Off The Record
My Business Partner Of 38 Years Offered Me $90,000 For My Half Of Our Grain Elevator, And When I Said No, He Reported My Old Dog As Starving And Had Him Hauled Off. At The Hearing, My Granddaughter Asked The Judge To Count The Toes On The Dog In His Photo
There is a concrete grain elevator on the edge of Dover, Oklahoma, that you can see from six miles off when the wheat is cut and the air is clear. It has been there since 1958. For the last thirty-eight years, my name has been on the side of the scale house, right next to Dwain Rakestraw’s.
My name is Ruble Overholt. I am seventy-six years old. Dwain and I bought that elevator together in 1987 from the widow of the man who built it, and we paid her $212,000 we did not have. We each mortgaged our houses. My wife Arvella cried for two days and then went down to the bank with me and signed.
Dwain is five years younger than me. He was the first one at my house the morning Arvella’s daddy died, and he was a pallbearer at Arvella’s funeral four years ago. Every harvest we worked eighteen-hour days side by side and ate supper standing up in the scale house out of the same paper sack. I would have told you he was the best friend I ever had. I would have told you that right up until this October.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →
A Dog Named Walrus
I should tell you about Walrus, because this is mostly his story.
Arvella kept a few sheep, never more than twenty, because she liked to spin wool and because her mother had kept sheep. In 2016 the coyotes got bad, and she bought a Great Pyrenees pup from a family near Okeene to guard them. He was a white ball of fluff about the size of a loaf of bread, and he had a little cream-colored mask around his eyes and a big droopy mustache of fur, and our granddaughter Macy, who was eleven then, took one look at him and said, “He looks like a walrus.” That was that.
He grew into a hundred and eighteen pounds of white dog. A Pyrenees is calm and stubborn and thinks for himself. They were bred to stay out with the sheep and decide on their own who was a threat. Walrus decided early on that the threat was anything that came near Arvella.
When Arvella got sick, we sold the sheep. Walrus moved onto the front porch and lay across the door. After she passed, he moved inside, which a Pyrenees will hardly ever do, and lay across the foot of my bed. He is nine now. He goes to work with me every morning in the truck and lies in the shade of the scale house, and the farmers who bring their wheat in all know him.
One more thing about Pyrenees. On their back legs, they have two extra toes up above the foot, called dewclaws. Most dogs have one or none back there. A Pyrenees is supposed to have two on each hind leg, and the breeders will tell you it is in the standard. Walrus has his. I never thought one thing about them in nine years. Macy pointed them out to me once when she was little and said, “Pawpaw, he has thumbs.” That is the only time I can remember anybody mentioning them.
Ninety Thousand Dollars
This past summer was hard on me. I won’t pretend it wasn’t. Harvest was short and hot, and I am seventy-six, and twice in June I left the scale house door unlocked overnight. Once I wrote down the wrong test weight on a load of wheat for a young farmer named Cogburn and had to call him back and fix it. These were small things. But Dwain noticed them, and he kept a list. I found that out later.
The first week of October, Dwain came out to the house on a Sunday afternoon and sat at my kitchen table and drank my coffee and told me he thought it was time I retired.
“You’ve earned it, Ruble,” he said. “Arvella would want you to rest. Let me buy you out. I’ll take the headaches, you go see Rayford in Tulsa and play with your great-grandbaby.”
Rayford is my son. He sells insurance in Tulsa, and he has been after me to move closer since his mother died.
I asked Dwain what he had in mind. He slid a piece of paper across the table. It was typed up, very neat, and it said $90,000 for my half of the business, the elevator, the scale, the bins, the equipment and the land under it.
I am not a businessman with a fancy degree. But I have bought and sold wheat for thirty-eight years, and I knew that number was wrong. My cousin’s boy does farm appraisals out of Enid, and I had him come out once a couple of years ago for the insurance, and his number for the whole place was something over $800,000.
I told Dwain I would think about it. Then I told him no, the next morning, at the scale house.
He did not argue. He just nodded and said, “All right, partner. You let me know if you change your mind.” And he went back to the office and shut the door.
Eight days later, a sheriff’s deputy came for my dog.
The Deputy at My Gate
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →His name was Deputy Fussell, and he was polite. He was young, maybe twenty-six, and he looked like he would rather be anywhere else. He stood at my gate on a Tuesday afternoon with a clipboard and a printout and said the sheriff’s office had received a complaint of animal neglect at my address. A large white dog, severely underweight, kept without food or water, lying in the dirt next to a fence.
He showed me the printout. It was a color photograph of a big white dog lying on its side in red dirt next to a green pipe fence. You could see its ribs. Its hip bones stuck up. There was no water bowl in sight.
“That’s not my dog,” I said.
Walrus was standing right behind me in the yard, fat as a pumpkin, with his tail going.
The deputy looked at Walrus, and he looked at the picture, and I could see him trying to work it out. A big white dog lying down looks a lot like another big white dog lying down, to a young man who doesn’t know the breed. And the complaint was very specific. It gave my address on Route 2. It said the photograph had been taken “on multiple occasions” from the county road. It said the owner was “elderly and appears to be confused and unable to care for himself or the animal.”
“Mr. Overholt,” the deputy said, “I’ve got to follow the procedure. The complaint is sworn. I have to take the animal to the county’s contract kennel in Kingfisher until the judge can hear it. It’ll be a few days. If he’s healthy, you’ll get him back.”
I asked him who swore it. He said he could not tell me that yet. It would come out at the hearing.
It took the deputy and me both to get Walrus into the back of that county truck. He did not fight. He just would not stand up. He lay down in my yard and made himself heavy the way a Pyrenees can, and finally I had to pick up his front end and talk to him while the deputy lifted the back. When they drove off, he was looking at me through the window of the dog box, and I stood in my yard until I could not see the truck.
That was the first night since Arvella died that I slept alone in that house.
A Visit From an Old Friend
The next morning, before I had even made coffee, Dwain’s pickup came up my road.
He stood on my porch with his hat in his hand and said he had heard about my trouble. Small town. The deputy’s mama goes to his church.
“Ruble, I hate this for you,” he said. “People are going to talk. You know how they are. An old man living alone out here, dog taken off by the sheriff. Folks will start asking whether you ought to be running a business that handles their wheat. Whether you’re keeping up.”
I did not say anything.
“I know some people,” he said. “I know the sheriff. I could make a call. Help make this all go away. But you’re going to need to start thinking about what’s best for you. That offer’s still on the table.”
I stood there in my sock feet and looked at a man I had known for thirty-eight years. And I knew. I did not have one shred of proof, but I knew the way you know a storm is coming before the radio says so.
“Get off my porch, Dwain,” I said.
He put his hat on and went.
After he was gone, my hands shook so bad I could not hold my coffee. I went in and called my granddaughter.
Macy Comes Home
Macy is twenty now. She is in the second year of the veterinary technician program at the state college in Oklahoma City, and she wants to work with large animals, cattle mostly. When I told her what happened, she said, “Pawpaw, I’m coming home.” I told her she had classes. She said she had already started the car.
She got there at dark. She came in the door and hugged me and then said, “Show me the picture.”
I had the deputy’s printout. I had asked him for a copy, and he had given it to me. She sat down at the kitchen table under the light and put her glasses on and looked at it for a long time without saying anything.
Then she said, “This isn’t Walrus.”
“I know it isn’t,” I said. “But how do I prove it? It’s a white dog lying down.”
She turned the paper around toward me and put her finger on the dog’s back leg. In the picture, the dog was lying on its side with both hind legs stretched out toward the camera, and the flash or the sun had caught them, and you could see them plain.
“Look at his back feet, Pawpaw. What do you see?”
I looked. I saw a dog’s foot.
“No dewclaws,” she said. “Not one. Not two. Nothing. This dog’s back legs are smooth as a broom handle. A Great Pyrenees has two on each back leg. It’s in the breed standard. Walrus has all four of his. I’ve trimmed them myself.”
She sat back.
“Whoever this is, he is not a purebred Pyrenees. He might be part. But he is not your dog.”
I looked at that picture again. And then I looked at the fence.
The Green Pipe Fence
My place is fenced in woven wire on cedar posts. Arvella and I put it up ourselves in 1979, and it has never been anything else. There is not one stick of pipe fence on my whole quarter section.
But I knew that green pipe fence. I had painted it myself. In 2009, the summer after we put in the new truck scale at the elevator, I welded up a pipe rail around the scale house so the trucks would not clip the corner, and I painted it the only color of paint we had left in the shop, which was a bright tractor green. Dwain gave me grief about that color for fifteen years.
And I knew that dog.
Starting back in August, a skinny white dog had been hanging around the elevator. Some kind of Pyrenees cross, I always figured, mixed with something with shorter hair. Nobody knew where he came from. Somebody probably dumped him out on the highway. He was scared to death of people and would not let you near him, and he was thin, real thin. I started setting out a pan of dog food behind the scale house every morning and a bucket of water. I’d sit in the truck and watch him come slinking up to eat when he thought nobody was looking. Walrus would watch him too, from the shade, and never once barked at him.
Dwain hated that dog. He said it was going to bite a customer and get us sued. He told me twice to call the county and have it picked up, and I told him I would handle it.
I set the printout down on the kitchen table.
“Macy,” I said, “this picture wasn’t taken at my house. It was taken at the elevator. Behind the scale house. Where I feed that stray.”
She looked at me, and then she looked at the picture, and then she said a word I won’t print, and I did not correct her.
Getting Ready for Court
The hearing was set for Friday morning in front of the special district judge in Kingfisher.
I called the only lawyer I really knew, Ransom Partain, who has done every will and deed in my family since 1974. He is eighty. He listened to the whole story without interrupting once and then said, “Ruble, bring the girl. And bring your vet.”
Our vet is Dr. Wheelis, who has taken care of every animal on our place since the Reagan administration. He pulled Walrus’s chart for me. At his checkup on September 19th, three weeks before the deputy came, Walrus weighed 118 pounds and had a body condition score of five out of nine, which Dr. Wheelis said meant “ideal, maybe a touch chubby.” The chart also had a line I had never noticed. “Double hind dewclaws present, bilateral, intact.”
Macy did one more thing. On Thursday morning, she drove to the elevator before it opened and walked around behind the scale house with her phone and took pictures from every direction until she found the exact spot. The same angle on the green pipe fence. The same bent rail in the background. The same old propane tank in the corner of the frame. She held the printout up next to the real fence and took a picture of that too.
The stray was there, lying by the fence in the morning sun. When he saw Macy, he got up and trotted off. She said he looked a little better than in the picture. I had been feeding him for two months.
Friday in Kingfisher
The courtroom was small, and it was about half full, which surprised me. A lot of farmers I’d known for decades were there. Cogburn, the young fellow with the wrong test weight, was there with his wife.
Dwain was there. He sat on the far side in the second row in a pressed shirt, and he did not look at me.
The judge was a woman named Leatrice Bivens, about sixty, with reading glasses on a chain. Before anything else, she asked the deputy to read the name of the complaining party into the record, and Deputy Fussell stood up and read it.
“Dwain A. Rakestraw.”
There was a sound in that courtroom like air going out of a tire. Somebody behind me said, “His partner?”
Dwain stood up and said he wished to speak. The judge let him. He said he had brought this complaint with a heavy heart. He said he had known me for thirty-eight years and loved me like a brother, and that I had been slipping since my wife died, and that he had seen with his own eyes my dog starving at my place on multiple occasions and had taken the photograph himself from the county road to protect the animal and to protect me from myself. He said he had only wanted me to get help.
He was good. If I had not known what I knew, I might have believed him.
The judge thanked him and asked if I had anything to say.
Ransom Partain stood up, slowly, the way he does everything now, and said, “Your Honor, Mr. Overholt’s granddaughter is a student in veterinary technology. She would like to ask the court one question about the photograph.”

Count the Toes
The judge said she would allow it.
Macy stood up. Her hands were shaking. She held up the deputy’s printout and walked it up to the bench and laid it down.
“Your Honor,” she said, “would you count the toes on the back feet of the dog in this picture?”
The judge looked at her over her glasses for a second like she was not sure she’d heard right. Then she picked up the printout and looked at it.
“I see four toes on each foot,” she said. “What am I looking for?”
“Anything above the foot,” Macy said. “On the inside of the back leg.”
The judge looked again. “There’s nothing there.”
“No, ma’am,” Macy said. “Every purebred Great Pyrenees has two dewclaws on each hind leg. It’s in the breed standard. My grandfather’s dog, Walrus, has two on each back leg. It’s written in his veterinary chart from September, which Mr. Partain has. The dog in this picture has none. He is not my grandfather’s dog.”
Then Ransom handed up Dr. Wheelis’s chart, and the September weight of 118 pounds, and Macy’s pictures from Thursday morning. The real fence. The printout held up beside it. The same bent rail. The same propane tank.
“This photograph was taken behind the scale house at the Overholt and Rakestraw grain elevator in Dover,” Ransom said. “Not at Mr. Overholt’s residence. Mr. Overholt doesn’t own one foot of pipe fence. The dog in it is a stray that Mr. Overholt has been feeding there, every morning, since August. Mr. Rakestraw has asked him on two occasions to have it removed.”
The judge sat there for a moment. Then she said something I did not expect.
“Is the animal here?”
The deputy said yes, ma’am, the kennel had brought him over for the hearing. He was in the county truck outside.
“Bring him to the hallway,” the judge said. “I’d like to see for myself.”
The Judge Kneels Down
I will remember this part until they put me in the ground.
They brought Walrus up the courthouse steps on a leash. When he came through the door and saw me in that hallway, a hundred and eighteen pounds of dog went straight up on his back legs and put both front feet on my shoulders and nearly knocked me into the water fountain, and he made a sound I had never heard him make, a kind of low singing moan. I put my face in his neck and stayed there.
Judge Bivens came out of the courtroom in her robe. She knelt down right there on the hallway tile next to my dog, and she said, “May I?” and I said yes ma’am, and she lifted his back leg and parted the fur with her fingers.
Two dewclaws. Then the other leg. Two more.
She stood up and brushed off her knees and went back in.
She did not take long after that. She found that the animal seized from my residence was healthy and well cared for and ordered him released to me immediately, with the county to pay the kennel charges. She found that the photograph attached to the sworn complaint did not depict my dog or my property. Then she looked at Dwain for a long time over her glasses.
“Mr. Rakestraw, filing a false sworn complaint with a law enforcement agency is a crime in this state. I’m referring this matter to the district attorney. I would advise you to speak with a lawyer.”
Dwain left without a word. A couple of the farmers in the back moved their knees so he could get by, and none of them looked at him.
What Was in the Office
I wish that was the end of it. It was not.
Monday morning I went into the elevator office for the first time since all this started. Dwain was not there. He had called in to our bookkeeper and said he was taking some days. I sat down at his desk, which I had never done in thirty-eight years because a man’s desk is his own business, and I opened the top drawer.
There was a letter in it on the letterhead of a big farmers cooperative out of Kansas that has been buying up small elevators all over our part of the state. It was dated September 2nd. It was addressed to Dwain alone. It was a letter of intent to buy the Dover elevator, all of it, for $1,150,000, “contingent upon sole ownership being established by the seller prior to closing.”
Sole ownership.
He was going to buy my half for $90,000, then turn around and sell the whole thing for a million one fifty. And when I said no, he went and found the one thing on God’s earth that would bring me to my knees, and he tried to take it away.
Rayford drove over from Tulsa that night. He read the letter at my kitchen table and put his head in his hands. He told me later he had been on Dwain’s side, that he’d thought maybe I really was slipping, and that Dwain had been calling him all fall telling him so. Dwain had been working on my son too.

Where We Ended Up
The district attorney charged Dwain with filing a false report. He pleaded to it in the spring and paid a fine and did some community service. That was not the part that hurt him. The part that hurt him was that everybody in Kingfisher County knew.
The co-op in Kansas still wanted the elevator. Ransom Partain set up a meeting, and I sat across the table from Dwain and his new lawyer, and we sold it, together, for $1,150,000. Half to him and half to me, just like the deed has said since 1987. I did not want any more than my half. I did not want any less, either. Dwain did not shake my hand afterward, and I did not offer.
I put some of my half in an account for Macy’s school. She says she’ll pay me back. She won’t, and I’ll never ask.
I’m retired now. Turns out Dwain was right about that much. I still drive out to the elevator once in a while to sit in the truck and watch the trucks come in, and the new manager doesn’t seem to mind.
And that stray dog? He lives with me.
It took three more weeks of sitting in the truck with a pan of food before he would let me touch him. Now he sleeps on the porch on Arvella’s old rug, and in the evenings he lies on one side of the porch swing and Walrus lies on the other. He’s put on twenty-two pounds. Dr. Wheelis says he’s part Pyrenees, part something else, and he’s about four years old.
He has no dewclaws on his back legs. Not a one.
Macy named him Exhibit A. I call him Thumbs, which Macy says is a joke only a Pyrenees would get. He answers to both.
If you’ve ever been told you were “slipping” by somebody who stood to gain from it, I hope this one reminds you to look hard at the fine print, and at the fence. And if you know somebody who’s been quietly feeding a stray behind a building somewhere, share this with them. Sometimes the kindest thing you ever do ends up being the thing that saves you.
Now Trending:
- My Husband Gave Me A Bathroom Scale For Our 20th Anniversary In Front Of Our Kids And Told Me To Finally Do Something About Myself. So I Walked Out To My Car And Brought Back The Gift I Had Been Saving For Him
- A Week After Mom Died, My Brother And I Found 28 Packages Stacked Outside Her Apartment Door. She Had Never Ordered Anything Online In Her Life, And One Box Had An Instruction Taped To The Top For The Two Of Us
- Days Before I Gave Birth, My Best Friend From The Orphanage Knocked On My Door For The First Time In 13 Years And Said, ‘Your Husband Isn’t Who He Pretends To Be.’ Then He Showed Me A Video On His Shaking Phone
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
