My Husband’s Grandfather Left Me His Lake Cabin, And His Family Called Me A Gold Digger At The Will Reading

“You worked him. Six years of casseroles and you worked a dying old man out of his land.”

That was my mother-in-law, Darla, standing up so fast her chair scraped across the floor of Mr. Abernathy’s office in Gaylord, Michigan.

Mr. Abernathy had just read one sentence out loud. The cabin on Tamarack Lake and the forty acres around it, left to me. Lorraine Pruitt. Fifty-eight years old, a retired school secretary from Saginaw, married into the family for thirty-one years.

My sister-in-law Tiffany was next to her mother, already shaking her head with her arms crossed.

“This is sick,” Tiffany said. “She wasn’t even blood. Grandpa had dementia at the end, everybody knows that.”

Gus did not have dementia. Gus Pruitt was ninety-three years old and he beat me at euchre the week before he died.

My husband Wade put his hand on my knee under the table. I could feel it shaking.

I didn’t say anything. I couldn’t. My face was burning and my eyes were burning and I kept staring at the brown file folder in front of Mr. Abernathy like it might explain itself.

Darla pointed her finger at me across the table. She had on the black dress from the funeral, the same one, and her lipstick had worn off on one side.

“That property is worth six hundred thousand dollars. That was my father’s. That was supposed to come to me and my children. And she drove up there every week with her pie plates and got her name put on it.”

I had driven up there every week. That part was true.

What Darla didn’t know, what nobody in that room knew except Mr. Abernathy, was that Gus had been keeping count.

Mr. Abernathy took off his reading glasses, folded them, and set them on the folder. He was in his seventies, a small man with a bow tie, and he had been Gus’s lawyer since 1980.

“Mrs. Pruitt,” he said to Darla, very calm. “Please sit down. Your father left a letter. He asked me to read it in this room, to all of you, if anyone objected to the will.”

He paused.

“He was quite sure someone would.”

It started six years ago with a pot roast and a green guest book by the cabin door

To understand that day, you have to go back to the fall six years ago, when Gus’s wife Nell passed.

Nell and Gus had been married sixty-four years. They built that cabin on Tamarack Lake themselves in 1971, with lumber Gus hauled up from a mill in Grayling on a borrowed flatbed. Two bedrooms, a woodstove, a screened porch facing the water, and a dock he rebuilt every few springs.

After Nell’s funeral, everyone went home. Darla went back to her house in Midland. Tiffany went back to Grand Rapids and her salon. Wade and I went back to Saginaw.

And Gus, eighty-seven years old, went back to the cabin alone.

I lost my own father that same year. I think that was part of it. I knew what a quiet house sounded like after the funeral food runs out.

So the second Sunday after Nell died, I made a pot roast, wrapped it in towels, and put it on the floor of the passenger side of my Buick. It’s two hours from Saginaw to Tamarack Lake if you don’t stop. I stopped in West Branch for coffee.

Gus opened the door in his flannel shirt and his suspenders and just looked at me.

“Lorraine,” he said. “Is Wade with you?”

“He’s on shift at the plant,” I said. “I brought you supper.”

He stood there a long minute. Then he stepped aside and let me in.

On a little table by the door was a guest book. Green cloth cover, the corners worn down to cardboard. Nell had started it the summer they built the place. Every person who ever slept there, fished off that dock, or came for coffee had signed it.

Gus tapped it with one thick finger.

“Everybody who comes in signs the book,” he said. “Nell’s rule. Name and date. That’s all.”

So I signed it. Lorraine, October 9, and the year.

I had no idea that would be the first of three hundred and twelve.

We ate the pot roast at the kitchen table without saying much. He had two helpings. When I was putting on my coat, he cleared his throat.

“Same time next week?” he asked, not looking at me.

“Same time next week,” I said.

Every Sunday for six years I drove two hours north, and Gus was always at the window

I want to be clear about something. I didn’t go up there for a cabin. I went up there because a lonely old man asked me if I was coming back and I said yes.

After that, it just became my Sunday.

I’d leave Saginaw at seven in the morning after early service. I’d stop at the same gas station in West Branch, the one with the good donuts, and buy two. One for me, one for Gus. Plain cake, no frosting. He said frosting was for people who didn’t like donuts.

By nine thirty I’d pull up the gravel drive, and Gus would already be standing at the front window. Every single time. Rain, snow, the first warm day in May. He’d lift his hand like a man flagging down a bus.

Wade came when he could. The plant had him on rotating weekends, so it was maybe every other Sunday at first, then more once he retired. Gus loved having him there. The two of them would take the old Lund boat out and come back three hours later with four perch and a sunburn.

On the Sundays I came alone, Gus taught me things.

He taught me how to clean a perch with a fillet knife his father had owned. He taught me how to bank a woodstove so it lasted the night. He taught me Nell’s pasty recipe, the one with rutabaga, and he stood over my shoulder the whole time making sure I didn’t skimp on the pepper.

I taught him how to use a cell phone, mostly. He never did get the hang of texting. He’d call me and hold the phone a foot from his face and shout.

We played euchre at the kitchen table with whoever was around. Sometimes the mail carrier, a woman named Patsy, would come in for coffee. Sometimes Kyle, the teenage boy from down the road who mowed for Gus, would sit in.

Every one of them signed the book. Gus made sure of it.

“Nell’s rule,” he’d say, pushing the pen across the table. “I don’t make the rules. I just keep them.”

I fixed the screen door twice. I painted the porch. I drove him to his eye doctor in Petoskey and his heart doctor in Traverse City. I sat in the waiting room with a crossword and an old Reader’s Digest.

The years just went by like that. One Sunday at a time.

In six years, Darla and Tiffany came up to the lake exactly three times

I don’t say this to be mean. I say it because it matters to what happened later.

Darla is Gus’s only daughter. Tiffany is her youngest, Wade’s little sister. Both of them lived within three hours of the cabin. Both of them had cars that ran.

The first time they came was the Fourth of July, the second summer. They stayed for about forty minutes. Tiffany sat on the porch on her phone the whole time. Darla walked around the outside of the cabin looking at the roof and the foundation and asking Gus how much he’d paid in property taxes that year.

The second time was Gus’s ninetieth birthday. I baked a cake, a yellow cake with chocolate frosting, which Gus forgave because it was cake and not a donut. Darla brought a card and a fleece blanket still in the plastic. They left before the candles were lit because Tiffany had a dinner reservation in Traverse City.

The third time is the one I still think about.

It was a Saturday, not a Sunday, so I wasn’t there. But Gus told me about it the next morning, sitting at the kitchen table, turning his coffee cup around and around in his hands.

“Darla brought a man with her,” he said. “Nice suit. Real estate fella from Charlevoix.”

My stomach dropped.

“What did he want?” I asked.

“Wanted to walk the shoreline. Wanted to know if I’d ever had the land surveyed.” Gus snorted. “Darla told him I was thinking about assisted living. First I ever heard of it.”

“Gus, are you?”

He set his cup down hard.

“Lorraine, I’m going to die in this cabin looking at that lake. They can carry me out feet first. That real estate fella can wait for the funeral like everybody else.”

I remember he got up after that and went to the guest book. He flipped to that Saturday’s page and wrote something in pencil, in his slow square handwriting. I didn’t look. It wasn’t my business.

I wish now I’d looked. It might have prepared me.

Gus’s last winter, he asked me to bring the guest book to the hospital

Gus started slowing down the winter he turned ninety-three.

He still met me at the window, but he’d sit down in the chair by it instead of standing. His feet swelled up. He got winded walking to the dock and back. In January he caught pneumonia, and a neighbor found him on the kitchen floor and called the ambulance.

They took him to the hospital in Petoskey. I drove up that same night in a snowstorm and almost put the Buick in a ditch outside Vanderbilt.

Wade called his mother from the hallway.

“Mom, Grandpa’s in the hospital. It’s bad. You should come.”

I could hear Darla’s voice through the phone from three feet away.

“Wade, I can’t just drop everything and drive up there in this weather. Call me if anything changes.”

She didn’t come. Tiffany didn’t come either. Tiffany sent a text to Wade that said, “Praying for Grandpa,” with two hands emoji.

Gus was in that hospital nine days. I was there for seven of them. I slept in a recliner next to his bed and ate vending machine crackers and held his hand when the nurses did things that hurt.

On the fifth day, he was having a good morning. Sitting up, sipping apple juice through a straw, complaining about the Jell-O.

“Lorraine,” he said. “Do me a favor. Go up to the cabin and bring me the guest book.”

“The guest book? Gus, it’s forty minutes each way.”

“I know how far it is. I built the road.”

So I went. I drove to the cabin, let myself in with the key under the frog statue, and picked up that green book off the table by the door. It felt heavier than I remembered. Nearly six years of Sundays.

When I brought it back, Gus held it in his lap a long time. Then he asked me to go get him a coffee from the cafeteria, a real one, not the hospital kind.

I was gone maybe twenty minutes. When I came back, the guest book was closed, and he had a pen in his hand.

The next week, a man in a bow tie came to see him. I didn’t know who he was at the time. Gus asked me to step out.

Gus came home in February. He lived three more weeks in his chair by the window looking at the frozen lake. He died on a Sunday morning in March, a few minutes before I pulled up the drive.

His hospice nurse said he’d been asking what time it was.

At the funeral, Darla was already talking about who would buy the lake

The funeral was at the Methodist church in Gaylord, the same one where Nell’s had been.

Darla handled everything. She picked the casket, the hymns, the flowers. She did not ask me a single question, which was fine. He was her father. I just wanted to sit in a pew and say goodbye.

But I couldn’t help what I overheard.

At the luncheon in the church basement, standing in line for the ham and scalloped potatoes, I heard Tiffany behind me talking to one of her cousins.

“Mom already talked to a guy. Lakefront up there is crazy right now. He thinks six hundred, maybe more with the acreage.”

“Are you guys going to keep it?” the cousin asked.

Tiffany laughed.

“Keep it? Who’s going to drive up to the middle of nowhere every weekend? We’ll split it and be done.”

I set my plate down and walked outside to the parking lot, where it was sleeting, and cried behind a minivan for ten minutes.

Wade found me out there. He didn’t say anything. He just stood next to me in the sleet with his hands in his coat pockets.

“They’re going to sell it,” I said. “Somebody’s going to tear it down and put up one of those big glass houses.”

“Maybe,” Wade said. “It’s not up to us, Lorrie.”

He was right. It wasn’t up to us. Or I thought it wasn’t.

Two weeks later, we got a letter from the law office of Gerald Abernathy in Gaylord. All family members were requested to attend the reading of the last will and testament of August Pruitt on Thursday, April 3rd, at ten in the morning.

I almost didn’t go. Wade had to talk me into it.

“Grandpa would want you there,” he said. “Even if it’s just to hear them read his name one more time.”

When Mr. Abernathy read my name, the whole room turned on me

Which brings us back to that office. Wood paneling, a big oak table, a window looking out on the Gaylord main street with the alpine-style storefronts.

Mr. Abernathy read the will in order. Gus’s savings, about forty-one thousand dollars, split between Darla and Wade’s two older brothers, who lived out of state and didn’t come. His truck to a church charity. His tools to Kyle, the boy who mowed.

Then he got to the real property.

“To my granddaughter-in-law, Lorraine Pruitt, I leave my cabin on Tamarack Lake, and all forty acres of land associated with it, with all its contents, except as otherwise noted.”

That was when Darla stood up.

I’ve already told you what she said. Gold digger. Worked a dying man. Pie plates. I won’t repeat it all.

Tiffany said I was a manipulator. She said I’d been planning this for years. She said she was going to call a lawyer of her own, a real one, from Grand Rapids.

Then Darla turned to her son.

“Wade, are you just going to sit there? Your wife robbed your own mother. She robbed you.”

And my husband, who doesn’t like to raise his voice, who had never once in thirty-one years taken a side against his mother, set both hands flat on that oak table.

“Mom, she didn’t rob anybody. She was there. You weren’t.”

The room went silent.

Darla’s mouth opened and closed. Tiffany looked at her brother like she’d never seen him before.

“How dare you,” Darla said, but her voice cracked on it.

That was when Mr. Abernathy asked her to sit down and told us about the letter.

He slid a cream-colored envelope out of the brown folder. It was sealed with tape, and on the front, in Gus’s square handwriting, it said: TO BE READ IF ANYBODY SQUAWKS.

Wade let out a little laugh beside me. I started crying all over again.

Gus’s sealed letter said he had been keeping count the whole time

Mr. Abernathy put his reading glasses back on, slit the envelope with a silver letter opener, and unfolded two sheets of yellow legal paper.

He read it out loud, slowly.

“If you’re hearing this, somebody is upset that Lorraine got the cabin. I’d bet money it’s my daughter. I’d bet more money Tiffany’s helping.”

Darla’s face went white.

“So let me explain myself, since I won’t be there to do it.”

“Nell and I kept a guest book at the cabin from the day we finished building it. Everybody who walks in signs it. That was her rule, and I kept it for her after she passed. Gerald has the book now. I asked him to bring it today.”

Mr. Abernathy reached under the table and set something on the oak. The green cloth cover. The worn-down corners.

I put my hand over my mouth.

“After Nell died, I started paying attention to who signed it. Then I started counting. I am ninety-three years old and I’ve got time.”

“In six years, Lorraine signed that book three hundred and twelve times. She missed four Sundays. Two for her mother’s surgery, one for a blizzard, and one when she had the flu and called me from bed to make sure I’d eaten.”

I didn’t know he had counted. I didn’t know he remembered the flu.

“My grandson Wade signed it one hundred and eighty-eight times. He’d have signed more if the plant let him off. Patsy the mail lady signed sixty-one times. Kyle signed ninety-four. My hospice nurse, Donna, signed nineteen.”

“My daughter Darla and my granddaughter Tiffany came to the cabin three times in six years. They did not sign once. I asked them to every time. I wrote down their visits myself, in pencil, so there’d be a record.”

Mr. Abernathy turned the guest book around and opened it to a page marked with a strip of newspaper. There, in the margin, in pencil, in Gus’s handwriting:

July 4. Darla and Tiffany. 40 min. Would not sign. Asked about taxes.

He turned to another marked page.

Dad’s 90th. Darla and Tiffany. Left before cake. Would not sign.

And a third.

Saturday. Darla with realtor from Charlevoix. Walked my shoreline. Told him I was going to a home. Would not sign.

Everyone who signed the book got a gift, and Darla and Tiffany got the book itself

Mr. Abernathy went back to the letter.

“So here’s how I decided things. Anybody who came up here and sat with an old man gets something from me. That’s fair. Anybody who didn’t, I figure they didn’t want anything to do with this place, so I won’t burden them with it.”

“Patsy gets Nell’s good china, because she’s the only one who ever said it was pretty. Kyle gets my tools and my fishing rods, and I’ve already paid his first year at the community college. Donna gets five thousand dollars and my thanks.”

Kyle’s college. I hadn’t known that either. Gus had never said a word.

“Wade gets the boat. The 1978 Lund, and the trailer, and the motor that he fixed four times. That boy and I caught a lot of perch out of that boat. I want him to keep catching them.”

Wade made a sound beside me, like a breath getting caught. I took his hand. He’s not a crier. He was crying.

“Lorraine gets the cabin and the land. Not because she asked. She never asked for one thing in six years except whether I’d eaten. She gets it because she’s the one who kept Nell’s rule. She came in that door every Sunday and signed her name. She’s the one who knows how to bank the woodstove. She’s the one who’ll keep it the way Nell would want.”

“I had my doctor in Petoskey examine me the same week I signed this will, so nobody can say I didn’t know what I was doing. Gerald has the paperwork.”

Mr. Abernathy tapped a second, smaller envelope in the folder. He didn’t open it. He didn’t need to.

“Now. To my daughter Darla and my granddaughter Tiffany.”

Darla sat very still.

“I leave you the guest book.”

Tiffany let out a little huff, like she thought it was a joke.

“Take it home. Read every page. Look at all those names and dates. That’s six years of Sundays you could have had with me. I’d have liked that. I’d have liked it more than you know.”

“I don’t hold anything against you. I just want you to know what you missed. Maybe someday you’ll go up to the lake and sign it. It’s never too late to start keeping a rule.”

“Love, Dad. Grandpa. Gus.”

Mr. Abernathy folded the yellow paper and slid the green guest book across the oak table until it stopped in front of Darla.

She didn’t touch it.

Darla threatened to fight it, and then she walked out without the book

For a long minute, nobody said anything.

Then Darla stood up again, but slower this time. She picked up her purse. She didn’t look at me. She looked at Mr. Abernathy.

“I’ll be contesting this,” she said. “He wasn’t in his right mind.”

Mr. Abernathy nodded like he’d heard that sentence a hundred times.

“You’re welcome to try, Mrs. Pruitt. Your father anticipated that. He had a full cognitive evaluation by Dr. Hensley at Northern Michigan Hospital, signed and dated the same week. I’d also point out he managed his own checkbook until February. A judge will see all of that.”

Darla looked at Tiffany. Tiffany looked at the floor.

“Mom,” Tiffany said, low. “Let’s just go.”

They walked out. The door to the office had a little brass bell on it, and it jingled behind them, which seemed wrong somehow. Too cheerful.

The green guest book was still sitting on the table.

Mr. Abernathy looked at it, then at me.

“Legally, that belongs to them,” he said. “I’ll mail it to Mrs. Pruitt’s address in Midland.”

“Please don’t,” I said, before I could stop myself. “She’ll throw it away.”

He thought about that. Then he did something I didn’t expect. He pushed it toward Wade.

“Wade, you’re her son. Maybe you’d see that it gets to her. In your own time.”

Wade picked it up and held it against his chest.

In the parking lot, he sat behind the wheel of our car and didn’t start it for almost five minutes.

“I should have pushed her harder,” he said finally. “All those years. I should have made her come.”

“You can’t make people come, honey,” I said. “You can only show up yourself.”

He nodded and started the car.

Darla never did contest the will. Her lawyer from Grand Rapids took one look at Dr. Hensley’s report and told her she’d be wasting her money. She didn’t speak to Wade for almost three months. She didn’t speak to me at all.

Months later, on a Sunday morning, a car I didn’t recognize pulled up the gravel drive

We kept going up every Sunday. It just didn’t feel right not to.

Wade fixed up the Lund and put it in the water in May. I planted Nell’s tiger lilies along the porch again because the deer had gotten most of the old ones. Patsy still stops for coffee on her route. Kyle comes by on his summer break from college and mows, and he won’t let us pay him.

We started a new guest book, a blue one from the Hallmark store in Gaylord, because Wade still had the green one in a drawer at home. He hadn’t figured out how to give it to his mother yet.

Then one Sunday in late September, I was at the kitchen counter rolling out pasty dough when I heard tires on the gravel.

I went to the front window. The same window Gus used to stand at.

It was a little silver SUV with a Grand Rapids dealer plate frame. Tiffany got out of the driver’s side. She was alone.

She stood by the car for a long time, looking at the lake. Then she walked up the steps to the porch and knocked.

I opened the door. Neither of us said anything at first.

She looked older than I remembered. No makeup. Her hair pulled back in a clip.

“Wade gave me the book,” she said. “Last month. He said Mom wouldn’t take it, so he gave it to me.”

“Okay,” I said.

“I read the whole thing. Every page.” Her chin was trembling. “Lorraine, you came up here three hundred and twelve times. I couldn’t come up here once for an hour without looking at my phone.”

“Tiffany, you don’t have to…”

“No. I do.” She wiped her eyes with the back of her hand. “I said terrible things about you. In front of Grandpa’s lawyer. In front of my brother. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. I don’t even know why I said them, except that it was easier than admitting he was lonely and I didn’t care enough to notice.”

I didn’t know what to say. So I said the only thing I could think of. The thing Gus would have said.

“Do you want to come in?”

Tiffany signed the guest book, and I set a second donut on the kitchen table

She came in. She stood in the doorway looking around at the woodstove, the euchre deck on the shelf, Nell’s china cabinet with the empty spot where the good plates used to be.

Then she reached into her bag and took out the green guest book. She set it on the little table by the door, right where it used to sit.

“I think it belongs here,” she said. “Not with me.”

She opened it to the last page with writing on it. I recognized the entry. It was the Sunday Gus died. In my handwriting: Lorraine, March 16. And under it, Wade.

Underneath that, the page was blank.

Tiffany picked up the pen. Her hand was shaking so badly the first letter came out crooked.

Tiffany, September 28.

She stared at it for a second, and then she broke down crying, right there in the doorway, with the pen still in her hand.

I put my arms around her. I hadn’t hugged Tiffany since her wedding, twelve years earlier. She held on to me like she was drowning.

“He wanted me to,” she said into my shoulder. “He said it’s never too late to start keeping a rule.”

“He did say that,” I said. “He meant it, too.”

Wade came in from the dock about then, carrying a bucket with three perch in it. He saw his sister standing there with the pen and the open book, and he set the bucket down on the porch and just stood in the doorway for a while.

We had pasties for lunch, Nell’s recipe, with plenty of pepper. Tiffany stayed until almost four. Before she left, she asked if she could come back.

“Same time next week?” I said.

She laughed, and cried a little more, and said yes.

She’s come four times since then. She signs the book every time. Darla hasn’t come yet. But last week Tiffany told me her mother asked what the cabin looks like now, and whether the tiger lilies came back.

I told Tiffany to tell her they did.

On Sunday mornings I still stop in West Branch and buy two plain cake donuts. I eat one in the car. The other one I set on the kitchen table by the window, next to the green guest book.

Gus never did like frosting.

Now Trending:

• The Marina Owner’s Son Told Me My Old Newfoundland Had To Get Off My Boat Because “Dogs Aren’t Crew” And Gave Me 30 Days To Clear My Slip. On Day 27 The Fog Came In, And His Brand-New Boat Didn’t Come Back
• The Town’s New Animal Control Officer Took My Old Husky Off My Own Front Porch And Wrote Me A $350 Ticket For “Running Loose.” I Taught Him Eighth-Grade English In 1999, And At The Hearing I Brought One Photograph
• My Father Left His House And $300,000 To His Old Dog. My Brother Called It Insanity And Wanted The Dog Put Down. Then The Lawyer Opened The Second Envelope

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family