Connect with us

Our Neighbor Told The Insurance Company My 76-Year-Old Husband’s Brush Fire Burned Down His Hay Barn And Sued Us For $94,000. Then Our Old Heeler Kept Coming Home With Tractor Grease On Her Coat, So One Night We Followed Her To A Shed On His Back Forty

Off The Record

Our Neighbor Told The Insurance Company My 76-Year-Old Husband’s Brush Fire Burned Down His Hay Barn And Sued Us For $94,000. Then Our Old Heeler Kept Coming Home With Tractor Grease On Her Coat, So One Night We Followed Her To A Shed On His Back Forty

Every November for fifty years, my husband Lafe has burned his brush pile the same way.

He waits for a good soaking rain, and then he waits two more days. He drags the green garden hose all the way out past the hog lot and lays it on the ground beside him like a snake he trusts. He rakes a ring of bare dirt around the pile, six feet wide. He calls the county dispatcher in Liberty and tells her his name and his road, and she says, “All right, Mr. Gillum, holler if you need us,” the way she has said it since she was a teenager answering phones for her daddy. Then he lights it, and he stands there with a rake until there’s nothing left but a gray circle, and he soaks that circle until it steams.

My name is Melba Gillum. I am seventy-two years old. Lafe is seventy-six. We have a hundred and twelve acres on Gilpin Ridge Road in Casey County, Kentucky, about six miles out of Liberty, and most of it goes up and down, the way land does around here. Lafe drove a road grader for the county for thirty-one years. I kept books for the farm supply store until they sold it to a chain. We run a few Angus cows and keep a big garden and raised one son, Alton, who lives in Lexington now and sells software to hospitals,.

And we have Soot.

Soot is an Australian cattle dog, a blue heeler, eleven years old. Her coat is that speckled gray that looks like the inside of a woodstove, which is how she got her name, and she has a black patch over her left eye like a little pirate. She weighs thirty-eight pounds and believes she owns every cow, every truck and every human being in Casey County. She rides in the cab of Lafe’s pickup standing up on the bench seat between us, with her front feet braced, staring out the windshield like she’s the one driving. If Lafe goes to the barn, Soot goes.

The Man Who Bought the Coffey Place

In 2015 old Mr. Coffey died, and his place next to ours went up for auction. The man who bought it was Gaylon Stidham.

Everybody in Casey County knows Gaylon, or thinks they do. He is sixty-one. He owns Stidham Auction and Realty out on the bypass, and on Saturdays you can hear him calling a sale from half a mile away, that fast rolling chant that sounds like a song with no words in it. He is a deacon at a big church in town. The first Christmas after he moved in, he brought us a whole country ham.

He tore down Mr. Coffey’s old tobacco barn and put up a big red hay barn by the road, the kind with white trim that people stop and take pictures of. He kept round bales in one end, and in the other end he kept what he called his collection. Two old Farmall tractors he’d had restored, red as fire engines. A 1956 pickup. A brand-new round baler that cost more than our house. One of those side-by-side buggies with a roof on it.

Twice, he asked to buy our forty acres of creek bottom. The bottom is the best ground we have. It joins his on the north side and has a good spring on it that has never once gone dry. The first time he offered, Lafe said no thank you. The second time, Gaylon smiled and said, “Well, Lafe, none of us are getting any younger. You think about it.” Lafe came in the house and said, “I don’t like a man who tells me how old I am.”

The Night the Sky Turned Orange

On Tuesday, October the fourteenth, Lafe burned his brush pile.

It had rained an inch and a half the Saturday before. He called dispatch at one in the afternoon. He had it lit by quarter after one and it was down to coals by four. I took him a glass of tea at four-thirty and he was standing there spraying the ashes, with Soot lying in the grass at his feet. By supper it was a black wet circle, cold enough that he kicked through the middle of it with his boot to show me.

The pile sits out in the open on the south side of our hog lot. Gaylon’s barn was about six hundred yards away, on the other side of a hayfield and a fence row and a little drain.

That night, Soot wouldn’t settle. She’s slept on the rag rug at the foot of our bed for eleven years, and around midnight she got up and went to the bedroom door and whined. Lafe let her out, thinking she needed to go. She didn’t come back in. I heard her barking down toward the road, that high sharp heeler bark, over and over.

At twenty till two I woke up because the bedroom ceiling was orange.

Gaylon’s hay barn was burning. All of it, top to bottom, flames shooting up past the roof peak and sparks going up into the dark like somebody had kicked a campfire. Lafe pulled his pants on over his pajamas and ran out to the truck, and I called 911, and by the time the Middleburg volunteer department got there with two trucks there wasn’t anything left to save. We stood in our yard in our coats and watched it fall in. Soot was standing at the end of our drive with every hair on her back straight up, and she would not come when Lafe called her.

Gaylon got there at about two-thirty. He said he’d been at his daughter’s in Danville. He stood out on the road with his hands on his head, and Lafe walked over in his pajama pants and put an arm around him.

A Letter From a Lawyer in Lexington

For about a week, everything was sad and ordinary. The church took Gaylon casseroles. He told everyone the collection was a total loss. The tractors, the old truck, the baler, all of it, burned up with nine hundred round bales of hay.

Then a woman named Retha Combs came to our door. She was polite and tired-looking and she worked for Gaylon’s insurance company. She wanted to know about the brush pile. When did Lafe burn it? Did he stay with it? Which way was the wind blowing? She walked out to the black circle and took pictures of it, and then she walked the fence row toward the burned barn, taking more pictures.

Lafe told her everything. He’s like that. He has never had anything to hide.

Two days later Harlis Napier, the volunteer fire chief, stopped by. He’s a plumber in real life, and he didn’t want to say what he’d come to say. His report listed the cause as undetermined, but it also had a line that said “possible ignition from embers of neighboring brush burn earlier same day.” Gaylon had told him about the brush pile at the scene. Harlis said he had to write down what he was told. He said he was sorry.

Three weeks after the fire, a certified letter came from a law firm in Lexington. Gaylon’s insurance company had paid his claim, and now they were coming after us to get their money back. The letter said Lafe had “negligently conducted an open burn” that “spread to and destroyed” Gaylon’s barn and its contents. They wanted $94,312 from us. Our homeowner’s policy might cover some of it, our agent said, if our company agreed Lafe was negligent, and then they would most likely drop us. And if they didn’t agree, we could be sued for it ourselves.

Lafe read the letter once and then went and sat in his pickup.

What People Say After Church

Gaylon never said a hard word to us. That was the clever part. He didn’t have to. At church he would shake his head and say, “Lafe’s a good old man. I don’t blame him one bit. He just maybe ought not to be burning anymore, bless him.” He said it to the preacher. He said it to the Sunday school class. He said it at the feed mill. And people started looking at my husband the way you look at an old man who’s been found walking down the highway in his house shoes.

A lady I’ve known for forty years patted my hand in the church parking lot and asked if Lafe was “still driving.” One of the men at the feed mill told Lafe, real kindly, that he could help him get his guns put up somewhere safe if he needed. Lafe didn’t even answer him. He just came home.

Then Alton drove down from Lexington. He sat at our table in his nice quarter-zip sweater and told his daddy that maybe it was time to think about selling some ground. Pay the lawyers, get it behind us. He said it the way you’d say it to a child. And then he said, “Gaylon called me, Dad. He said he’d be willing to make this go away. He’d get the insurance company to back off if you sold him the bottom. He’d pay a fair price.”

The fair price was twenty-one hundred dollars an acre. Ground like that goes for twice that.

Lafe looked at his son for a long time. Then he said, “Your mother and I will talk about it,” and went out to the truck again.

He sat out there most nights after that. Engine off, window cracked, Soot on the seat beside him. I’d take him a cup of coffee and he’d say, “I’m just thinking, Melba.” He stopped going to church after the second Sunday. I’d never seen him ashamed before. Not in fifty-one years. He was ashamed of a thing he did not do, and there wasn’t one thing I could say that helped.

Grease on a Gray Dog

It was about the first of November when Soot started disappearing.

She’d always stayed close. Heelers do. But now, around one or two in the afternoon, she’d slip off from the barn and be gone two or three hours, and when she came back she smelled like diesel and hay dust. One afternoon she trotted up on the porch with a long black smear down her side, right through that pretty speckled coat. Grease. Real grease, the thick black kind. I knelt on the porch and scrubbed it with a rag and dish soap, and it would not come out.

The next day she came home with more of it, on her shoulder this time, and a few little chips of something stuck in the fur on her neck. Red paint. Bright red.

I showed Lafe. He turned the dog’s head to the light and picked off a chip of that paint with his thumbnail and looked at it for a long time.

“That’s tractor red,” he said. “That’s Farmall red.”

“Every tractor in that barn burned up,” I said. “Gaylon said so.”

Lafe didn’t say anything. He just went and stood on the porch and looked north across the hayfield, past the black hump where the red barn used to be, toward Gaylon’s back forty.

The next afternoon I tried to follow her. I am seventy-two and I have bad knees and that dog is half wolf, so I lost her at the creek in about four minutes. But I saw which way she went. North, up the drain along the fence row, into the woods on Gaylon’s side.

The Shed Nobody Looked At

The summer before last, Gaylon had put up a plain gray metal building way back on his back forty, past the woods, down by the creek where you can’t see it from any road. It had a gravel lane going back to it off his side and a big rolling door. When we asked about it, he said it was for storing auction overflow. Furniture and such.

That was the direction Soot was going.

And then I remembered something else. Ulys Dotson.

Ulys is about sixty-five. He’s done hired work for half the farms on our road at one time or another, and for six or seven summers back when Soot was young, he helped Lafe put up hay. Every day at noon Ulys would sit on the tailgate and eat a sausage biscuit out of wax paper, and he’d always give the last bite to Soot. She adored him. When he stopped working for us and went to work full time for Gaylon, she’d still run to the fence whenever she heard his truck.

I said, “Lafe, I believe she’s going to see Ulys.”

He said, “Then Ulys is working somewhere he oughtn’t to be.”

A Thermos and a Disposable Camera

On Saturday night, the eighth of November, we filled a thermos with coffee and put on our coats, and Lafe drove the pickup out our field lane with the headlights off, across our bottom, and parked behind the fence row where it bends close to Gaylon’s woods. From there, through the bare trees, you could just make out the shape of that metal shed.

I had a disposable camera in my coat pocket. I keep one in the glove box. My cell phone takes terrible pictures at night and that little drugstore camera with the flash has never let me down, so I brought it.

Soot stood up on the seat between us with her front feet braced on the dash and stared out at the dark.

We sat there two hours. At about ten-fifteen, a set of headlights came down Gaylon’s gravel lane on the far side. A truck, pulling a long flatbed trailer. It stopped at the shed. A light came on inside, and we saw the big rolling door go up.

Soot growled, low and long.

Lafe said, “Melba, I’m going to drive up there.”

I said, “Then I’m going with you.”

He started the truck and turned the headlights on, and he drove that old pickup right through the gap in the fence row where the gate had rotted out years ago, across the corner of the field, and up the gravel to that shed. He stopped with the high beams shining straight in through the open door.

Standing in a Fire That Never Happened

Inside that shed, lit up like a stage, were two red Farmall tractors.

Not burned. Not a scorch on them. Shining. Next to them sat the 1956 pickup, the side-by-side with the roof, and a round baler so new the plastic was still on the seat. And there was Gaylon Stidham in his pressed jeans with a ratchet strap in his hands, and Ulys Dotson standing at the back of the flatbed with his mouth open.

Gaylon put his hand up to shade his eyes. When he saw it was us, his face did something I will remember for the rest of my life. It went from mad to scared to friendly, all in about one second.

“Lafe!” he said. “What in the world are y’all doing out here this time of night? You’re on my property, buddy.”

Lafe got out of the truck. He’s a big man, even now, and he stood there in the headlights with his hands at his sides.

“You’re standing in a fire, Gaylon,” he said. “Ninety-four thousand dollars’ worth.”

I rolled down my window and held up my little camera and pushed the button. The flash went off. I wound it with my thumb and pushed it again. Gaylon came toward the truck fast with his hand out, saying, “Now, Melba, hold on, you don’t want to do that,” and that is when Soot went over the top of me and out the open window.

She didn’t bite him. She didn’t have to. She planted herself in the gravel between that man and my door with her head low and her lips pulled back and made a sound I didn’t know she could make. Gaylon stopped like he’d hit a wall.

I took four more pictures. Tractors, baler, the old truck, Gaylon. One of Ulys with his hands over his face.

Then Lafe whistled once, and Soot jumped back in the truck, and we drove home with the lights on. Lafe’s hands were shaking on the wheel. I’d never seen that either.

What the Fire Marshal Found

Our lawyer is a woman named Berdine Kiser, in Danville, and I believe she is the smartest person I’ve ever met. She had my film developed at a one-hour place that very Monday, looked at the pictures for a long time, and then picked up the phone and called the state fire marshal’s office in Frankfort.

An investigator named Joby Fugate came down that Thursday. By then the shed was empty. Gaylon had hauled everything out on Saturday night, of course, after we left. But he couldn’t haul out the tire tracks or the hydraulic fluid on the concrete floor or the chips of red paint where something had scraped the door frame. And he couldn’t make our pictures go away.

Mr. Fugate went over what was left of the barn too, which the insurance company had never really done once they’d decided who to blame. He found that the fire started inside, at the east end, low down, in the part where the collection was supposed to have been parked. He found traces of gasoline in the dirt there. He pulled the weather records from the airport in Somerset and showed Berdine that on the night of October the fourteenth, the wind had been out of the northeast. Blowing from Gaylon’s barn toward our brush pile. Not the other way around.

“Mrs. Gillum,” he told me, “embers don’t blow upwind six hundred yards and over a wet field. They just don’t.”

The insurance company had paid Gaylon $212,000. Tractors, baler, side-by-side, antique truck, hay and building.

They found every one of those machines three weeks later, at a consignment dealer in east Tennessee, waiting for a spring sale. The serial numbers matched the insurance claim.

Ulys on the Porch

The Sunday after we went up to that shed, Ulys Dotson drove into our yard in his old truck and sat in it for ten minutes before he came to the door.

Soot ran out and wiggled all over him.

He sat on our porch swing with his cap in his hands and told us. The Saturday before the fire, Gaylon had him move everything out of the barn and back to that shed. Gaylon said he’d sold the collection to a man in Tennessee and didn’t want the town knowing his business. Ulys believed him. Then the barn burned three days later and Gaylon told everybody the collection burned with it, and Ulys knew.

“I should have said something then,” he said. “I didn’t know who’d believe me over him. And I needed the job.”

Every day since, Gaylon had him working back at that shed, keeping the machines ready to haul. And every day at noon Ulys sat on an overturned bucket in the doorway and ate his sausage biscuit, and every day, starting about a week after the fire, a gray heeler came trotting up the creek to sit at his feet and get the last bite. She’d rub up against those tractors while she waited. That was where the grease came from.

“She kept looking at me,” Ulys said, and his voice went. “Like she knew. Like she was waiting on me to do right.”

Lafe didn’t say anything for a long time. Then he reached over and put his big hand on the back of Ulys’s neck, the way he does with Alton, and left it there.

Ulys told the fire marshal everything the next morning.

Paying for a Barn

Here is how it came out.

Gaylon Stidham was charged with arson and insurance fraud. Berdine says it’s the kind of case that doesn’t go to trial, and so far she’s been right, because his lawyer has been asking about a plea since the week the tractors turned up in Tennessee. It also turned out his auction company was badly behind on the loan for a big new sale barn on the bypass, and the bank had been sending him letters since spring. He needed money. He needed our bottom, too, with its spring, because he’d been telling a developer he could put together two hundred acres along the creek. If the lawsuit scared us into selling cheap, he’d have had both.

The insurance company dropped its suit against us in December. It sent Berdine a check for our legal fees and a short letter that said they “regret any distress.” Harlis Napier came out on his own and rewrote his report, and then he stood in our kitchen and apologized to Lafe with his hat in his hand, and the two of them went out to look at the cows together like nothing had ever happened, because that’s how men around here say they’re sorry.

Alton drove down the same week. He walked out to the pickup where his daddy was sitting and got in the passenger side, and they sat there together for over an hour with the engine off. I don’t know what they said. Alton came in with red eyes. He calls every Sunday now, and he doesn’t ask about selling anything.

Gaylon’s place sold at auction this past spring. A competitor of his called the sale, and I’m told he did a beautiful job.

The Next Brush Pile

Lafe hired Ulys three days a week. He’s here now, as I write this. He eats his sausage biscuit on the tailgate at noon, and Soot sits in the gravel and waits for the last bite, just like she did ten years ago.

And two weeks ago, after a good soaking rain and two more days, my husband burned his brush pile.

He dragged the green hose out past the hog lot. He raked his six-foot ring of bare dirt. He called the dispatcher in Liberty, and she said, “All right, Mr. Gillum, holler if you need us.” And when he walked out there with his matches, Harlis Napier’s red pickup came up the drive, and Harlis got out and stood beside Lafe with a rake of his own the whole afternoon. Nobody asked him to. He just came.

I watched them from the kitchen window, the two of them leaning on their rakes in the smoke, and Soot lying in the grass at Lafe’s feet with her chin on his boot.

I think about how a man can lose fifty years of a good name in three weeks of whispering. People who’d known Lafe since he was a boy believed he’d burned down a barn because a man in a sport coat said it softly enough. And the thing that brought the truth home wasn’t the church or the insurance company or the fire department. It was an old dog with a black patch on her eye who kept going back to the one place nobody else thought to look, because a friend was there with a sausage biscuit, and because something about that shed was wrong and she knew it before any of us did.

I keep a new disposable camera in the glove box now. You never know.

If somebody older in your family has been quietly talked about lately, and the story never sat quite right with you, go sit with them and ask what really happened. And if this made you think of a good dog or a good neighbor who saw the truth before anyone else, pass it along so it reaches them.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family

Continue Reading

Jason is a writer and storyteller who focuses on the human side of the stories — moments of kindness, resilience, family, and the turning points that quietly change a life. He writes to inform, engage, and inspire, and believes the best stories are the ones that make readers feel less alone.