Off The Record
The Bass Club President Accused My 74-Year-Old Husband Of Cheating In Front Of The Whole Lake And Kept His $12,000 Prize. Then Our Old Chesapeake Kept Diving Under Our Own Dock Every Morning Until He Dragged Up A Rope
My husband Thurl fished the Bluff Fork Fall Classic forty times and never won it.
He came in second four times. He came in third more times than I can count. He finished out of the money plenty of years too, and he always drove home the same way, with the windows down and the radio off, and he’d say, “Well, Merline, the fish had other plans.” Then he’d clean the boat and eat a bowl of chili and go to bed happy. That was Thurl. He did not need to win. He just needed to be out there.
We live on a cove on the north arm of Sycamore Bend Lake, about twenty minutes out of Hermitage, Missouri. Thurl climbed poles for the electric co-op for thirty-three years. I ran the cafeteria at the elementary school for twenty-six. We bought this lot in 1981 with a single-wide on it and a dock that leaned, and over the years the single-wide turned into a real house and the dock got straightened out, and we raised one boy here and buried two good dogs out by the redbud tree.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →The third dog is Tugboat. He’s a Chesapeake Bay retriever, eleven years old, dark brown and wavy as a doormat, with yellow eyes that look right through you. He weighs eighty-four pounds and he thinks he’s a lap dog. Thurl got him off a man in Clinton who was moving to an apartment, and from the first week that dog would not let Thurl go out on the water without him. He rides in the bow of the boat like a hood ornament. When Thurl sets the hook, Tugboat stands up. When Thurl lands a fish, Tugboat sneezes. I have no idea why. He has done it for eleven years.
The Bluff Fork Bass Club started in 1979 with nine men in a bait shop, and Thurl was one of the nine. Now there are about sixty members and the Fall Classic is the big event. Two days, the third weekend of October, five fish a day, and this year the first prize was $12,000 between the entry fees and what the marina and the feed store put in. That is a lot of money for a little club. It is more than our property taxes and our truck insurance put together.

Twenty-Four Pounds, Nine Ounces
Thurl went out on Saturday morning at a quarter to six with Tugboat in the bow and came back that afternoon with a limit that weighed twelve pounds and change. Good, not great. He was sitting sixth.
On Sunday he went back to a rocky point he has fished since Jimmy Carter was president, and about ten in the morning he hooked a largemouth that weighed seven pounds and two ounces. I wasn’t there, but a boy from the marina was fishing the next point over and he said that when Thurl lifted that fish into the boat, Tugboat sneezed so hard he nearly went over the side.
At the weigh-in that afternoon at the marina, Thurl’s two-day total came to twenty-four pounds and nine ounces. He won by a pound and a half.
I have been married to that man for fifty-one years and I had never seen him cry in public, not even at his mother’s funeral. He cried at that scale. He took his cap off and held it against his chest and just stood there, and people clapped, and old men he’d fished with since the seventies came up and slapped him on the back. They handed him one of those big cardboard checks and took his picture with Tugboat sitting at his feet, and I was crying too and I didn’t care who saw.
The man who came in second was Blaine Hargis.
The Man in Second Place
Blaine is fifty-eight. He owns Hargis Marine out on the highway, where half the people in this county have bought a boat at one time or another. He has been president of the bass club for eleven years. He had won the Fall Classic six of the last eight years, and he had his picture on the wall of the marina six times, always holding a big fish up by the lip with his teeth showing.
He was perfectly friendly that afternoon. He shook Thurl’s hand. He said, “About time, old man.” He even posed for one of the pictures.
Then at eight o’clock that night, while Thurl was asleep in his recliner with the cardboard check propped against the television, Blaine’s wife called me.
She said Blaine wanted me to know, as a friend, that the club board would be meeting on Tuesday. There had been “some concerns” about Thurl’s big fish. She said it the way people say somebody has a spot on an X-ray.
Tuesday Night at the Marina
The board was five men. Blaine sat in the middle.
He did most of the talking. He said that a seven-pound fish was “highly unusual” for Sycamore Bend in October. He said the fish had “worn fins,” which he said was a sign it had been kept in a pen. He said he did not want to believe it of a charter member, but the rules were the rules, and he had a responsibility to the sixty members who paid their entry fees in good faith.
Then he brought in his brother-in-law, a man named Rondal Shadrick. Rondal stood up and said that on Sunday morning at about four o’clock, before the boats were allowed to launch, he was driving the lake road to go to work at the chicken plant and he saw a boat sitting right off Thurl’s dock in the dark. He said he figured it had to be Thurl’s.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →Thurl said, “I was in my bed at four o’clock, Rondal. Ask my wife.”
Blaine said, kindly, “Thurl, with respect, a wife isn’t a witness.”
They voted four to one. The one was a retired mail carrier who has known us forever and who looked sick to his stomach. Thurl was disqualified from the Classic. He was suspended from the club for life. The first prize went to the second-place finisher.
That was Blaine.
How a Small Town Hears Things
By Thursday the whole north end of the county knew.
You’d think it wouldn’t matter much. It’s a fishing club. But Thurl has been a deacon at Bethel Baptist since 1988. He has coached Little League. He has never in his life owed a man a dollar he did not pay back by the end of the week. And now when he walked into the café for coffee, the table of men he’d sat with for twenty years got quiet.
Somebody posted about it on the county swap page. I won’t repeat what they wrote. One woman I taught to make yeast rolls in a church class said in a comment that she had always thought he was “a little too good to be true.”
Our son called from Kansas City. Our boy is forty-six and a pharmacist and a good man, but he asked his daddy, very carefully, “Dad, is there any chance you made a mistake? Maybe kept a fish in the live well overnight without thinking about it?”
Thurl said, “No, son.” And then he handed me the phone and went outside.
He stopped fishing. That was the part that scared me. He did not go out the next morning or the morning after that. He put the boat under its cover. For the first time in eleven years, Tugboat stood at the end of our dock at daylight and waited, and nobody came.
At night, Thurl would go out and sit in the cab of his pickup in the driveway with the engine off. I’d look out the kitchen window at ten, eleven o’clock and see the shape of him in there, just sitting. Tugboat sat on the bench seat next to him. I’d take a quilt out and Thurl would say, “I’m all right, honey. I’m just thinking.” But he wasn’t thinking. He was ashamed of something he didn’t do, and there is no worse feeling for a proud old man.
The Dog Goes Fishing Alone
About ten days after the board meeting, I got up at six and Tugboat was gone.
His bed by the woodstove was empty. The screen door on the porch was pushed open, because he learned years ago how to work it with his nose. I went down to the dock in my robe and there he was, swimming slow circles around the far end of our own dock in the gray light, putting his whole head under the water and blowing like a whale when he came up.
He climbed the ladder and shook himself all over my slippers. He smelled terrible. Not like lake water. Like the bottom of a live well on a hot day.
The next morning he did it again. And the next. Always the same place, the last float at the end of the dock, where the water drops off to about eight feet.
Thurl barely noticed. I’d say, “Your dog’s out there diving again,” and he’d say, “He’s old and he misses the boat. Let him do what he wants.”
But I wanted to know. Tugboat had swum off that dock every summer of his life and he had never once cared what was under it.
Under Our Own Dock
On the fifth morning I made Thurl come down with me. He grumbled the whole way. I had my yellow fleece on over my nightgown and he had his old olive jacket and his cap, and the mist was lying on the cove so thick you could barely see Blaine Hargis’s big gray dock across the water, three hundred yards off, with its boat lift and its floodlights. Blaine’s lake house sits right across the cove from us. It always has.
Tugboat went straight down the ladder and swam to the end float and went under. He came up and blew and went under again. His back legs were churning like a paddle wheel.
Thurl said, “Tugboat, leave it,” and the dog ignored him. Tugboat does not ignore Thurl.
When he came up the third time he had a rope in his mouth. A dark green rope, the kind that sinks. He swam to the ladder with it and I knelt down on the boards and took hold of it, and it was heavy, and it was tied off somewhere down underneath our float where you would never see it from the dock or the shore.
I pulled and Tugboat pulled, and up out of that cold water came a fish basket. One of those tall collapsible ones, green mesh stretched over wire rings, the kind people hang off a dock to keep their catch alive. It was cinched shut at the top.
There were four bass in it. Big ones. Every one of them was bigger than any fish Thurl had brought home in fifty-one years, except the one he caught that Sunday.
Thurl just stood there behind me. I have never seen the color go out of a man’s face so fast.
He said, “Merline, that’s not mine.”
I said, “I know it’s not yours, honey.”
A Camera From the Tackle Box
I didn’t open the basket. I didn’t untie anything. I had enough sense for that.
What I had was Thurl’s old disposable camera. He has kept one in his tackle box for twenty years, because he doesn’t trust his phone near the water. He went and got it, and I took every picture left on that roll. The basket. The rope. The fish. The knot down under the float, as best I could get it. Tugboat standing on the dock with that green rope still in his mouth, soaking wet, looking at me like he was waiting for his biscuit.
Then we let it all back down into the water exactly where it had been, and we went up to the house, and Thurl sat down at the kitchen table and didn’t say a word for a long time.
Then he said, “He’s been keeping them under my dock.”
What Thurl Knew About Pens
My husband is not a quick talker, but he is not a slow thinker either.
He got out the lake map and his coffee and he said, “If I was going to win the Classic every year, here’s how I’d do it.” And he explained.
You catch big fish all summer, whenever you can, wherever you can. You don’t release them. You put them in baskets and cages hidden where nobody would look. You feed them. Then on tournament morning, before anybody’s allowed on the water, you go around in the dark and load your live well. You don’t need to catch a thing all day. You ride around and look busy and come back to the scale with fish you caught in August.
“And the best place to hide one,” Thurl said, “is under the dock of an old man who goes to bed at nine o’clock and can’t hear a trolling motor anymore. Because if anybody ever finds it, whose dock is it under?”
Then he said the thing that made me put my cup down.
“Rondal didn’t lie, Merline. He did see a boat by my place at four o’clock Sunday morning. He just didn’t see me in it.”
I said, “Thurl, you have to take this to the club.”
He said, “The club is Blaine.”
Agent Fentress
So I took it to the state.
The conservation agent for our county is a woman named Sonja Fentress. She’s about forty, with a long braid and a voice like a school principal, and she has checked Thurl’s fishing license probably three hundred times. I called her office at the Department of Conservation and I said I needed to talk to her about something I’d seen on the lake, and she came out that afternoon.
I gave her the disposable camera. She drove it to a drugstore in Warsaw that still develops film and she came back the next day with the prints. She looked at them for a long time at my kitchen table. Tugboat sat with his head on her boot.
She said, “Mrs. Ogle, I’m going to ask you and your husband not to touch that basket again, and not to say a word about this to anybody. Not your son, not your preacher, not the ladies at the café.”
I said, “How long?”
She said, “Until I’ve got him.”
The Fish With the Crooked Jaw
What I didn’t know, and what Sonja told us later, was that she had been hearing rumbles about Blaine for two years. Other fishermen, younger ones, had said things. Nobody could ever prove anything.
She took my pictures to a fisheries biologist the department uses, a man named Dr. Winfrey Tarver in Springfield. He enlarged them. Then he went back through six years of the bass club’s weigh-in photographs, the ones that hang at the marina and get posted online, every picture of Blaine holding up a big fish with his teeth showing.
A largemouth bass has a pattern of dark blotches along its side, a little like a fingerprint. Dr. Tarver found the same fish in Blaine’s hands three times. Once in the 2023 Fall Classic, once in a spring tournament in 2024, and once in the 2025 Classic. A six-and-a-half-pound bass with a crooked lower jaw, from an old hook injury, that Blaine had “caught” and released at the marina and then somehow caught again, in a lake of twenty-two thousand acres, two more times.
And in my photograph of the basket under our own dock, there it was, fourth fish from the left, crooked jaw and all.

Four O’Clock in the Morning
The club had one more tournament on the calendar, the Gobbler Open, the Saturday before Thanksgiving. It’s a small one, but there’s a $3,000 pot.
Sonja asked if she could use our driveway.
At half past three that Saturday morning, she sat in the cab of Thurl’s pickup with Thurl behind the wheel and Tugboat on the bench seat between them. The truck was backed up under the cedars where you could see straight down the yard to the dock. The engine was off and the lights were off, and they had a thermos of my coffee and a pair of binoculars. I wasn’t allowed to come out. I watched through the kitchen window with the lights off. Two other agents were sitting in a boat with no lights around the point, and a deputy was parked up the lake road.
At ten till four, Tugboat stood up on the seat and stared out the windshield and made a low noise in his chest that Thurl said he had never once heard him make.
A boat was coming across the cove with no running lights, just the hum of a trolling motor. It slid in under the end of our dock. A man with a headlamp turned to red, the way hunters do, leaned out over the side and felt along under our float and started hauling up a rope.
Thurl told me afterward that he wanted to get out of that truck and walk down there with a boat paddle. Sonja put her hand on his arm and said, “Let him load the boat, Mr. Ogle. I need him to load the boat.”
Blaine loaded the boat. Then he motored up the arm without lights to a private point where Rondal’s mother owns the shoreline, and pulled up a second basket. That’s where the agents in the dark boat lit him up with a spotlight.
He had nine bass in his live well at a quarter past four in the morning, two hours before legal launch time. The fish with the crooked jaw was one of them.
What It Cost Him
I will tell you the rest quick, because the rest is mostly paperwork.
Blaine was charged by the county prosecutor with attempted stealing by deceit for the Gobbler Open, and with wildlife code violations for the penned fish. Once Dr. Tarver’s photographs came out, the club’s sponsors went back through the records. Between the Fall Classics and the smaller events, Blaine had taken home $41,600 in prize money over six years.
Rondal came to our door the week after. He stood on the porch with his hat in his hands and his eyes red. He said he had seen a boat at our dock that morning, all right, and he had known right then from the shape of it that it was Blaine’s. Blaine told him that if anybody asked, it was Thurl’s, and that family looks after family. He said, “I’m sorry, Mr. Ogle. He’s my wife’s brother. I didn’t think it would go this far.”
Thurl looked at him a long time and then said, “Well, it went this far, Rondal.” And he shook his hand anyway, because that is who my husband is.
Blaine pleaded guilty in February. He paid back every dollar of the prize money to the club and to the men he beat, he paid a fine, and he is banned from every sanctioned tournament in the state of Missouri. He resigned from the club before they could vote him out. Hargis Marine is still out on the highway. I hear business is slow.
The Twelve Thousand Dollars
The club held a special meeting in March. Sixty men and about twenty wives packed into the back room of the marina. The retired mail carrier who voted no that night made the motion. Thurl’s disqualification was reversed and his suspension was wiped off the books, unanimous, and they handed him a new cardboard check for $12,000 and a real check for the same amount.
Then somebody moved that Thurl be made club president. Everybody said yes before he could open his mouth.
He stood up and said, “No, thank you. I’m seventy-four and I just want to fish.” And they laughed, and he sat down. But then he stood back up and said, “I’ll tell you who ought to be an honorary member,” and he pointed at the door.
Tugboat was lying across the threshold like a rug, because they wouldn’t let him in the room.
They voted on that too. It was unanimous.
Back on the Water
Our son drove down from Kansas City for that meeting. Afterward, out in the parking lot, he hugged his daddy and held on a long time and said, “I should have known better than to ask you that.” Thurl said, “You asked because you love me. That’s all right.” But I saw our boy’s face. He’ll remember it.
The ladies from the café brought a pie. The woman from my yeast roll class did not, but she did delete her comment.
Thurl gave $2,000 of the money to the conservation department’s youth fishing program, the one Sonja runs in the summers for kids who don’t have a granddaddy with a boat. He put some aside for the truck. The rest he spent on a new trolling motor and a big orthopedic dog bed with a waterproof cover, because Tugboat is still swimming every morning, and his hips aren’t what they were.
The picture on the marina wall now is a different one. It’s Thurl at the scale with his cap against his chest, and an old brown dog sitting on his boot with his eyes shut, halfway into a sneeze.

Daylight on the Cove
Every morning at a quarter to six, Thurl goes down to the dock with Tugboat. He doesn’t fish every day anymore. Some days he just sits in the boat with his coffee and watches the mist come off the cove. But he goes.
The big gray dock across the water has a For Sale sign on it now. Tugboat still swims a circle around the end of our float every morning, just to check. There’s nothing down there anymore but cold water and an old tire Thurl lost in 1994.
I’ve thought a lot about how easy it was for one man with a title to take away what my husband spent seventy-four years building. Four votes and a brother-in-law. That’s all it took. And I’ve thought about how the truth came back up. Not from the club, not from the board, not from the men at the café who’d known him since they were boys. It came up out of eight feet of cold water on the end of a green rope, in the mouth of a dog who was just tired of waiting on the end of the dock for his best friend.
Thurl says Tugboat knew all along. I don’t know about that. But I know what that dog does every time Thurl lands a fish now.
He sneezes.
If you know an older man or woman who’s been talked about lately, and the story never quite sat right with you, maybe go sit with them a while and ask what really happened. And if this one made you think of somebody who never needed a trophy to be the best person on the water, pass it along to them.
Now Trending:
- My Mother-In-Law Came To See The Grandkids, Not Knowing Her Son Had Left Us Six Months Ago. When My Daughter Blurted Out The Truth, She Took Our Wedding Photo Off The Shelf And Said, “He’s Been Calling Me All These Months”
- I Paid Off My Condo At 3:42 P.M. When I Got Home, My Sister-In-Law Opened The Door In My Nightgown And Said, “Mom Transferred This Condo Into My Name. Get Out.”
- My Parents Skipped My Stanford PhD Graduation Because My Brother’s MBA “Actually Mattered.” Two Years Later, They Flew In For His Ceremony And Watched The Dean Call My Name As The Keynote Speaker
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
