Connect with us

The Movers Quoted Me $3,900 to Take Everything My Late Husband and I Owned to Tennessee, Then Called From the Road and Said It Would Be $11,400 More or I’d Never See Any of It Again. Three Weeks Later My Old Beagle Lay Down in Front of Storage Unit 117 and Started to Howl

Off The Record

The Movers Quoted Me $3,900 to Take Everything My Late Husband and I Owned to Tennessee, Then Called From the Road and Said It Would Be $11,400 More or I’d Never See Any of It Again. Three Weeks Later My Old Beagle Lay Down in Front of Storage Unit 117 and Started to Howl

My husband Alvie and I lived in the same white farmhouse outside Cambridge, Ohio, for forty-six years. He bought it in 1978 with money he saved inspecting rail cars in the Cambridge yard, and he used to say the house came with three things: a leaky cellar, a pear tree that only bore every other year, and me, because I would not marry him until he had a place with a porch.

He died two Februarys ago, in his chair, during the second half of a basketball game. I came in from the kitchen to ask if he wanted pie and he was gone. The doctor said it was his heart and that it was quick. I have decided to believe that.

After that it was me and Shug.

Shug is a beagle. He is ten years old now, tricolor, with a white muzzle that has gone the color of old snow, and a voice on him that you can hear clear down at the county road when he gets going. Alvie named him. He said a dog that sweet had to be called Shug, short for sugar, and the name stuck so hard that the vet’s office has it on file as Shug Coffelt, like he pays taxes.

Shug was Alvie’s dog first. He slept on the floor on Alvie’s side of the bed, on top of Alvie’s old barn coat, the brown canvas one with the corduroy collar. After the funeral I tried to wash that coat and Shug stood at the laundry room door and bayed at me until I put it back on the floor unwashed. It has been there ever since. I am not a sentimental woman, but I am not going to fight a beagle over a coat.

I lasted two winters alone in that house. The second one, the furnace went out on a Sunday night when it was nine degrees, and I sat up in the kitchen with the oven door open and Shug in my lap and decided I was done being brave. My daughter Trula had been asking me to move down near her in Cookeville, Tennessee, for a year and a half. She had found a little brick house four streets from hers with a fenced yard and no stairs.

I called her the next morning and said, “Find out if they take beagles.”

“You Should Have Let Me Handle It, Mom”

My son Dencil lives in Columbus and does something with commercial insurance that he has explained to me four times. He is a good boy, but he talks to me the way you talk to someone who has just woken up from surgery. Slow and loud.

When I told him I was moving, he said, “That’s great, Mom. Let me find the movers. There are a lot of crooks out there.”

I said I was perfectly capable of finding a moving company.

I want to be honest about this part, because it matters later. I did not let him help. I was seventy-two years old and I had raised two children and buried a husband and paid off a thirty-year mortgage in nineteen, and I did not need my son to pick up a telephone for me. That was pride, and I know it now.

I went on the computer at the library. I found a company called Patriot Star Van Lines. They had a nice website with a picture of a smiling family and a bald eagle, and a lot of five-star reviews, and they answered the phone on the second ring. A young woman named Krystal came on and was so sweet to me. She asked about the house and the furniture and whether I had any heirlooms. I told her about Alvie’s grandmother’s cherry corner cabinet, and the cedar chest, and Alvie’s tools, and our wedding pictures, and his recliner, which I could not leave behind even though it smelled like him and Shug and forty years of pipe tobacco.

“Oh, ma’am, we’ll take good care of all of it,” Krystal said. “We treat every move like it’s our own grandmother’s.”

She did an estimate over a video call. I walked my phone around the house and she wrote things down. The quote came back at $3,900, with a $1,200 deposit. I paid the deposit with a check. I remember feeling proud of myself.

Dencil called that night and asked who I had hired. I told him. He said, “Did you check their federal number?” I did not know what that was, and I told him so in a voice that meant the conversation was over.

The Truck Came on a Tuesday

They came on the second Tuesday in October, a day later than they said, in a big white truck with no name painted on it. That should have been my second warning. The first one was that the man in charge was not the man I had talked to, and there was no man I had talked to, only Krystal.

There were three of them. Two older fellows who did not say much, and a young man of maybe twenty-two with a sunburned neck and a gentle way about him. His name was Keaton. Shug, who does not care for strangers, walked straight up to him and leaned on his leg.

“Well, hey, buddy,” Keaton said, and knelt down and rubbed both of Shug’s ears at once, the way Alvie used to. “My grandma had a beagle. His name was Huckleberry. He used to sing when the noon whistle went off.”

“This one sings at the mail truck,” I said.

Keaton laughed. He was the one who wrapped the cherry cabinet in three blankets. He was the one who carried the cedar chest out by himself. And when it came time to load Alvie’s recliner, he asked me, “Ma’am, you want the coat on the floor to go too?”

I said yes. I told him it was Shug’s bed. He folded it careful as a flag and set it right on the seat of the recliner.

They finished at four in the afternoon. One of the older men handed me a clipboard with a stack of papers and told me to sign at the bottom so they could get on the road. I signed. I did not read all of it. I am a reader, I read every word of the church bulletin, but I was tired and the house was empty and Shug was crying at the door, and I signed.

The truck pulled out. Delivery was supposed to be Thursday in Cookeville. I spent that night on an air mattress in the front room with Shug, and he would not sleep. He walked from the door to the window and back, all night long, his nails ticking on the bare floor.

The Phone Call From the Road

I drove down Wednesday with Shug in the passenger seat, stopping every hour so his old legs could stretch. Trula met me at the new house with a pot of soup and her husband had already put a dog door in the back.

Thursday came. No truck.

Thursday afternoon, my phone rang. It was not Krystal. It was a man with a flat voice who said his name was Mr. Weidner, from the accounting department.

“Mrs. Coffelt, I’m calling about your shipment. There’s a problem with the weight.”

I asked what kind of problem.

“Your estimate was based on eight thousand pounds. Your load came in at nineteen thousand four hundred. We’re also assessing fees for long carry, stair carry, oversized items, and extra packing materials. Your new balance is $15,300.”

I sat down on the floor of my new kitchen because there were no chairs.

“That’s not possible,” I said. “I have a two-bedroom house. My furniture is old but it isn’t made of iron.”

“Ma’am, the scales don’t lie. You signed the bill of lading authorizing the reweigh and the additional charges. If you’d like to review it, it’s on page four.”

“I want my things delivered today, like you promised.”

“We’ll be happy to deliver once the balance is paid in full. Certified funds only. If the balance isn’t paid within thirty days, the shipment will be considered abandoned and disposed of to cover storage costs.”

I asked him what disposed of meant.

“Sold, ma’am. At auction.”

I said, “My husband’s things are on that truck.”

He said, “Then I’d make arrangements quickly,” and he hung up.

Shug was sitting in the empty living room in front of the bare spot where I had told Trula the recliner would go. He had been sitting there since Wednesday night.

What Everybody Told Me

I called Krystal’s number. It rang and rang, and then a recording said the mailbox was full. I called the number on the website. A man answered and said Krystal no longer worked there and transferred me to Mr. Weidner’s voicemail.

Trula’s husband, who is a quiet man and a deacon, said a word I had never heard him say.

Then I did the hardest thing, which was call Dencil.

He drove down from Columbus that night. Six hours. He came in the door at two in the morning, and I want to tell you he hugged me and said it would be all right, but the first thing he said was, “You should have let me handle it, Mom.”

I said, “I know that, Dencil.”

“I asked you to check their number. I asked you.”

“I know.”

He sat down on the floor next to me and looked at the papers from the clipboard. He read them all, every page. Page four said what Mr. Weidner said it did. In tiny print, it said that the customer authorized the carrier to reweigh and adjust charges at destination and agreed that goods would be held until all charges were paid.

“They do this to old people,” Dencil said. “It’s a whole thing. They’re called hostage movers. I read about it. They take a low deposit, load you up, then triple the price once your stuff’s in the truck.”

“Can we call the police?”

“I’ll call. But I already know what they’ll say.”

He was right. The Cookeville police were kind, but they said it was a contract dispute and a civil matter. The Ohio attorney general’s office took a complaint over the phone and gave me a case number. The federal motor carrier people had a website where you could file a complaint, and Dencil filed one, and an email came back saying it could take sixty to ninety days to review. My thirty days were already down to twenty-six.

Dencil sat at my card table on the third night and said, “Mom, I think we just pay it.”

“With what?”

“I’ll put it on my card. We’ll fight for it back later. It’s not worth losing Dad’s things over.”

I want you to know I almost let him. I sat there and thought about Alvie’s grandmother’s cabinet going to some auction in Nashville. I thought about our wedding album. I thought about his coat.

Then I thought about Alvie, who once drove forty miles to return a dollar and ten cents to a gas station that undercharged him, and I could hear him plain as day, saying, “Bel, you don’t pay a man for robbing you.”

“No,” I said. “We are not paying that man.”

The Boy Who Called Back

Eleven days after the truck left, at nine o’clock at night, my phone rang with a number I did not know. I almost did not answer it.

It was Keaton.

He was whispering. He said, “Ma’am, is this the lady with the beagle?”

I said it was.

“I’m not supposed to be calling you. I got your number off the paperwork. I quit. I quit last week. I want you to know I didn’t know how they did it when I started. They told me it was a regular moving company. I swear to God.”

I said, “Keaton, where are my things?”

He was quiet for a second. “They don’t take it to Tennessee, not really. They take it to a storage place outside Gallatin. It’s off the highway, it’s got an orange fence. They rent a bunch of units under different names so nobody can find it all in one place. When people pay, they deliver. When people don’t, they sell it out the back.”

“Which unit?”

“I don’t know. I swear I don’t. Me and the other guys just unload where Mr. Weidner tells us. There’s a lot of them. Maybe twenty. Ma’am, I gotta go.”

“Keaton, would you tell a policeman what you just told me?”

He breathed into the phone for a long time. Then he said, “I loaded your husband’s chair myself. I put the coat on it. Yes, ma’am. I would.”

Dencil was sitting across from me, and he had heard every word. He looked at me and I saw something on my son’s face I had not seen since he was little. He looked like he was proud of me.

“Mom,” he said, “you just got us a witness.”

Four Hundred Orange Doors

We found the storage place on the computer that same night. Mid-State Self Storage, Gallatin, Tennessee. Four hundred and twelve units. An orange fence.

The next morning Dencil called the Sumner County Sheriff’s Office and asked for anyone who handled fraud. That is how we met Detective Elvin Shreve, a big slow-talking man with a gray mustache, who listened to the whole story twice and then said, “Mrs. Coffelt, you are the fourth family that’s called me about Patriot Star since August. You’re the first one with a witness.”

He talked to Keaton on the phone that afternoon. Then he called us back.

“Here’s my problem,” he said. “The manager over there says the company rents units, but not under the company name. Under people names. Different ones. I can get a warrant for any unit I can tie to them. But I can’t get a warrant to open all four hundred doors on a hunch. I need something that points me at one.”

“What kind of something?” Dencil asked.

“Anything a judge will believe.”

I was holding Shug in my lap. He had not eaten right in two weeks. He had not slept in his bed because his bed was a coat in a truck. He was sitting up looking at the detective’s voice coming out of my phone like it was a person.

I said, “Detective, my husband’s coat is in one of those units.”

“Ma’am?”

“My dog has slept on that coat every night for two years. He will not sleep on anything else. That beagle can find a biscuit in a shut purse on the far side of a church. If you let me walk him down those rows, I believe he will tell you which door.”

There was a long silence on the line. Dencil was looking at me like I had lost my mind.

Then Detective Shreve said, “You know, my daddy ran coon dogs for thirty years.” And then he said, “Can you be here at ten tomorrow?”

Unit 117

It was the twenty-first day. Cold and gray, with a wind coming down off the ridge. Detective Shreve met us at the orange gate with a younger deputy and a lady from the storage office named Zola, who had a ring of keys and a worried face. She said she did not want any trouble with the company, but she did not want people’s grandmothers robbed either.

They had a hunch about one building, the long one in the back where most of the company’s units were. Detective Shreve said, “Let him go where he wants. If he goes nowhere, we’ll call it a nice walk.”

I unclipped the leash.

Shug put his nose down and started up the first row like he had a job. Past ten doors. Twenty. He stopped once at a door near the end and sniffed it and moved on. He turned the corner into the second row. He was moving faster now, the way he does in the yard when a rabbit has been through in the night. His tail was straight up, white tip and all.

Halfway down the third row he stopped dead.

He put his nose to the gap under a plain orange door, and he breathed in so hard I could hear it. Then he lay down flat on the concrete with his chin on the bottom of that door, and he threw his head back and howled.

I have heard Shug bay at the mail truck. I have heard him sing along with the noon whistle at the volunteer fire department. I had never heard him make that sound. It went up and up and broke in the middle, and it echoed down that whole long concrete row, and the young deputy took his hat off without seeming to know he did it.

The number painted on the post beside the door was 117.

Zola looked at her clipboard and went pale. “That one’s rented to a Mr. Wilbert Tarbell,” she said. “Paid cash. Same day as the three on the next row.”

Detective Shreve did not say anything for a minute. He just watched my old dog lying on the concrete with his nose pressed under that door, crying.

“Well,” he said, very quietly. “I’ve gotten warrants on a lot less than that.”

What Was Behind the Door

They did not open it that day. They did it right. Detective Shreve wrote out what he had seen and what Keaton had told him, and he put in that Zola’s records showed four units rented by the same cash customer the same afternoon, and that the dates matched three other families’ complaints. A judge in Gallatin signed the warrant at four-fifteen the next afternoon.

They cut the lock at nine the morning after that. Dencil held my arm.

The door rolled up, and there was Alvie’s grandmother’s cherry cabinet, still in Keaton’s three blankets. There was the cedar chest. There was Alvie’s recliner, and on the seat, folded careful as a flag, was a brown canvas barn coat with a corduroy collar.

Shug walked into that unit, climbed straight up into the recliner, turned around twice, and lay down on the coat. Then he let out the longest dog sigh I have ever heard and closed his eyes.

Every one of my boxes was there. The weight, by the way, was 7,800 pounds. The detective had a truck scale reading done on the load when they moved it. Not nineteen thousand. Not even eight.

In the other three units on Mr. Tarbell’s name they found the household goods of a widower from Kentucky, a retired teacher from Indiana, and a young Army family who had been moved from Fort Campbell. In a fourth building, under yet another name, there were three more.

Mr. Tarbell turned out to be Jarrod Weidner. So did Mr. Weidner from accounting, and so did the man who signed the paperwork for two other companies with different eagles on their websites. Krystal, it turned out, was his wife’s cousin, and when they arrested her she told them everything inside an afternoon. Jarrod Weidner was charged in Sumner County with theft over $60,000 and with extortion, and the federal people, who had suddenly found their review moving along much faster, shut down his authority to haul anything across a state line.

I got my $1,200 deposit back in March, from a restitution fund. I would have let him keep it to see his face when they put the cuffs on.

The Boy, the Chair, and My Son

Keaton testified. He wore a borrowed tie that was too short and he looked at the floor the whole time, but he told the truth from start to finish. Afterward he came out in the hallway and Shug ran to him and leaned on his leg, same as the first day.

Dencil shook his hand and said, “You did a hard thing, son.”

Keaton said, “Sir, I just kept thinking about that coat.”

He works for a real moving company in Cookeville now. A family one, with a name painted on the truck and a federal number on the door. I made sure of the number. When they moved Trula’s mother-in-law in the spring, I asked for him by name.

Dencil and I had a talk after the trial, sitting on my new porch with the recliner pulled up to the window inside where Shug could see us. He said he was sorry he had talked to me like I was a child. I said I was sorry I had acted like one, a little, about the federal number.

He said, “Mom, I’ve been doing insurance claims for twenty-two years. I have never seen anybody get their stuff back from one of those outfits. Ever. You know that?”

I said, “I didn’t. Your daddy’s dog did.”

He laughed, and then he did not laugh, and he wiped his eyes with the back of his hand the same way Alvie did when the National Anthem got to him at ball games.

My house in Cookeville is small and brick and has no stairs. Alvie’s grandmother’s cabinet is in the dining room with our wedding plates in it. The cedar chest is at the foot of my bed. And on the floor on what would have been Alvie’s side, on top of a brown canvas coat that has still never been washed, an old beagle sleeps every night with his chin on the collar.

Every once in a while, in his sleep, he lets out one low little howl. I do not know what he is dreaming. I like to think he is still guarding the door.

If you know someone who is getting ready to move, especially someone older who would rather do it all themselves, please share this with them. Ask them to look up the mover’s federal number before they sign anything. It might save somebody’s whole life in boxes.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family

Continue Reading

Jason is a writer and storyteller who focuses on the human side of the stories — moments of kindness, resilience, family, and the turning points that quietly change a life. He writes to inform, engage, and inspire, and believes the best stories are the ones that make readers feel less alone.