Off The Record
The Kennel Handed Me A Cedar Box Of Ashes And Said My Husband’s Old Bird Dog Died In His Sleep While I Was At My Sister’s Funeral. When I Called The Crematory To Ask For His Paw Print, The Lady Said They Hadn’t Had A Dog From That Kennel All Year
My husband Merl hunted grouse in the hills above Wellsboro, Pennsylvania, for fifty-one years, and for the last eight of them he never once went into the woods without Doc.
Doc is an English setter. White with orange ticking all over him like somebody flicked a paintbrush, orange ears, a long feathered tail that he carries straight up like a flag when he is working. Merl bought him as a pup from a man in Lycoming County who had been breeding the same line of grouse dogs since the 1970s, and he paid more for that puppy than he paid for his first car. I told him he was out of his mind. He said, “Ludie, you’ll see.”
I saw. By his second fall, Doc could find a grouse in a laurel thicket that I would have sworn on the Bible was empty. He would lock up on point, one front foot curled up under him, that tail high and trembling, and he would hold it there until Merl walked in. Merl used to say that dog had better manners than half the deacons at our church.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →Every evening of hunting season, the two of them would come up the porch steps at dusk, Merl in his red-and-black wool coat smelling like woodsmoke and wet leaves, Doc with burrs in his feathers, both of them so tired and so happy they could hardly stand. I would have supper on. Merl would sit on the steps and pick the burrs out of Doc’s coat one at a time and tell me every point, every flush, every miss. Doc would lie across his boots.
Merl died eighteen months ago in April. His heart, on a Tuesday, in the truck in the feed store parking lot. Doc was in the passenger seat. The man who found them said the dog would not let anyone open Merl’s door until the ambulance came, and then he lay down in the gravel and would not get up.

The Two of Us
After that it was Doc and me in the farmhouse on Bowen Hollow Road.
I am sixty-nine and I don’t hunt. I never did. But that first fall after Merl passed, when the leaves turned and the air got that smell, Doc started standing at the back door every morning at six-thirty, whining. On the fourth morning I put on my green wool jacket and Merl’s old boots, which are three sizes too big, and I took Doc up the hill behind the barn.
We didn’t find a single bird I could have hit. I don’t own a shotgun. But Doc found three, and pointed every one, and stood there trembling, waiting for Merl to walk in. I walked in instead. The birds went up with a roar like a truck starting, and Doc looked back at me over his shoulder, puzzled, as if to say, well, aren’t you going to do anything?
I laughed so hard I had to sit down on a stump. It was the first time I had laughed since April.
We went up that hill most mornings after that. I started carrying Merl’s old brass whistle. Doc didn’t care that I was not a hunter. He cared that somebody walked in.
The Kennel on Pine Run
This past September my sister Ivah died in Hagerstown, Maryland. She was seventy-four, and it was not sudden, and I had been driving down to sit with her every few weeks since spring. When her daughter called to say it was time, I packed a bag in fifteen minutes.
I could not take Doc. Ivah’s daughter has two cats and an apartment, and the service and the house and the lawyer were going to take most of a week. My usual neighbor who looks after him, Exie Nusbaum, had just had her knee replaced and couldn’t walk a dog to the mailbox.
So I called Pine Run Kennels, out past Stony Fork.
I knew the owner a little. Her name was Joleen Haverstick, a big friendly woman in her fifties with a laugh you could hear across the feed store. She had boarded Doc once before, two days, the spring after Merl died, when I had to go to Harrisburg for the estate. When I came to pick him up that time, she walked him out on a lead and said, “Now that’s a pretty dog. Merl’s setter, isn’t he? Finished grouse dog?”
I said he was.
“You know what men pay for a finished grouse dog from that line?” she said, and whistled. “Honey, you’re sitting on a gold mine.”
I laughed and said he wasn’t for sale. I didn’t think about it again.
I dropped Doc off on a Thursday morning in September. I brought his bed and his food and Merl’s old red wool scarf, which Doc sleeps with. Joleen took the leash and patted my arm and said, “Go take care of your family. We’ll take care of yours.”
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →Doc looked back at me from the kennel door. He always does that.
The Phone Call in Hagerstown
On Sunday afternoon, the day after Ivah’s service, I was sitting in her kitchen with my niece going through recipe boxes when my phone rang. It was Joleen.
“Ludie, honey. Are you sitting down?”
I don’t remember all of what she said. I remember “in his sleep” and “he just didn’t wake up” and “it happens with the older dogs sometimes, they just go.” I remember her saying she found him curled up on Merl’s scarf in the morning and he looked peaceful. I remember her saying, “I didn’t want you to have to come home to that, with everything else, so I took care of it. I took him over to the crematory in Mansfield Saturday. You’ll have him back. I’m so sorry, honey.”
I said Doc was only eight.
“I know. I know. Sometimes it’s their heart. You never know with these big dogs.”
I sat in my dead sister’s kitchen with her recipe for walnut cake in my hand and I could not breathe. My niece took the phone from me and talked to Joleen. Then she held me while I cried, for Ivah and for Doc and for Merl, all three, the way you do when the grief has been stacked up and something knocks the bottom out.
I drove home on Wednesday. It is a four-hour drive and I don’t remember any of it.
A Cedar Box and a Collar
Joleen met me at the kennel office. She had tears in her eyes. She hugged me for a long time.
She handed me a small cedar box, about the size of a loaf of bread, with a brass latch. And in a plastic bag, Doc’s collar, the orange one with the brass plate Merl had engraved with his name and our phone number.
“I took it off him before they took him,” she said. “I figured you’d want it.”
I asked her what I owed for the boarding. She wouldn’t take a dime. “Not after this,” she said. “Not a dime.”
I thanked her. I want you to remember that. I stood in that kennel office and thanked her.
I took the box home and set it on the fireplace mantel next to Merl’s picture. I put the collar on the mantel too. And for five weeks I did not go up the hill behind the barn. I couldn’t. In the mornings at six-thirty I would wake up and listen for Doc whining at the back door, and there would be nothing, and I would lie there until it got light.
My son Marlon drove up from Pittsburgh. He sat with me and said Doc had a good life. He said maybe in the spring I could get a pup. I told him I was sixty-nine and had buried a husband and a sister and a dog in a year and a half and I was not getting anything else that could die on me.
The Paw Print
It was Exie who gave me the idea, God love her. She was finally getting around on her new knee, and she came over in October with a pie and saw the cedar box on the mantel.
“Ludie, did they give you a paw print?”
I didn’t know what she meant.
“When my Sugarfoot passed, the crematory made a little clay print of her paw and sent it home with the ashes. Lots of them do it. It’s on my windowsill. You ought to call and ask. They probably still have one, or they could tell you.”
I thought that would be something. To have his foot, the one he curled up when he pointed. So the next morning I looked up the crematory in Mansfield. There is only one. Twin Tiers Pet Crematory, on the Lambs Creek Road.
A woman answered. Her name was Cordie Bupp, and she had the kind of soft, slow voice I imagine you develop in that business. I told her who I was and that my English setter had been brought to her from Pine Run Kennels on a Saturday in September, the twentieth, and I wondered if they had made a paw print.
She said, “Let me look, hon.” I heard her turning pages. A long time.
Then she said, “Mrs. Fetterolf, I don’t have a setter on the twentieth. I don’t have anything from Pine Run that week.”
I asked if she could look at the whole month.
“Ma’am,” she said, slower now. “I don’t have anything from Pine Run Kennels this year at all. Joleen hasn’t brought me a dog since last fall. And to be honest with you, we didn’t do a large dog at all the last two weeks of September. Our big unit was down for repairs.”
I was standing in my kitchen. I looked through the doorway at the cedar box on the mantel.
“Hon?” said Cordie Bupp. “Hon, are you still there?”
What Was in the Box
I am not proud of this, but I opened it. I got a butter knife and worked the little brass latch, and inside was a plastic bag with a twist tie, full of gray powder.
I don’t know what dog ashes look like. I know what fireplace ash looks like, because I have cleaned out a woodstove every morning for forty-six winters. This was fireplace ash. Soft and light, with little black flecks of charcoal in it. And down near the bottom, when I tipped the bag, there was a tiny curl of something that caught the light.
It was half of a burnt carpet tack.
I sat down on the hearth. Then I got up and went to the kitchen drawer where I keep the things I don’t know what to do with, and I took out Merl’s old cell phone, because I had a thought I couldn’t shake.
When Merl bought Doc as a pup, the breeder had made him put a microchip in him. Merl filled out the registration online with his own email, because I don’t have one. I have never once looked at it since he died. I didn’t even know the password. But Marlon had set the phone up to keep working for the old pictures, and when I opened the mail on it there were a hundred and forty messages I had never read.
The seventh one down was from the microchip company. It was dated September twenty-second. Two days after Doc died in his sleep.
The subject line said, “Transfer of Ownership Request: DOC.”
Potter County
The email said that a new owner had requested the registration be transferred to him after his veterinarian scanned the chip during a routine visit. It said the registered owner, Merl Fetterolf, had fourteen days to object, after which the transfer would go through automatically. It gave the new owner’s name and county. Emmitt Oberholtzer. Coudersport, Pennsylvania.
The fourteen days had run out on October sixth.
I called Marlon in Pittsburgh. He was quiet for a long time, and then he said, “Mom, don’t you go anywhere. I’m calling the state police.”
The trooper who came out the next afternoon was a young woman named Lexi Kaltenbach, from the Mansfield barracks. She read the email on Merl’s phone. She called Cordie Bupp at Twin Tiers and talked to her for ten minutes. She looked in the cedar box and smelled it and made a face. Then she asked me if I could get Merl’s whistle.
Coudersport is an hour west of us, in Potter County, which is the kind of country where there are more bear than people. Emmitt Oberholtzer turned out to run a small guide business for grouse and woodcock hunters out of an old farmhouse on a dirt road, with a row of dog runs behind the barn. He was a lean man of about sixty with a gray ponytail, and when the trooper’s car pulled in, followed by Marlon’s car with me in it, he came out on the porch drying his hands on a dish towel and looked worried.
Trooper Kaltenbach did the talking. I didn’t hear all of it. I heard Emmitt say, “Pine Run? No, ma’am. I bought him from a woman named Joleen. She said he came out of an estate. The owner had passed and the widow couldn’t keep him. I paid her $3,500 cash. Best grouse dog I’ve ever had.”
Then he looked over at me, standing by the car in my green jacket, and his face changed.
“Ma’am,” he said. “Are you the widow?”
Come Around
I didn’t wait for anybody to say anything else. I walked around the side of that barn toward the dog runs. There were five of them, and the dogs in them were barking at the strangers, pointers and a Brittany and a little black setter.
The last run was quiet.
He was lying down in the back with his chin on his paws, white and orange, thinner than I remembered. He didn’t get up. He wasn’t looking at me. I don’t think he could see me past the other dogs, and I don’t think he believed I could be there anyway.
I put Merl’s brass whistle to my lips and blew it the way Merl did at the end of every hunt. Two short and one long. Come around.
Doc’s head came up.
He stood. He stared. His tail went straight up like a flag, trembling, the way it does when he points. Then he threw himself at the gate of that run and cried, a high sound I have never heard from him, over and over, and Emmitt Oberholtzer came running with the key in his hand and his face wet.
He opened the gate and Doc came out like a shot. He hit me so hard I went down on my knees in the leaves, and he climbed into my arms and pushed his face into my neck, whining and shaking, and I held on to him and said his name until I couldn’t say it anymore.
Marlon told me later that the trooper turned around and walked back to her car for a minute.

What Joleen Had Done
When Emmitt understood the whole thing, he went in the house and came back out with Doc’s bed, and a brown paper sack, and he handed me the sack and said, “This was in his crate when she brought him.”
Inside was Merl’s old red wool scarf.
He would not take any money. I tried. He said, “Ma’am, I’ve been hunting behind that dog for six weeks. I know what he is. I wasn’t going to take him from you for $3,500 if it was $35,000.” He said he would testify to whatever the trooper needed.
He testified. So did Cordie Bupp, who brought her logbook. So did two other families.
Because once Trooper Kaltenbach started pulling at the string, it all came loose. Joleen Haverstick had been doing it for at least three years. She picked older, well-bred dogs whose owners were away for something terrible, a funeral, a hospital stay, a long trip they couldn’t cut short. She sold the dogs for cash to buyers in other counties and handed the owners a cedar box of woodstove ash, and never charged them for boarding, which, as the trooper said, is a hard thing to complain about. A retired couple from Elmira had gotten a box for their springer spaniel. A widower in Blossburg had gotten one for his Lab. The springer was found alive and well with a family in Ohio. The Lab has not been found yet, and I pray for that man.
Joleen was charged with theft by deception, receiving stolen property,, and the commonwealth shut Pine Run down. She pleaded guilty in the spring. The judge gave her two years in the county and ordered her to pay back every buyer, so that people like Emmitt Oberholtzer would not be out a dime for being honest.
The Box on the Mantel
I still have the cedar box. I couldn’t bring myself to throw it away, and I wasn’t about to keep what was in it, so I carried the bag of ash out to the garden and dumped it on the compost where it belongs. Then I washed the box and dried it.
Inside it now is Merl’s picture, the one of him on the porch steps with his red-and-black coat on and Doc sitting at his knee. And a little clay print of a setter’s front paw. Cordie Bupp made it for me, at no charge, with Doc standing right there in her office having the time of his life.
Doc sleeps on the red scarf again, on the rug beside my bed. He gained back his weight by Christmas.
And every morning in season, at six-thirty, he stands at the back door and whines until I get up. I put on my green jacket and Merl’s boots, three sizes too big, and we go up the hill behind the barn. He finds them. He points them, one foot curled up under him, tail high and trembling. And he waits for somebody to walk in.
I walk in. The birds go up with a roar. He looks back at me over his shoulder like I am the worst hunter he has ever had to put up with.
I tell him I know. I tell him Merl would have hit that one. Then I blow two short and one long, and he comes around.
If you have ever had to board an animal you love while your life was falling apart, I hope you had someone honest looking after them. Please share this with anyone who has a pet and a hard trip coming up. And if your dog has a microchip, check the email it is registered to. You never know who might be trying to reach you.
Now Trending:
- My Mother Took My 8-Year-Old’s Plate Away At Christmas Dinner Because She Spilled My Nephew’s Juice, And My Sister Laughed That Being Hungry Would Teach Her Manners. That Night My Father Texted Me About The $2,850 Rent I Pay Them. I Sent One Email Instead
- My Son Insisted On Picking Up My Mail Every Morning So I Wouldn’t Have To Walk Our Half-Mile Lane. The Day The New Carrier Came Early, My Old Shepherd Dropped A Letter At My Feet Thanking Me For My $61,000 Home Equity Loan
- My Father Threw Me Out Of Christmas Dinner For Being A Failure With “Just A Laptop” While My Sister And Brother Laughed. He Had No Idea That For Four Years I Had Been Secretly Sending The Family $28,000 Every Month, And That Night I Sent One Email
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
