Off The Record

I Picked Up My Daughter From School — What She Said About Her “New Daddy” Left Me Speechless

Published on November 7, 2025

I believed I know my spouse. A lovely kid, ten years of marriage, and a life we had created together from nothing. Then one afternoon, my five-year-old told me about “the new daddy,” and I found myself looking at a stranger who was dressed like my wife, wondering how long she had been deceiving me.

I swear that when I first saw Sophia ten years ago at a friend’s birthday party, standing by that window with a glass of wine in her hand and smiling at a joke I couldn’t hear, I knew that something significant was about to happen in my life.

She exuded confidence and charisma, making her the type of lady who could effortlessly take over any space. Me? At parties, I was merely a clumsy IT engineer who could hardly speak in complete phrases.

But she saw me somehow.

That night, we spoke for hours on end. About travel, music, and the foolish things we did as children. I felt like someone genuinely saw me for the first time in my life as I fell hard and quickly. I believed I had won the lotto when we got married in a modest ceremony by the lake a year later.

Everything changed with the birth of our daughter, Lizzy, five years ago. I had never been more afraid or felt more whole than I did when I realized that this little person was completely dependent on us.

I recall Sophia whispering promises about all the things she would teach her as she held her for the first time. I recall those feedings at three in the morning, when we would both stumbling around like zombies, alternately soothing Lizzy back to sleep.

Yes, we were tired, but we were content. We worked as a group.

Six months later, Sophia returned to her job. She leads the marketing department at a large company in the downtown area. She is one of those individuals that thrives on meeting deadlines, giving presentations, and accomplishing seemingly impossible goals. I wholeheartedly agreed with that.

We managed to make it work, even if my job wasn’t quite 9 to 5. We followed a schedule. Since my hours ran later, Sophia usually took Lizzy up from kindergarten. We would read Lizzy’s tales, bathe her, and eat dinner together. Typical thing. Excellent stuff.

We didn’t have many arguments. The typical married couple quarreled over why the dishes were still in the sink, who had forgotten to buy milk, and whether we needed a new automobile. I never had any doubts about our solidity.

Until my work phone rang that Thursday afternoon.

Sophia responded, “Hey, babe,” and I could sense the tension in her voice. “Will you please do me a great favor? Today, I am unable to pick up Lizzy. I can’t miss this meeting with the executive team at all costs. Could you get her instead?”

I looked at the time. 3:15 p.m. I could make it if I left now.

“Yes, of course. No issue!”

“Many thanks. You’ve saved my life.”

I drove directly to the kindergarten after informing my supervisor that I had a family emergency. Lizzy’s expression brightened like a fireworks display as I entered those doors. I missed these moments, my god. I became so preoccupied with my work that I lost sight of how wonderful it was to see my daughter smile.

“Daddy!” Her tiny sneakers squealed on the floor as she ran to me.

I knelt and drew her into an embrace. “Hi, my love. Are you prepared to return home?”

“Uh-huh!”

I began assisting her into her pink jacket, the one with the cartoon bears on the sleeves, after grabbing it off the hanger. During snack time, she was talking about something her buddy Emma had said, and I was grinning and taking it all in.

“Daddy, why didn’t the new daddy pick me up like he usually does?” she asked, tilting her head.

As I was zipping, my hands froze.

“My dear, what do you mean? What’s new, dad?”

She gave me a look as though I had just posed the most ridiculous query.

“All right, the new dad. Every time, he takes me to Mommy’s workplace before we head home. We also occasionally take hikes together! Last week, we visited the zoo and watched the elephants. Additionally, he visits our home when you’re not there. He’s a very kind person. Sometimes he gives me cookies.”

It was as though the floor had fallen out from beneath me. Despite my heart thumping so loudly that I could hear it in my ears, I maintained a neutral expression and a quiet voice.

“Oh. I understand. Since he was unable to attend today, I came in his place. Are you not glad I came?”

“Of course, I am!” She laughed, utterly unaware. “Despite his constant requests, I don’t like calling him Daddy. It’s strange.” Therefore, I just refer to him as the “new daddy.”

I took a deep breath. “All right, all right. That makes sense.”

All the way home, she talked. Regarding Miss Rodriguez, her instructor. Regarding the sandbox and Tommy’s apology after pushing her. Lizzy talked endlessly about the drawing she had done of a giraffe.

I uttered the right words, such as “Uh-huh, wow, that’s great!”

However, I heard nothing at all. My mind kept repeating the same thing over and over. What on earth was the new father?

And when did Sophia begin bringing Lizzy to her workplace? She had never brought it up. Not once.

I prepared dinner for Lizzy after we arrived home. Macaroni and cheese and chicken nuggets are her favorites. Then, as my mind raced, I assisted her with a puzzle.

While my wife slept that night, I lay in bed next her and stared at the ceiling. I wanted to rouse her and make her answer my questions. But I was halted by something. Perhaps it was a fear of her words. Perhaps I needed to be certain before accusing her of anything.

I didn’t sleep, however.

I had made up my mind by dawn. I reported to work unwell. I reported having a stomach ailment to my boss. Around midday, I then took a car to Lizzy’s school. I parked far enough back that no one would see me, but across the street where I could see the entrance. She was to be picked up by Sophia at three that afternoon.

However, Sophia did not approach Lizzy when the doors opened and the children began to pour out.

On the steering wheel, my knuckles turned white.

“What the fuck? My God… You must be joking with me.”

It was Ben, Sophia’s secretary, who was holding my daughter’s hand.

He is about five or seven years younger than my wife. She would occasionally show me those company images of her, beaming broadly, just out of graduate school. I had heard his name mentioned in passing and seen his face in the backdrop of event videos. That’s all. All I knew about him was that.

So far.

I picked up my phone and began taking photos. I had trembling hands. At that moment, a part of me wanted to get out of the car and pull him away from my daughter. But I required evidence. Before I made a decision I couldn’t reverse, I needed to be fully informed about what was happening.

They entered his silver car. I kept two cars back and followed them from a distance. My heart was thumping violently. My instinct told me there had to be an innocent explanation, but every logical idea in my head told me otherwise.

They headed directly downtown to Sophia’s office building. They both got out after he parked in the underground garage. As they made their way to the elevator, Ben held Lizzy’s hand.

Five minutes passed while I waited. Next, 10. I was no longer able to sit there.

I entered into the main lobby. Most of the building was deserted. The workday is over. Only the cleaning team and a few stragglers. Lizzy was seated in the foyer with her small teddy bear on one of those awful modern chairs.

When she noticed me, she looked up and grinned. “Daddy!”

I knelt next to her and tried to remain composed. “Hi, my love. Mommy, where are you? What about the man who came to get you?”

She gestured toward the closed door by the hallway’s corner. “They’re inside. I should wait here and be good, they said.”

I gave her a forehead kiss. “Alright, stay right here. I’ll be right back. Stay put.”

“Okay, Daddy.”

My legs felt like lead as I approached the door. I was apprehensive about what might be behind the door. There was a part of me that wanted to go back, take Lizzy home, and act as though this entire day had never occurred.

However, I was unable to.

I inhaled deeply and, without knocking, pushed the door open. I then entered and silently closed it after myself. I didn’t want Lizzy to witness the impending event.

Ben and Sophia were sharing a kiss.

No one moved for a moment. Like deer in headlights, they simply gazed at me. Then I approached Ben directly, and my voice sounded colder and lower than I had ever heard it.

“Why on earth are you with my wife? Furthermore, what gives you the authority to instruct my daughter to refer to you as her father?”

Ben’s eyes shifted to the ground. remained silent.

Sophia’s expression turned pallid. “Ben… what did you say to her?”

I shook my head and turned to face her. “Don’t pretend you were unaware. Every day, you sent him to bring her up from school. You gave him permission to hang out with her. Go to the zoo with her. When I’m at work, stop by our residence. And now I know you’re having an affair with him?”

“Josh, please…” She broke down in tears. He told her to call him that, but I was unaware of it. I promise I didn’t. This isn’t how it appears.

“Don’t.” I extended my hand. “Don’t use that line to disparage my IQ. It looks just like that. Our daughter is being used as a cover for your affair with your secretary.”

She continued, her words coming out more quickly. It has to do with relinquishing control. Something about feeling overburdened, about my never being there, or about it being an error. All the typical justifications. Ben, meantime, stood there as if he were watching a thriller on television.

I gave him a look. “What’s the worst about it? My daughter was involved in this by you. You took advantage of her. A child of five years old. What sort of individual does that?”

Sophia grabbed my arm. “Josh, please, we can work through this…”

I withdrew. “No. We are unable to. We’re finished. The marriage is over.”

“You don’t mean that…”

“I’ve never meant anything more in my life.”

I was done listening to excuses. “This is not the end of it. Not by any means.”

After taking Lizzy’s hand and slamming the door behind me, we left the building. She inquired as to why I was distressed. I assured her that everything would be alright and that we would simply enjoy a wonderful evening together as father and daughter.

I wasn’t okay. Not even close.

The following morning, I hired a lawyer and filed for full custody and divorce. The months that followed were a living misery. Everything was verified by the security footage taken from the kindergarten and the office building: Ben had been picking Lizzy up on a daily basis for weeks. Since he was aware of all the pertinent information, the school staff concluded he had authorization. And they were seen together in that conference room on several occasions by the office cameras.

The court took my side. Sophia’s carelessness and the affair cost her primary custody. Nor was the judge amenable to it. It didn’t set well to use our child as a conduit for an affair. Every other weekend, Sophia received visits under supervision.

She and Ben were dismissed within a week after the affair became public knowledge (as these things often do). It seems that there is a provision regarding improper interactions between superiors and subordinates. That wasn’t something I requested. However, I also didn’t want to miss any sleep over it.

There are repercussions for betraying someone.

When I was by myself, I occasionally cried, usually in the middle of the night after I had put Lizzy to bed. Sophia had been my love for years. I believed that she would be my lifelong companion. However, she threw everything away for a guy who felt it was acceptable to play home with a girl from another man.

My whole attention is on Lizzy now. I made a self-promise to raise her to be wiser than the grownups who failed her, compassionate, and strong. She would always know she was adored.

On those supervised weekend trips, at birthday celebrations, and at school functions where we both attend and act polite, Sophia still occasionally runs into Lizzy. She had spent months searching for a new position. She has repeatedly begged for my forgiveness, generally in lengthy late-night texts.

She hasn’t won my forgiveness. Not quite yet. Perhaps never.

However, when Sophia arrives, we occasionally eat at the same table for Lizzy’s sake. We engage in small chat. For a short time, we act as though we are still a family. Because Lizzy is deserving of that. Even though her parents were unable to maintain their marriage, she should know that they both adore her. even if one of them made decisions that destroyed everything.

I have no idea what the future will bring. I’m not sure if I’ll ever be able to trust someone like that again or have the courage to fall in love. I get exhausted just thinking about going out on dates again.

However, I am aware that I will do everything in my power to keep my daughter safe. She will always know she comes first. She will never question if she is significant enough.

And if, after reading this, you’re assuming that you’ll never experience it? That your union is unique, more robust, and impervious to such treachery? Rethink your thought. Be mindful of the little things. When something doesn’t feel right, ask inquiries. Have faith in your intuition. Because the individuals we share our beds and lives with, the people we trust the most, are sometimes the ones with the biggest secrets.

If your five-year-old mentioned someone you had never heard of in passing, how would you respond? Would you investigate more or would you dismiss it as child confusion? Would you tell yourself you’re being paranoid or would you follow your instincts?

I’m happy I trusted mine and did what I said. Because who knows how long it would have lasted if I hadn’t? How much more profound would the lies have been?

I prevented my kid from growing up in a home where dishonesty was the norm. And I will never regret doing that.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family!

Share on Facebook

Save