and said they missed seeing Alphus there.

We were about halfway around when Smoke stopped dead.

Then he pulled that leash right out of my hand. He went across the grass at a dead run, ten years old and stiff in the hips, and with one jump he cleared the side of a truck and landed in the bed. He walked straight up to the front of the bed behind the cab, on the passenger side, turned around three times, and lay down right on top of a circle of scratched metal about the size of a dinner plate.

It was the Pickle. Pale green and white. Somebody had polished her up so she shone like a new dime and put whitewall tires on her. But it was the Pickle.

Waymon Mabe

The man standing beside the truck was about fifty-five, in a navy windbreaker, and he was not happy.

He said, “Ma’am, is this your dog? Ma’am, he’s going to scratch the paint.”

I couldn’t talk. I put my hand on Smoke’s neck and the other one on my chest and just stood there.

The man reached into the bed to take Smoke by the collar, and Smoke didn’t growl, didn’t bite. He just flattened himself down on that spot and looked up at the man with those yellow eyes and didn’t move one inch. The man tried twice. Then he stood back with his hands on his hips.

A crowd had started gathering. Somebody said, “That’s Alphus Shoemake’s old truck. That’s his dog.”

The man looked at the dog. Then he looked at me. Then he said, in a different voice, “Are you Burnice?”

I said I was.

He said, “Wait right here.”

The Binder

His name was Waymon Mabe and he was from out near Monterey, and he’d bought the Pickle at the August auction for twenty-four thousand dollars. He was a collector. He’d restored eleven old pickups in his life, and he was the kind of collector who keeps everything. He went to his own truck and came back with a three-ring binder, and in it, in plastic sleeves, was every scrap of paper he’d found in the Pickle.

The original window sticker from 1971. Alphus’s oil change receipts going back to the Nixon administration. A church bulletin from 1983. A drawing of the truck one of our boys did in crayon in second grade.

And a page torn off a yellow pad.

Waymon said, “I found this in the glove box and I didn’t know what it was. I kept it because it had the truck on it.”

It said, in Cullen Brickey’s handwriting:

“Rec’d $1,800 cash from Alphus Shoemake toward trans rebuild, ’71 pickup. Balance $1,400 when done. No storage charge, take as long as needed. C. Brickey. 3/3.”

Alphus had put it in the glove box when we got home that day, like he did every receipt he ever got. And Cullen had sold the truck without ever looking inside it.

Two Other Families

Waymon Mabe drove to Sparta with me that same afternoon and sat in Mrs. Wimberly’s office while she made copies. I think he was madder than I was. He said, “I paid that man twenty-four thousand dollars for a stolen truck, and I’ve put nine thousand more into it.”

Mrs. Wimberly sent everything to the district attorney and to the state office that handles vehicle titles. Once they started looking, they found that Cullen Brickey had filed lien titles on three other vehicles in five years. One belonged to an old bachelor in Doyle who’d gone into a nursing home. One belonged to a man whose wife said he’d paid in full and had a canceled check to prove it. Every one of them had certified mail cards signed by somebody who wasn’t the owner.

The bachelor’s niece called me a week after it was in the paper. She lived in Chattanooga. She said her uncle had owned a little red tractor he’d bought new in 1966, and he’d taken it to Cullen for a clutch, and then he’d fallen and gone into the home, and by the time she came up to see about his things, the tractor was gone and Cullen said the same thing he’d said to me. She’d believed him. She said, “I thought I must have missed something. I thought it was my fault.” I told her I knew exactly how that felt. We talked for over an hour. Her uncle’s tractor turned up at a farm in Alabama, and she got it back in June.

A handwriting examiner from Nashville compared the “B. Shoemake” on those green cards with Cullen’s handwriting on the yellow receipt. It wasn’t close. It was him.

Cullen Brickey was charged with forgery and with filing false statements with the state.

I went to the first hearing in the courthouse in Sparta, the same courthouse whose lawn the Pickle had been parked on. Cullen wore a suit that didn’t fit him across the shoulders. When he walked past me in the hall, he stopped and said, “Miss Burnice, I hope you know I never meant anything personal by it.”

I said, “Cullen, you signed my name.”

He didn’t have anything to say to that. He went on into the courtroom. His lawyer did most of the talking after that, and none of it was to me.

He pled guilty in the spring. He lost his garage. He doesn’t coach Little League anymore.

What Belongs to Who

The judge voided Cullen’s title. Under the law, the Pickle was mine again. And Cullen was ordered to pay back the twenty-four thousand dollars to Waymon Mabe.

But Waymon had put nine thousand dollars of his own money into restoring her, and I knew it. Whitewalls, new paint on the body, a new headliner, the seat recovered in the same green vinyl Alphus had picked in 1971. He’d done it right. He’d done it the way Alphus would have.

So we sat down at my kitchen table and worked it out. I paid him back for his parts out of Alphus’s insurance money. He wouldn’t take a dime for his labor. He said, “Mrs. Shoemake, I’ve never once had a dog tell me whose truck I was standing next to. That’s payment enough.”

We made one more deal. Every October, Waymon drives the Pickle in the car show. He picks her up the night before and brings her home after. And Smoke rides in the back.

One thing he didn’t touch. He never painted the bed. He said he’d thought about it, and he’d stood looking at that scratched circle behind the cab for a long time and decided it belonged there.

Learning the Three-on-the-Tree

I never drove the Pickle in fifty-three years. Alphus always drove.

This spring, Fenton came down from Nashville for a long weekend and taught me. First gear is down and toward you. Second is up and away. Third is straight down. The clutch is heavier than you’d think. I stalled her eleven times in the pasture and Smoke sat in the bed through every one of them like he was supervising.

Now I drive her to the feed store on Saturdays. I’m the slowest thing on the Doyle highway. People honk and wave.

Some nights, when I can’t sleep, I go out to the barn and sit behind the wheel in the dark with the door open. Smoke comes and climbs up on the bench seat beside me and puts his head on my shoulder, right where Alphus’s shoulder used to be. We don’t go anywhere. We just sit.

If you know a widow or widower who’s been told their memory can’t be trusted, sit with them a while and take them at their word. And if somebody you love kept every receipt they ever got, don’t throw out a single one. Pass this story along to someone who needs the reminder.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family

Continue Reading

Jason is a writer and storyteller who focuses on the human side of the stories — moments of kindness, resilience, family, and the turning points that quietly change a life. He writes to inform, engage, and inspire, and believes the best stories are the ones that make readers feel less alone.