Off The Record
My Stepdaughter Pulled A New Will Out Of Her Purse At My Husband’s Funeral Lunch And Said He Signed It At Our Kitchen Table On April 12. On April 12 He Was 140 Miles Away Blowing A Whistle For Our Old Boykin Spaniel, And I Had The Ribbon To Prove It
I was fifty-seven years old when I married Coy Truluck, and his daughter wore black to the wedding.
I don’t say that to be ugly. I say it because it tells you about where things stood from the very first day. Dacey was thirty-seven then, and her mama had been gone five years, and she did not want anybody new in her daddy’s house. I understood that. I had lost my own mother young. I thought if I was patient and kind and never once tried to take her mama’s place, she would come around in time.
I had twelve years. She never did.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →Coy and I met at a fish fry at the volunteer fire department in Bethune, South Carolina, where he had lived his whole life. I was a widow, retired from managing the cafeteria at the middle school in Bishopville for twenty-six years. He was a widower who raised a few cows on fifty-two acres off Pine Log Road and spent most of his free time training bird dogs. He asked me if I wanted the last hushpuppy. I said only if he split it with me. Two years later we were married at the county courthouse with his brother and my sister for witnesses, and Dacey sitting in the back row in a black dress.
She called me “Daddy’s friend” for the first three years. After that she called me Merlene, when she called me anything.

A Little Brown Dog From South Carolina
The year after we married, Coy brought home a puppy from a breeder down near Lugoff. A Boykin spaniel.
If you are not from South Carolina, you might not know them. They are our state dog. Little, sturdy, chocolate-brown spaniels with curly ears and gold eyes, bred a hundred years ago by men who hunted ducks out of small boats on the Wateree River and needed a dog that could fit in the boat and not tip it over. They love water. They love birds. And if they love you, they love you completely.
Coy named him Toddy, after the hot toddy his granddaddy used to make on cold duck-hunting mornings.
That dog was Coy’s shadow for ten years. He rode in the truck. He slept under the kitchen table, on Coy’s feet, every single morning while Coy drank his coffee. When Coy went out to check the cows, Toddy went. When Coy went to the feed store, Toddy went. I used to say I married a man and got a dog for a chaperone.
And every spring, Coy ran Toddy in hunt tests.
A hunt test, if you don’t know, is a kind of exam for hunting dogs. The judges set out a course with duck decoys and a pond and some cover, and they throw birds, and the dog has to watch where they fall and go get them and bring them back to the handler’s hand. There is no first place or second place. Either your dog passes or he doesn’t. If he passes, the club gives you a ribbon.
Coy loved it. It was his one vacation. Every April we would load Toddy in his crate and drive somewhere in the Lowcountry and spend a night in a motel, and Coy would stand at the edge of some pond with his whistle and his old tan field jacket, and I would stand behind the rope with the other wives and hold my breath. Toddy got his first ribbon when he was two. By the time he was ten, we had a whole row of them tacked up over the kitchen door.
I want you to remember that row of ribbons. And I want you to remember that Toddy slept under the kitchen table every morning of his life.
The Funeral Lunch
Coy died this past August, in his sleep, at seventy-eight. He had been tired for a while. The doctor said his heart just stopped. I woke up and he was gone, and Toddy was lying on the floor by his side of the bed with his chin on Coy’s slipper and would not move.
The service was at the Methodist church in Bethune, and afterward the ladies had a lunch for the family in the fellowship hall. Chicken bog and deviled eggs and pound cake. Dacey sat at the head of the table with her husband and her two grown boys. I sat at the other end with my sister.
When people were starting to clear the plates, Dacey stood up and tapped her tea glass with a fork.
She said she was sorry to do this on such a hard day, but she thought it was best that everybody knew where things stood, so there would not be any confusion later. Then she reached into her purse and took out a long white envelope and took out some folded papers.
“Daddy made a new will this spring,” she said. “He signed it at the kitchen table at the house on April 12th. Kristal and Delano Starnes were the witnesses, and it’s notarized. He left the house and the land to me. Merlene gets ten thousand dollars and ninety days to make other arrangements.”
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →Then she sat down.
You could have heard a deviled egg drop. My sister grabbed my hand under the table so hard she left marks.
Coy had a will. I knew he had a will, because I sat beside him in Mr. Funderburk’s office in Bishopville in 2019 when he made it. It said I could live in the house and on the land for the rest of my life, and when I passed, it would all go to Dacey. The savings would be split between us down the middle. Coy wanted it that way. He said, “Merlene, you’ve earned a roof, and Dacey’s mama’s people farmed that land since 1881. It ought to end up with her.” I agreed with him. I still do.
He never said one word to me about a new will. Not one.
April 12
I did not sleep that night. I sat at the kitchen table where Dacey said Coy had signed away my home, and Toddy lay under the table on my feet the way he used to lie on Coy’s, and I tried to remember April 12th.
April. Spring. I got up and looked at the calendar on the side of the refrigerator, which was still on August, and I flipped it back. April 12th was a Saturday.
And on April 12th, in Coy’s square block printing, it said: “TODDY. YEMASSEE. LEAVE FRI NOON.”
I sat down on the kitchen floor. Toddy came out from under the table and climbed in my lap like he was a puppy and not a forty-pound dog, and I held on to him and cried for the first time since the funeral.
Because I remembered. I remembered all of it.
A Saturday in the Lowcountry
On Friday, April 11th, we left the house at noon. I packed pimento cheese sandwiches. Coy drove the whole way with the window cracked so Toddy could smell the air from his crate in the back. We stopped at a gas station outside Orangeburg and Coy bought me a peach soda. We checked into a little motel in Walterboro around four, and Coy walked Toddy along the edge of the parking lot and talked to him about the test the next day, the way he always did. He believed the dog understood. Maybe he did.
On Saturday morning we were up at five. The test was at a hunting club on an old plantation outside Yemassee, about 140 miles from our house. Coy checked in at the registration table at 7:40. I know because he signed the sheet. The handlers sign in so the judges know who is there. His run was at 9:50 at the big pond. I stood behind the rope with a thermos of coffee.
Toddy was ten years old, and his back legs were not what they used to be, and Coy had told me in the truck that this would probably be the last time. That if the dog did not pass, that was all right, he had nothing left to prove.
The judge raised his hand. The bird went up. The shot. The bird came down way out in the cattails on the far side, and Toddy went into that pond like he was two years old.
He brought it back to Coy’s hand. Then he did it again. Then he did a blind retrieve, where the dog does not see the bird fall and the handler has to steer him there with whistle and hand signals, and I watched my husband stand at the edge of that pond and blow two short blasts on his whistle and point, and that little brown dog turned in the water and swam exactly where Coy pointed.
He passed. At seventy-seven, with a ten-year-old dog, Coy Truluck stood at the edge of a pond in the Lowcountry and cried in front of a bunch of men he didn’t know, and they all came over and shook his hand.
The club secretary took our picture. Coy and me and Toddy, soaking wet, with the blue ribbon. It was 10:14 in the morning. I know that because she posted it on the club’s Facebook page, and I had saved it on my phone, and the phone tells you the time.
At 10:14 on Saturday, April 12th, my husband was standing at the edge of a pond 140 miles from our kitchen table, holding a ribbon.
The Lawyer in Bishopville
Mr. Funderburk is seventy-four and still practices out of the same office over the hardware store in Bishopville where he drew up Coy’s will in 2019. I went to see him on Monday morning with a shoebox.
In the box I had the blue ribbon off the nail over the kitchen door. I had the motel receipt from Walterboro, which I found in the glove box of Coy’s truck. I had the gas station receipt from outside Orangeburg, which was in Coy’s jacket pocket, because Coy never threw a receipt away in his life. I had my phone with the club secretary’s picture. And I had the calendar.
Mr. Funderburk had already gotten a copy of Dacey’s will from the probate court, because she had filed it the Friday after the funeral. He laid it on his desk and turned it so I could see the last page.
It said, “Signed, sealed, published and declared by the above-named testator, Coy E. Truluck, as and for his Last Will and Testament, in our presence, at his residence, 418 Pine Log Road, Bethune, South Carolina, on this the 12th day of April, at approximately 10:00 a.m.”
There was Coy’s signature, or something that looked a lot like it. There were the two witnesses’ names, Kristal Starnes and Delano Starnes. And there was a notary stamp from a woman named Shonda Gaddy.
I did not know Kristal and Delano Starnes very well. Kristal had been Dacey’s best friend since high school. I had met her maybe four times.
I had never heard of Shonda Gaddy.
Mr. Funderburk put his glasses on and looked through everything in my shoebox. He looked at the picture of Coy and me and the dog on my phone for a long time. Then he said, “Mrs. Truluck, I’d like to borrow this ribbon.”
Probate Court
The hearing on the will was in the probate court in the county seat, the second week of October.
Judge Tallent is a heavyset man in his sixties with a gentle voice who has been probate judge since before Coy and I married. Dacey sat at one table with her lawyer, a young man from Columbia in a very good suit. I sat at the other with Mr. Funderburk, who wore the same brown suit he wears to everything. Toddy was at home with my sister, and I missed him so bad my hands hurt.
Dacey’s lawyer called Kristal Starnes first.
Kristal was nervous, but she had her story straight. She said she and her husband Delano drove out to the house on the morning of Saturday, April 12th, around nine-thirty, because Dacey had asked them to witness some papers for her daddy. She said Coy was sitting at the kitchen table in his overalls having his coffee. She said he read the papers over and said he wanted to make sure his little girl was taken care of. He signed, and they signed.
“And was Mrs. Merlene Truluck present?”
“No, sir,” Kristal said. “Mr. Coy said she’d gone to the grocery store.”
Dacey’s lawyer sat down. Mr. Funderburk stood up, and he took his time.
“Mrs. Starnes,” he said, “you said Mr. Truluck was sitting at the kitchen table having his coffee. Can you tell the court anything else about that morning? Anything at all you remember about the kitchen?”
Kristal thought. You could tell she wanted to be helpful. She wanted to be believed.
“Well,” she said, “the little brown dog was there. Toddy. He was lying under the table on Mr. Coy’s feet. He always was. Dacey always said that dog was glued to her daddy.”
I heard Dacey make a small sound at the other table.
“Under the table,” Mr. Funderburk said. “On Mr. Truluck’s feet. At about ten o’clock in the morning on Saturday, April 12th. You’re certain.”
“Yes, sir. I remember because I bent down and petted him.”

The Blue Ribbon
Mr. Funderburk walked back to our table and picked up the shoebox.
He took out the blue ribbon first and handed it up to the judge. Then the scoresheet, which he had gotten from the hunting club’s secretary, a lady named Verdie Pressley, who had driven all the way up from Hampton County that morning and was sitting in the back of the courtroom in her Sunday hat. The scoresheet showed handler Coy Truluck and dog Toddy, registered and signed in at 7:40 a.m. at Yemassee, run at 9:50 a.m., passed. Then the motel receipt. Then the gas station receipt. Then the photograph, printed out large, with Mrs. Pressley’s sworn statement that she took it at 10:14 a.m.
“Your Honor,” Mr. Funderburk said, “at ten o’clock in the morning on Saturday, April 12th, Coy Truluck was standing at the edge of a duck pond outside Yemassee, a hundred and forty miles from his kitchen table, blowing a whistle at that dog. And that dog, who according to the witness was lying under the kitchen table in Bethune getting petted, was swimming across a pond in Colleton County with a duck in his mouth.”
Mrs. Pressley stood up in the back. “That’s right, Judge,” she said. “I’ve got forty people who saw him do it. The whole club cried.”
The judge looked at the photograph for a long time. Coy, soaking wet to the knees, grinning. Me, holding the ribbon. Toddy between us, dripping, looking up at Coy like he hung the moon.
Then Judge Tallent asked if the notary was present.
The Notary
Shonda Gaddy was present. Dacey’s lawyer had subpoenaed her to establish that the will was properly notarized. She was about forty, and she worked with Dacey at the bank branch in Columbia, and she had not looked up from her lap once since she came in.
The judge asked her, kindly, to come forward. He asked her where she was when she notarized the will.
She said at the bank.
He asked her if Coy Truluck had been present when she put her stamp on it.
There was a long, long silence. Then Shonda Gaddy started to cry.
She said Dacey brought the papers into the bank on the Tuesday after, already signed, and told her that her daddy was too sick to come all the way to Columbia, and could Shonda please just stamp it, because Dacey was afraid her stepmother was going to take everything. Shonda said she knew she was not supposed to. She said Dacey was her friend, and Dacey was crying, and she thought she was helping a daughter protect her daddy’s land.
“I never met the man,” she said. “I’m so sorry. I never once met him.”
Judge Tallent thanked her. He told her she would want to talk to a lawyer of her own.
Then he looked over at Kristal Starnes, who had gone white as a sheet, and asked her if she would like to say anything else about the morning of April 12th. She looked at Dacey. Then she looked at the floor and said, “No, sir. I’d like to talk to a lawyer too.”
What Dacey Said in the Hallway
The judge found that the April document was not the valid will of Coy Truluck, and he admitted Coy’s 2019 will to probate. Exactly what Coy wanted. He referred the matter to the solicitor’s office.
I expected to feel like I’d won. I didn’t. I felt like I’d been to another funeral.
Dacey caught me in the hallway outside the courtroom. Her lawyer was trying to steer her toward the door, and she shook him off and came straight at me, and I thought for a second she was going to hit me.
She didn’t. She stood in front of me shaking and said, “That was my mama’s land. My mama’s people farmed it since 1881. You were going to live on it till you died and I was going to be sixty-five years old before I could set foot on it without asking you.”
“Dacey,” I said, “you never once asked.”
She stared at me.
“Not one time in twelve years did you ask to come out there. Your daddy waited for you every Christmas. He bought a ham every Easter because you used to like ham. I would have handed you the key.”
She started crying then. Not the angry kind. The other kind. Her husband came and put his arm around her and took her out to the car, and I stood in that hallway with my shoebox under my arm and Mrs. Pressley patting my back.

The Kitchen Table
The solicitor’s office let Dacey go into a pretrial program because she had never been in trouble before, and because I wrote them a letter. Mr. Funderburk thought I was crazy. Maybe I was. But I kept thinking about Coy, and about who he would want me to be, and I knew he would not want his only child to have a record because she was jealous of me.
The program had conditions. Restitution of my legal fees. Community service. A class. And something I asked for, that the solicitor said was unusual but he would put it in: she had to come out to the house once a month for six months and have Sunday dinner with me.
The first time she came, she sat in her car in the driveway for twenty minutes. I watched from the kitchen window. Finally she came in and sat down at the kitchen table across from me, stiff as a board, and neither one of us said anything.
Then Toddy came out from under the table and put his chin on her knee.
He’s eleven now. He’s slowing down. He did not have to get up. But he walked over and laid his head on her knee and looked up at her with those gold eyes, the way he used to look up at Coy, and Dacey put her hand on his head and started to cry, and said, “He smells like Daddy’s truck.”
We’ve had five of those Sunday dinners now. She talks a little more each time. Last month she asked if she could walk the back forty where her mama’s daddy used to plant cotton. I said she didn’t have to ask. She went out there for two hours. When she came back, she had red clay on her shoes and her eyes were swollen, and she asked if she could take one of Coy’s ribbons home.
I let her pick. She took the one from April 12th.
If you’re the second wife, or the stepmother, or the one who came along late and never got let all the way in, I see you, and I hope this story finds you. And if there’s somebody in your family who has kept their distance for too long, maybe pass this along to them. Sometimes all it takes is a dog under the table and an empty chair.
Now Trending:
- My Husband Gave Me A Bathroom Scale For Our 20th Anniversary In Front Of Our Kids And Told Me To Finally Do Something About Myself. So I Walked Out To My Car And Brought Back The Gift I Had Been Saving For Him
- My Business Partner Of 38 Years Offered Me $90,000 For My Half Of Our Grain Elevator, And When I Said No, He Reported My Old Dog As Starving And Had Him Hauled Off. At The Hearing, My Granddaughter Asked The Judge To Count The Toes On The Dog In His Photo
- Days Before I Gave Birth, My Best Friend From The Orphanage Knocked On My Door For The First Time In 13 Years And Said, ‘Your Husband Isn’t Who He Pretends To Be.’ Then He Showed Me A Video On His Shaking Phone
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
