Off The Record
Somebody Drained $23,700 From My Late Husband’s Bank Account Using His Own Phone, And The Bank Said It Had To Be Me. On Thanksgiving I Called His Number Like I Always Do, And My Old Plott Hound Started Howling At My Grandson’s Girlfriend’s Purse
Every evening for forty-six years, after supper, my husband Okey went out on the front porch and played “Red River Valley” on his harmonica.
He played other songs too. He knew a hundred of them. But that was the one he always started with, and that was the one he always ended with, and in between, the dog howled.
We live in a farmhouse on sixty acres in a hollow outside Elkins, West Virginia, in Randolph County, on land Okey’s granddaddy bought with mine money in 1922. You can see three ridges from our porch. In October they look like somebody spilled paint on them. In November they turn gray and brown and you can see every road and every house that the leaves were hiding.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →My name is Dreama Mullenax. I am seventy-one years old. I taught second grade at the elementary school in Elkins for thirty-three years, and if you went to school in Randolph County between 1976 and 2009, there’s a fair chance I taught you to read.
Okey drove a coal truck for twenty years and then worked maintenance for the county schools until he retired. He was a big bald man with a gray beard that came halfway down his chest, and he was the gentlest person I ever knew. He could not stand to see anything suffer. He once drove forty miles at midnight to return a box turtle to the creek he’d accidentally carried it away from in his truck bed.
And he loved that harmonica. And he loved that dog.

Jigger
Jigger is a Plott hound. If you’re not from the mountains, Plotts are big brindle hounds, the color of a tiger that’s been rolled in coffee grounds, bred in North Carolina to run bear. They have voices you can hear three ridges away. Okey hunted bear with Plotts all his life, and when he got too old to hunt, he kept just the one. Jigger is twelve now. He came to us as a puppy the year Okey retired, and he never once went on a hunt. He was a porch dog, a truck dog, a lie-by-the-woodstove dog.
The first time Okey sat down on the porch and played “Red River Valley,” Jigger was about ten weeks old. Halfway through the first verse, that puppy sat back on his haunches, pointed his nose straight up at the porch ceiling, and howled.
He howled at that song every single time for twelve years. Not at sirens. Not at other music. Not at “Amazing Grace” or “Shenandoah” or anything else Okey played. Just “Red River Valley.” Okey said the dog had good taste.
On Okey’s seventieth birthday, our grandson Ryland, who was twenty then and good with phones, did something that tickled Okey more than any present he ever got. Ryland recorded his granddaddy playing “Red River Valley” on the porch, and he made it into the ringtone on Okey’s cell phone.
So from then on, every time anybody called Okey, his own harmonica started playing out of his shirt pocket. And every time it did, Jigger threw back his head and howled. In the feed store. In the doctor’s waiting room. At church once, which I will never live down. Okey would laugh so hard he couldn’t answer the phone.
March
Okey died this past March, sitting in his recliner after supper, with his harmonica in his lap. I’d gone to run the dishwater. When I came back in, he was gone. Jigger was lying across his feet.
I won’t tell you about the weeks after that. If you’ve been through it, you already know, and if you haven’t, there’s no way for me to tell you. The house was full of people for a week. Food on every surface. My son Harless and his wife Fonda came from Morgantown and stayed. Our grandson Ryland came, and he brought his girlfriend, Brandi, who he’d been seeing for about a year.
I’ll say this for Brandi. She worked. She washed dishes for three days straight. She wrote down every casserole and who brought it so I could send thank-you notes. She sat with me on the porch one evening and held my hand and told me what a sweet man Okey was, how he’d made her feel welcome at Christmas. I liked her. I told Ryland I liked her.
Sometime during that week, Okey’s phone disappeared.
I didn’t think much of it at the time. I remembered seeing it on the kitchen counter, plugged in, the day after he died. After that, I didn’t see it again. I figured somebody moved it while they were cleaning up and it ended up in a drawer or a box of sympathy cards. I looked for it a few times. Harless looked. We never found it.
Calling Okey
I need to tell you something now that might sound foolish. I’ve never told anybody but my sister.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →I kept paying for his phone line. Thirty-five dollars a month. Harless told me to cancel it. I said I would, and I didn’t.
Because on Okey’s phone there was a voicemail greeting he recorded about ten years ago. Ryland had to show him how. It goes, “This is Okey. I’m probably out with the dog. Leave it at the beep.” That’s it. Nine words, in his voice, with Jigger barking in the background.
I call it on Sundays. I call it on holidays. I called it on our anniversary in June and on his birthday in September. It rings four times, and then I hear him say he’s probably out with the dog, and I hang up before the beep. I don’t know why I don’t leave a message. Maybe I’m afraid it’ll fill up.
I never once wondered where the phone was ringing. I thought it was ringing in a drawer somewhere. Or nowhere. I didn’t really think phones had to be anywhere to ring.
The Bounced Check
In August, my property tax check bounced.
I had never bounced a check in my life. I taught second grade. I balance my checkbook to the penny every Friday. I drove to the bank in Elkins with my checkbook in my purse and my face burning, and I sat down across from a young woman at the desk and told her there had been a mistake.
There had not been a mistake. The joint savings account Okey and I had kept since 1979, where we put his retirement and my teacher’s pension and every penny we did not need to live on, had $1,104 in it. In February, it had more than $24,000.
The young woman printed out the statements. There were transfers out of it, starting in April, the month after Okey died. Every week or two. Four hundred dollars. Eleven hundred. Nineteen hundred. Six hundred and fifty. All of them sent through the bank’s phone app to an account under a business name I’d never heard of. All of them done from Okey’s phone, using Okey’s login.
Twenty-three thousand, seven hundred dollars.
The teller who came over to help was a girl named Kayla whose mother I’d had in my class, and I watched her look at those statements and then look at me with a kind of pity I’d never had aimed at me before. The pity you give an old woman who has gotten confused. I wanted to tell her I still balanced my checkbook every Friday. I wanted to show her. Instead I thanked her and walked out to my car and sat there until my hands quit shaking enough to drive.
“Who Else Has His Passcode, Ma’am?”
The bank sent me to a man in their fraud department, a Mr. Rexroad, who called me on the telephone from their main office in Clarksburg. He was polite. He was also very clear.
The transfers were made from a device registered to the account holder, he said. They were made with the correct passcode. There were no failed attempts, no new device, nothing that looked like a hacker. The phone was the one Okey had set up himself in 2021. As far as the bank was concerned, these were authorized transactions on a joint account.
“Who else would have his passcode, Mrs. Mullenax?”
“Nobody,” I said. “The phone’s lost. I haven’t seen it since March.”
He was quiet a second. “Ma’am, did you report it lost to the bank in March?”
I hadn’t. I didn’t know you were supposed to. I didn’t know the bank had anything to do with a telephone.
Then he said, “Ma’am, you’re a joint owner on this account, and the account receiving these funds is a business account at another institution. We’ll need you to provide some information about whether you have any connection to that business.”
I sat there in my kitchen with the phone to my ear, and I understood. He thought it was me. Or he thought it was somebody I was covering for. An old widow moving her money around to hide it, or giving it away to some man on the internet, and now crying fraud to get it back.
He said they would open an investigation, but I should understand the bank was not obligated to return funds from authorized transactions, and the process could take some time.
Harless drove down that weekend. He was furious, on my side, the whole way. He called the bank. He called the business account’s bank. Nobody would tell him who owned it. He filed a report with the sheriff’s office. A deputy named Shifflett, whose mother I taught in 1981, came out and sat at my kitchen table and wrote everything down and was very kind and told me honestly that these things were hard to trace.
Nobody could find the phone. And without the phone, nobody could prove it wasn’t me.
The worst of it came in October. Harless called on a Sunday night, and I could tell from his voice he’d been working up to something. He asked me, as gently as he knew how, if there was anybody I’d been talking to. On the computer, maybe. Anybody who had asked me for help. He said he’d read about widows who got lonely and met somebody online who needed money for a plane ticket or a hospital bill, and how they were ashamed to tell their families.
“Harless,” I said, “I don’t even know how to turn the computer on.”
He said he knew that. He said he was sorry. He said he just had to ask, because the bank had asked him. I told him I understood. I did understand. But I sat up a long time that night with Jigger’s head on my knee, thinking that my own son had, for one minute, wondered about me.
I started keeping every receipt in a shoebox after that. Every one. I don’t know who I thought I was going to show them to.
Thanksgiving
We had Thanksgiving at my house. We always have, and I wasn’t going to stop the first year without Okey, though Fonda offered to host. Harless and Fonda came Wednesday night. Ryland and Brandi drove over from Buckhannon on Thursday morning. Brandi brought a sweet potato casserole with the little marshmallows and hugged me for a long time at the door.
While we were basting the turkey, she asked me, very casual, whether the bank had ever figured anything out about “that money thing.” Ryland had told her about it. I said no, they were still investigating, and the sheriff didn’t have much to go on. She said that was terrible, that banks never take care of regular people, and she patted my arm. I remember thinking how sweet it was that she asked.
She hung her purse on the coat hooks by the kitchen door, where everybody always hangs everything. I remember that because it was a nice purse, a big tan leather one, and I remember thinking it looked expensive and that Ryland must be doing well at the lumber yard.
It was a good dinner. It was hard, too. Harless said the blessing, and he got through about half of it before he had to stop. Ryland told the story about Jigger howling in church and everybody laughed and then everybody cried. Okey’s chair was at the head of the table, and nobody sat in it.
After the pie, while Fonda and Brandi started on the dishes and the men were watching the football game, I put on my coat and went out on the porch by myself.
I do this every holiday. I go out to the porch where he played, and I sit on the swing, and I call his number to hear him say he’s out with the dog. I don’t tell anybody. I just slip out.
It was cold and gray. The ridges were brown. I sat on the swing and dialed Okey’s number and put the phone to my ear.
It rang once in my ear.
And from inside my house, through the kitchen window, I heard a harmonica start to play “Red River Valley.”

The Howl
I’ll never forget how it sounded. It was faint at first. Tinny and far off, like a radio in another room. Okey’s harmonica, the way he played it, with that little hitch he did on the high note.
Then I heard Jigger.
He’d been asleep in front of the woodstove. He’s twelve years old and he sleeps most of the day now. But I heard him scramble up off that floor, nails sliding on the linoleum, and then I heard him let loose a howl that I swear you could have heard on the next ridge. That long, deep, rolling Plott hound bawl. He hadn’t made that sound since March.
I was up off that swing and through the door with my own phone still ringing at my ear.
Everybody in my kitchen was frozen. Fonda had a dish towel in her hands. Harless and Ryland had come in from the living room. Jigger was standing under the coat hooks by the kitchen door with his head thrown back, howling straight up at a big tan leather purse.
And Brandi was standing at the sink with her hands in the dishwater, and all the color had gone out of her face.
Nobody moved. The harmonica played on. Fourth ring. Then it stopped, and in my ear I heard my husband say, “This is Okey. I’m probably out with the dog. Leave it at the beep.”
Jigger stopped howling. He stood there whining up at that purse, his tail going slow.
Ryland was the one who spoke. He was looking at his girlfriend.
“That’s Papaw’s ringtone,” he said. “I made that. That’s the only phone in the world that plays that.”
What Was in the Purse
Brandi said something about it being a ringtone she downloaded. That it was just a song. She dried her hands and started toward the coat hooks, fast, like she was going to grab the purse and go.
Ryland got there first.
He didn’t grab anything. He just stood in front of the coat hooks. He’s six foot three, like his granddaddy was, and he stood there with his back to that purse and said, real quiet, “Brandi. Tell me it’s not.”
She didn’t say anything.
I hung up my phone. Then I called again.
The harmonica started up inside the purse. Jigger threw back his head and howled. And Ryland turned around and opened that purse and reached in and pulled out his granddaddy’s phone, in the same brown case Okey had carried for five years, with the corner chewed off where Jigger got hold of it one Christmas.
On the screen was my name. “DREAMA.” And my picture. The one Okey took of me on the porch the summer we got that phone, laughing at him.
Ryland stood in the middle of my kitchen holding it, looking at my face on that screen, while it played his granddaddy’s harmonica, and that big boy started to cry.
The Passcode
Deputy Shifflett came out that evening. He didn’t even make me ask him twice. He left his own Thanksgiving dinner and came.
Brandi told him all of it, sitting at my kitchen table with a cup of coffee she didn’t drink.
She’d taken the phone off the kitchen counter the day after Okey died, while she was washing dishes. She said she didn’t plan it. She said she just picked it up. She’d started an online boutique the year before, selling clothes and jewelry, and she owed money on it everywhere, on credit cards and on a loan from a company that called her six times a day. She said she knew Okey’s passcode because he told everybody at Christmas. That was true. He thought it was funny. He used our anniversary, six-one-four-seven-nine, June 14th, 1979, “so I’ll never forget it, and if I do, Dreama will kill me.”
She said she found the bank app on his phone. She said she only meant to borrow four hundred dollars. She said she was going to pay it back. She said that every time.
She kept the phone in her glove box most of the time, she said, with the sound off. But Thursday morning she’d needed to make one more transfer before they drove over, to cover a payment due Friday, and she’d done it in the car and dropped the phone in her purse and forgot it was there.
She’d forgotten to turn the sound off. And she’d forgotten that I call him.
She hadn’t known I call him. Nobody knew.

After
The bank returned all $23,700 in January, once Deputy Shifflett’s report and the phone were in their hands. Mr. Rexroad called me himself and apologized. I told him I accepted it, and I did, mostly.
Brandi was charged with fraud and pleaded guilty in the spring. She got probation and an order to pay the bank back. Ryland moved out of their apartment the Saturday after Thanksgiving and came to stay with me for a month. I didn’t ask him to. He just showed up with a duffel bag and said, “Mamaw, you shouldn’t be by yourself out here.” I think he was the one who shouldn’t have been by himself. We were good company for each other.
He did something else while he was here. He took Okey’s phone and cleaned it out and got it working right, and he set the ringtone back to “Red River Valley.” He made sure the voicemail greeting was still on there. Then he handed it to me.
“It’s yours now, Mamaw,” he said. “You don’t have to call it anymore. You can just keep it.”
I keep it on the kitchen windowsill, plugged in. And I still call it.
I know how that sounds. But on Sunday evenings I sit at the kitchen table with my own phone and dial Okey’s number, and his phone lights up on the windowsill and his harmonica starts playing, and Jigger gets up off the floor by the woodstove and throws back his gray old head and howls along. Four rings. Then I hear Okey tell me he’s probably out with the dog.
And I look at the dog, and I tell him, “Not tonight, he’s not.”
If you’ve lost somebody and you still call their number just to hear their voice, you’re not foolish, and you’re not alone. Share this with somebody who still does. And if you’ve got an old phone in a drawer that belonged to someone you loved, check on it. Make sure it’s still where you left it.
Now Trending:
- My Husband Gave Me A Bathroom Scale For Our 20th Anniversary In Front Of Our Kids And Told Me To Finally Do Something About Myself. So I Walked Out To My Car And Brought Back The Gift I Had Been Saving For Him
- My Business Partner Of 38 Years Offered Me $90,000 For My Half Of Our Grain Elevator, And When I Said No, He Reported My Old Dog As Starving And Had Him Hauled Off. At The Hearing, My Granddaughter Asked The Judge To Count The Toes On The Dog In His Photo
- My Stepdaughter Pulled A New Will Out Of Her Purse At My Husband’s Funeral Lunch And Said He Signed It At Our Kitchen Table On April 12. On April 12 He Was 140 Miles Away Blowing A Whistle For Our Old Boykin Spaniel, And I Had The Ribbon To Prove It
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
