Off The Record
My 8-Year-Old Was Sent Out Of Class For Her Blue Hair. The Next Day She Took Off Her Jacket And The Whole Room Froze
The school office called me at 1:52 on a Monday afternoon.
“Mrs. Lindquist? Isla’s okay,” the secretary said, which is the sentence that makes every mother’s heart stop. “But could you come pick her up? She’s very upset.”
I’m a physical therapist. I left a man named Gary on a table with an ice pack on his new knee and told him I’d be right back. I was not right back.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →When I came through the front doors of the elementary school, I saw her before she saw me.
She was on the wooden bench outside the principal’s office, all by herself. Her yellow backpack was still on her shoulders. Her cheek was resting on her hand, her bright blue hair was falling over her face in a messy curtain, and she was crying the hiccupy way kids cry when they’ve been trying very hard not to.

I knelt down in front of her right there on the tile.
“Baby. Hey. I’m here.”
She looked up. Her eyes were red, and her black nail polish was chipped where she had been picking at it.
“Mommy,” she said, “they said I look like a monster.”
I would love to tell you I stayed calm. On the inside, I was ready to take that building apart brick by brick.
On the outside, I wiped her face with my sleeve and said, “Who said that?”
She looked down at the floor.
“Everybody laughed,” she whispered. “And then Mrs. Petrakis made me leave.”
She had begged me for blue hair for five months, and that Saturday I finally said yes
Isla is eight. She’s in third grade. She collects smooth rocks and draws dragons on everything, and she has never once in her life wanted to look like anybody else.
It’s just the two of us, most of the time. Her dad lives in Oregon and calls on Sundays. So when she wants something, she usually wants it from me, and she knows exactly how to ask.
Since the summer, she had been asking for blue hair. She didn’t want a streak. She wanted all of it, bright blue, like the deep end of the pool at the Y.
I said what mothers say. Maybe next summer. Maybe when you’re older. Let’s see how you feel at Christmas.
She asked every week. She made me a card with a blue-haired girl on the front and the word PLEASE written inside in twelve different markers.
In the middle of October, after a long week at the clinic, I looked at her across the dinner table and thought, why not? It’s hair. It grows. She’s only going to be eight once.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →So on Saturday morning we drove to the beauty supply store and came home with a jar of bright blue semi-permanent dye and a bleach kit for the ends. We spread old towels all over the bathroom. Isla sat on the closed toilet lid in one of my old T-shirts, kicking her feet and singing, while I followed the instructions the girl at the store had written on the back of the receipt.
It took four hours. My bathroom grout is still a little blue.
When I finally rinsed it and blew it dry, she climbed onto the step stool in front of the mirror and didn’t say anything for a long time.
Then she put both hands on her cheeks.
“Mommy. I look like me.”
I had to go stand in the hallway for a minute after that.
She wore it down to the grocery store, to the park and to Sunday dinner at my mom’s. My mother, who is seventy-one and goes to Mass every morning, studied it for a long moment and said, “Well, it’s very cheerful.” Then she told Isla she looked like a little mermaid, which was the best review we could have hoped for.
The black nails and the giant denim jacket were her idea, and I checked the school rules twice
On Sunday night, she asked for black nail polish. I said fine. She painted them herself at the kitchen table with her tongue between her teeth, and she got some on her knuckles, and she didn’t care one bit.
Then she went to her closet and got out the jacket.
The jacket deserves its own paragraph. It’s an old oversized denim jacket we found at a thrift store last spring for four dollars, a grown-up’s medium. On Isla, the sleeves hang past her fingertips unless she rolls them twice, and the hem comes nearly to her knees. She wears it to school, to the library and to the dentist. She tried to wear it to bed once.
Before I went to sleep, I did one practical thing, because I’m a practical person. I pulled up the school handbook on my phone and read the dress code. Twice.
It said nothing about hair color. It said nothing about nail polish. It said shirts needed sleeves and shoes needed backs.
I went to bed feeling good. I thought we had done everything right.
On Monday it was chilly, so she wore her gray hoodie and left the jacket on the hook by the door.
By two o’clock she was crying on a bench.
A boy called her a witch, and her teacher sent her out of the room for being a distraction
The principal, Mr. Delgado, brought us into his office and shut the door. He is a tall, tired man with reading glasses on a cord around his neck, and to his credit, he looked miserable about the whole thing.
He told me what had happened.
During morning reading, a boy in Isla’s class named Wyatt had looked at her and said, loud enough for everyone to hear, “She looks like a witch.” A few kids laughed. Then a few more. Somebody made a cackling noise. By lunch, three of them were calling her Monster Hair.
Isla didn’t fight back. She just put her hood up.
After lunch, her teacher, Mrs. Petrakis, told her to take the hood down, because hoods aren’t allowed in class. When Isla did, two kids started cackling again. And Mrs. Petrakis, instead of dealing with the kids who were cackling, walked Isla to the office.
“She said my hair was distracting,” Isla told me in a small voice. “She said I could come back when my mom did something about it.”
I looked at Mr. Delgado. “Is there a rule against blue hair?”
“There isn’t,” he said.
“Then why is my daughter the one sitting in the hallway?”
He took his glasses off. “That’s a fair question, Mrs. Lindquist. I’m going to look into it. I promise you that.”
Here’s the strange part. I had met Mrs. Petrakis at Back-to-School night in August, and I had liked her. Her first name is Dina. It turned out we had graduated the same year from North Ridge High, across town, though we ran in completely different crowds and I barely remembered her. We laughed about what a small world it was. She seemed organized and a little strict, the kind of teacher who has a labeled bin for everything.
I couldn’t make that woman fit with the one who had sent my crying daughter out of her classroom.
I signed Isla out, and we drove home without the radio on.
That night she sat on her bedroom floor and repainted every single nail
She wouldn’t eat dinner. I made macaroni and cheese, which is her favorite food in the world, and she pushed it around her plate and asked to be excused.
An hour later, I went to check on her.
She was sitting on her bedroom floor with her back against the bed, the bottle of black polish open on a paper towel, carefully repainting her nails. Every one. She had picked half of them off on that bench, and now she was fixing them, slowly, one stroke at a time, with her tongue between her teeth.
I sat down on the carpet next to her.
“You could take it off, if you want,” I said. “I’ve got remover. And we can wash some of the blue out. It’s semi-permanent. Nobody would blame you.”
She shook her head without looking up.
“I can’t change them, Mommy.”
“Why not, sweetheart?”
She thought about it for a long time, the way she does.
“Because then they’d be right,” she said. “And they’re not right.”
I didn’t trust my voice, so I just nodded.
She blew on her nails. Then she said, “Can I wear my jacket tomorrow?”
“Of course you can.”
“And if Mrs. Petrakis tells me to take it off?”
I looked at her, my eight-year-old with her blue hair and her careful black nails, and I said the only thing I could think of.
“Then tell her to call me.”
She nodded very seriously, like we had just signed a contract.
After she brushed her teeth, I sat at the kitchen table and wrote Mrs. Petrakis an email. It was four paragraphs long and very angry, and it used the word unacceptable three times.
I read it over twice. Then I deleted it.
I wanted to be fair. Mr. Delgado had promised to look into it, and I had liked this woman in August. I decided to give the school one day. One day, and then I would write the email again, and this time I would send it.
Later, when I went to bed, I saw a line of light under her door. I figured she was reading under the covers. I let it go.
I almost knocked.

The next morning she was strangely calm, and she wouldn’t let me see her T-shirt
On Tuesday morning, Isla was already dressed when I came into the kitchen. She was eating cereal. She had brushed her blue hair herself and put it into two crooked braids.
She had the denim jacket on, buttoned all the way to the top, with the sleeves rolled down to her fingertips.
“Aren’t you hot in that?” I asked.
“No.”
“What shirt are you wearing under there?”
“A shirt,” she said.
I reached over to undo the top button, just to look, and she leaned back out of my reach so fast she nearly tipped her chair.
“Mommy. It’s a surprise.”
There was something stiff in her left sleeve. I could see the outline of it when she lifted her spoon. When I asked, she just said, “It’s for later,” and went back to her cereal.
I had patients starting at eight. I didn’t push. At the drop-off line, I kissed the top of her blue head and said, “Remember. If anything happens, they call me.”
“I know,” she said, and climbed out of the car with her yellow backpack bouncing.
She didn’t look scared. That’s what I remember most. She looked like someone with a plan.
At 10:17 the next morning, the principal called and told me to come right now
At 10:17 a.m., I was helping a woman named Patrice do heel slides on a therapy table when my phone buzzed in the pocket of my scrubs.
Mr. Delgado.
I stepped out into the hallway.
“Mrs. Lindquist, you need to come to the school right now,” he said. There was noise behind him, a lot of voices. “It’s Isla.”
“Is she hurt?”
“No. No, she’s not hurt. She, um. She took off her jacket in front of the whole class.”
That was all he said before somebody called his name and he had to hang up.
I don’t remember the drive. Eleven minutes. I know I went through at least one yellow light that was more red than yellow. My mind went to every terrible place a mother’s mind can go. Had somebody grabbed her? Was there something under that jacket I should have known about? What on earth had she hidden in that sleeve?
I parked crooked in the visitor spot and ran.
When I ran into the hallway, her teacher was crying and my daughter was pointing right at her
The third-grade hallway was full of grown-ups.
Two teachers from the classrooms next door. The school counselor. The lunch aide. They were standing outside Room 12 in a little cluster, and when I came around the corner, they all turned to look at me at once.
The classroom door was propped open.
Isla’s denim jacket lay on the floor just inside the doorway, in a heap, one sleeve turned inside out.
Mrs. Petrakis was standing by the whiteboard with both hands over her face. Her shoulders were shaking. She was crying so hard she couldn’t speak.
Mr. Delgado stood beside her, holding something in his hand. A folded piece of paper, creased into a small square, exactly the size that would fit inside a sleeve.
Twenty-three third-graders sat at their desks in total silence. I have never in my life heard a third-grade classroom that quiet.
And in the middle of the room, standing beside her own desk in a white T-shirt, with her blue braids hanging down her back, was my daughter.
She saw me. She didn’t run to me.
She just raised one arm and pointed straight at her teacher.
The folded paper in her sleeve was a page from my own high-school yearbook
Mr. Delgado walked over and handed me the paper.
It was a color photocopy, folded eight times. I opened it with shaking fingers.
It was a page from my senior yearbook at North Ridge High, the Senior Superlatives page. Best Smile. Most Likely to Succeed. Class Clown.
In the corner was a photo of a skinny seventeen-year-old girl with bright blue hair, chopped short and messy. Black nail polish. A huge denim jacket covered in pins and patches, the sleeves hanging past her hands. She was grinning at the camera like she owned the world.
The caption under the photo said: Most Original. Dina Marsh.
Dina Marsh, who married a man named Petrakis and became a third-grade teacher.
I looked up at Isla. “Where did you get this?”
“Your yearbook,” she said. “In the hall closet. You said you went to school with Mrs. Petrakis, so I looked for her.” She shrugged. “She had blue hair. Bluer than mine.”
So that was the line of light under her door. My eight-year-old had pulled a yearbook out of the hall closet, turned pages on her bedroom floor until she found the right face, and figured out the copy button on our printer at eleven o’clock at night.
The lunch aide, who had been in the room, told me the rest.
At morning meeting, Mrs. Petrakis had asked Isla to take off her jacket, because jackets aren’t worn in class. Isla said, “Okay,” walked to the front of the room, took it off and dropped it on the floor.
Underneath was a white T-shirt she had decorated herself with fabric markers. Blue stars all over it, and two words across the front in big, careful letters: Be You.
Then she pulled the folded paper out of her sleeve, opened it up and held it high for the whole class to see.
“This is Mrs. Petrakis when she was in high school,” she said. “She had blue hair and black nails and a big jacket, like me. They voted her Most Original.”
Then she turned around and looked up at her teacher.
“You were a monster too,” she said. “And you turned out nice.”
My daughter’s teacher knelt down in front of the whole class and told them the truth
Mrs. Petrakis took her hands away from her face. Her mascara had run all the way down her cheeks. She looked at me standing in the doorway, and then she did something I didn’t expect.
She knelt down on the classroom carpet, right in front of Isla, so they were eye to eye.
“Isla,” she said, and her voice cracked. “I am so sorry. I was wrong yesterday. I was very, very wrong.”
Isla nodded seriously.
Then Mrs. Petrakis stood up and turned to the class, wiping her face with the back of her hand.
“I want to tell all of you something,” she said. “When I was in high school, I dyed my hair blue in my mother’s bathroom sink. And kids were mean to me. They called me Smurf. They called me freak. One morning someone wrote something ugly on my locker in marker, and I had to scrub it off before first period.”
Twenty-three kids stared at her.
“My mom made me dye it brown again before graduation, because she said nobody would ever hire a girl with blue hair. And I guess I got so busy being a grown-up that I forgot how it felt to be the kid in the hallway.”
She looked at Wyatt, who had turned red to the tips of his ears.
“Yesterday I made Isla feel exactly the way those kids made me feel. That wasn’t okay. Nobody in this room gets called a witch or a monster for how they look. That includes me, it includes Isla, and it includes every one of you.”
Then she looked down at my daughter again.
“Thank you for reminding me who I used to be,” she said. “I liked her. I’d like to be her again.”
Isla walked over and hugged her around the waist.
In the back of the room, a little girl with glasses started clapping. Then two more kids. Then the whole class.
Mr. Delgado had to take off his glasses and clean them for a long time.
In the empty classroom at lunchtime, Dina and I finally talked like two old classmates
Isla went to lunch with her friends that day, holding hands with two of them. She left her jacket on the floor and forgot about it completely.
I stayed. Dina made us two cups of terrible coffee from the machine in the teachers’ lounge, and we sat in tiny third-grade chairs with our knees up near our chins.
“I don’t even have a good excuse,” she said. “Last year a parent complained that a boy’s mohawk was distracting the class. It turned into a whole thing. Meetings, emails, a note in my file. So when I saw the kids laughing at Isla yesterday, I panicked. I thought, if I get her out of the room, the problem goes away.”
“The problem was the kids laughing,” I said.
“I know. I knew it by the time I got home.” She stared into her cup. “I almost called you last night. I didn’t know what to say.”
I told her I barely remembered her from high school. I had been on the swim team and spent senior year smelling like chlorine and worrying about college applications.
She laughed. “I remember you. You lent me a pencil in chemistry once, and you didn’t make fun of my hair.”
“That’s a low bar, Dina.”
“It was a low year,” she said.
Before I left, she asked if she could keep the photocopy. I told her she would have to ask Isla.
Isla said yes, as long as Mrs. Petrakis put it somewhere nice.
The next morning, it was taped to the corner of her desk.
The boy who called her a witch asked her for the strangest favor a few weeks later
Wyatt’s mother called me that night, mortified. The next day Wyatt gave Isla an apology card written in pencil. It said he was sorry he called her a witch, and that he actually thought her hair was the color of a superhero’s suit, and he just didn’t know how to say that.
That same week, Mrs. Petrakis took an idea to Mr. Delgado. By November, the school had something called Come As You Are Fridays. On Fridays, kids can wear whatever makes them feel most like themselves, as long as it’s school-appropriate. Capes. Mismatched socks. Tutus over jeans. One boy wore a fishing vest with about forty pockets for three months straight.
On the very first Come As You Are Friday, Mrs. Petrakis walked into Room 12 wearing an enormous old denim jacket covered in pins and patches.
She had kept it in a box in her basement for twenty years.
The kids lost their minds. Isla came home that afternoon so excited she could barely get the words out.
Then, the week before winter break, the school held Superhero Day. Wyatt came up to Isla’s desk that morning, shuffling his feet, holding a little bottle of blue nail polish his mom had bought him.
“Can you paint my nails?” he asked. “My guy has blue hands. You’re the only one who’s good at it.”
Isla painted all ten of them, with her tongue between her teeth.
They’re friends now, more or less. The kind of eight-year-old friends who argue about dragons at recess and then split a pack of fruit snacks.

On the last day of school, her teacher walked into class with a surprise in her hair
Over the winter, Isla’s blue faded to a soft teal and then to something like seafoam, and in March she asked to do it again. We did. My grout is a lost cause.
On the last day of school in June, I took the morning off to help with the class party.
Mrs. Petrakis walked in at eight o’clock with her dark hair in a ponytail, and right at the front, tucked behind one ear, was a single bright blue streak.
Isla shrieked. The whole class shrieked.
“I did it in my bathroom sink,” Dina told me, grinning. “Just like old times. My husband thinks I’ve lost my mind.”
“How does it feel?”
She touched the streak and thought about it.
“Like me,” she said.
That afternoon I took a picture of the two of them side by side by the sunny classroom window, both with blue in their hair, laughing so hard that Isla’s braids were swinging. It’s on our refrigerator now, next to Isla’s report card. At the bottom of the card, in Mrs. Petrakis’s neat handwriting, it says: Isla taught me more this year than I taught her.
Isla had her own surprise for the end of the year. She had saved her allowance for three weeks, and when the party was over, she handed Mrs. Petrakis a small paper bag. Inside was a bottle of black nail polish and a card with a blue-haired girl on the front.
Dina opened it, laughed, and then had to step into the hallway for a minute. I knew exactly how she felt.
That night Isla fell asleep in her denim jacket, which happens more often than I like to admit.
I stood in her doorway for a while and looked at the blue hair spread across her pillow.
I’m so glad I didn’t knock that night.
Now Trending:
- My Sister-In-Law Demanded $30,000 For A Yacht Party. I Sent Her $60, And My Husband Threw My Suitcase Down The Steps Of The House I Own
- My Husband Said His Pregnant Girlfriend Was Taking Over Our Mansion. When They Arrived To Move In, The Surprise At The Door Wiped The Smile Off His Face
- The Mechanic Kept My Late Husband’s 1971 Pickup For “Unpaid Storage,” Got A Title From The State And Sold It While I Was Still Grieving. At The Fall Car Show, Our Old Weimaraner Jumped Into The Truck Bed And Wouldn’t Let The New Owner Near It
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
