Off The Record
After 10 Years Of Trying, I Finally Gave Birth To Twin Girls. When I Woke Up From Surgery, My Husband Was Gone And Wouldn’t Answer His Phone, And The Doctor Asked Me, ‘Do You Really Not Know Why He Left?’
The first thing I heard was a woman’s voice, very close and very happy.
“Congratulations, Mom! Two beautiful baby girls.”
My throat was raw from the breathing tube, and the ceiling tiles kept sliding to the left. I tried to say thank you and it came out as a cough. The nurse laughed kindly and held a cup of ice chips to my lips.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →Then she wheeled two clear bassinets up to the side of my bed, and I saw my daughters for the first time.
They were tiny and pink and furious about being awake. One had a soft red mark across her left cheek, like someone had brushed it with watercolor. The other had a red patch on her forehead, just above her right eyebrow.
I thought they were the most beautiful things I had ever seen. I still think so.
I turned my head to the right, where Simon was supposed to be. Where he had promised to be.
The chair was empty. His gray jacket was gone from the back of it. His phone charger was still plugged into the wall, the cord hanging down to the floor.
“Where’s my husband?” I asked.
The nurse’s smile slipped. It came back a second later, but it wasn’t the same smile.
“Let me get the doctor,” she said.

For ten years Simon held my hand through every needle, every negative test and every loss
My name is Rebecca Keller. I’m 36, and I teach kindergarten in Madison, Wisconsin. My husband, Simon, is 38 and teaches high-school chemistry across town.
We started trying for a baby the year we got married. I was 26. I thought it would take a few months.
It took ten years.
Ten years of ovulation tests lined up on the bathroom counter like little soldiers. Ten years of blood draws at seven in the morning so I could still make it to school before the kids. Three rounds of IVF.
Two pregnancies that ended before we got to tell anyone. About $41,000 we put on a home equity line, a little at a time, and never once said out loud as a number.
Through every bit of it, Simon held my hand.
He did my injections at the kitchen table every night at nine because my own hands shook. He gave the syringes ridiculous names. He drew a smiley face on my stomach with a pen before the first shot so it wouldn’t feel so clinical.
When the second pregnancy ended, he lay on the bathroom floor next to me for an hour with his hand on my back and didn’t say a single thing, because there was nothing right to say. He knew that.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →People ask how we stayed married through all that. I tell them it was easy to stay married to Simon. The hard part was staying hopeful.
My husband hated cameras, and I thought that was the only strange thing about him
If there was one odd thing about Simon, it was pictures.
He hated having his photo taken. At parties he was always the one holding the camera. At our wedding he asked the photographer to shoot him mostly from his right side, and he laughed it off by saying his left side “has a face for radio.”
He wore a short beard the whole time I knew him. He said he looked twelve without it.
His mother, Irma, lives three hours north of us, in Eau Claire. She is a tidy, careful woman who irons her dish towels. When I asked her once for baby pictures of Simon, she told me there had been a basement flood in the eighties and all the albums were ruined.
“Such a shame,” she said, and changed the subject to her tomato plants.
I believed her. Why wouldn’t I? Floods happen.
My own parents had lost a box of Christmas decorations to one. Simon never brought up his childhood much, and when he did, it was about science fairs and the dog they had named Pickles.
There were a few photos of him at around twelve or thirteen. A school picture, a shot of him holding a fish. In all of them he was turned slightly to the right.
I noticed it the way you notice someone always sits in the same chair. I never once thought it meant anything.
When the second line finally showed up, Simon sat down on the bathroom floor and cried
The fourth round of IVF worked.
I took the test on a Saturday morning in March. I didn’t even look at it. I handed it to Simon and went to put the kettle on, because I couldn’t stand to see one more blank window.
He didn’t come out of the bathroom. When I went back in, he was sitting on the floor with his back against the tub, holding the test in both hands and crying so hard his shoulders shook.
At the eight-week scan, the technician got very quiet and then smiled. “Okay, so there are two in here.”
Simon laughed so loud a nurse poked her head in to check on us.
After that, he turned into the most excited man in the state of Wisconsin. He repainted the nursery a soft sage green, two coats, with tape lines so straight you could use them as a ruler. He built both cribs himself from a kit, swore at the instructions for four hours, and then built them again because one was a quarter inch off.
He researched strollers like he was buying a car. He brought me warm chamomile tea every night and those little caramel-filled chocolates I liked, one square at a time, so I wouldn’t eat the whole bar.
By the third trimester I could barely get up off the couch, and he carried me up the stairs more than once, both of us laughing.
There was only one moment that stuck in my head later. At the twenty-week scan, Simon asked the technician a strange question.
“Can you tell from this if they’ll have any marks on their skin?”
The technician said no, not really. Simon nodded and looked at the screen and didn’t ask anything else.
The C-section was supposed to be routine, and then the room got very loud
Our doctor, Dr. Hannah Lindqvist, scheduled a C-section for 37 weeks. Twin A was head down and Twin B was sideways, and nobody wanted to take any chances.
The morning of the surgery, Simon shaved his beard down short and neat and put on his good flannel shirt under the paper gown. He said he wanted to look decent in the girls’ first pictures. I remember thinking that was sweet. I remember thinking, he’s going to let somebody take his picture.
The spinal block didn’t take all the way. I could feel too much. They tried again, and then my blood pressure dropped, and somebody said a number out loud that made everyone move faster.
I remember the anesthesiologist leaning over me and saying, very calmly, that they were going to put me to sleep now.
The last thing I saw before everything went dark was Simon’s eyes above his surgical mask. He was nodding at me, over and over, like he was trying to hold me up with it.
Later, I found out that there had been bleeding, and that it took a while to get under control. Both girls were born in under four minutes. Ivy came first, at 8:51 in the morning, and Willa followed at 8:53.
Simon was sent out to wait while they finished with me. A nurse brought the babies to him in the hallway. He held them before I did.
I was asleep for almost three more hours.
Both of my daughters had a red mark on their faces, and I thought they were perfect
The nurse’s name was Tamsin. She had a gray streak in her ponytail and a voice like warm bread.
While we waited for the doctor, she helped me hold the girls, one in each arm, propped up on pillows because I couldn’t sit up properly yet.
Ivy was the one with the mark on her cheek. It started below her left eye and spread down toward her jaw, a deep rosy red, flat and soft. Willa’s was smaller, a patch of the same color on her forehead, just above her right eyebrow, shaped a little like the state of Michigan.
“Those are called port-wine stains,” Tamsin said, touching Ivy’s cheek with one finger. “They’re birthmarks. The little blood vessels under the skin there just formed a bit wider than usual. They don’t hurt her at all.”
“Will they go away?” I asked.
“Usually they stay,” she said. “Some families choose laser treatment later on to lighten them, and some don’t. There’s no rush on any of that. The pediatrician will come look at them both today, and they’ll check Willa’s eyes, just because hers is up near her forehead. It’s a routine check.”
I looked down at my daughters and they looked back up at me with those dark, unfocused newborn eyes.
“Hi,” I whispered. “I’ve been waiting for you for ten years.”
Ivy sneezed. Willa grabbed my finger and held on.
I didn’t care about the marks one way or the other. I only kept thinking about the empty chair, and how much Simon would love this exact moment, and where on earth he was.
The nurse’s smile disappeared when I asked where my husband was
I called him four times while we waited. It went to voicemail every time.
“Hey, it’s Simon. Leave a message, or better yet, send me a text.”
I texted him. “They’re here. They’re perfect.
Where are you?” The message just sat there, delivered, unread.
I asked Tamsin if she had seen him. She said he had been in the hallway with the girls, and then he had talked to the doctor, and after that she didn’t know.
“Did something happen to him? Is he okay?”
“As far as I know he’s fine, honey,” she said. But she was folding the same blanket for the third time.
I started to think the worst, the way you do when you are full of anesthesia and hormones and you have just become somebody’s mother twice in two minutes.
Maybe he had panicked. Maybe he had looked at two babies and ten years of debt and a wife who had almost bled out on the table, and he had just walked away.
Then I thought about the question at the twenty-week scan. Can you tell if they’ll have any marks on their skin? And for one awful second I wondered if my husband had seen our daughters’ faces and left because of them.
I hated myself for even thinking it. But it was there, and it sat on my chest like a stone.
At 12:15, Dr. Lindqvist came in and closed the door behind her.
Dr. Lindqvist sat down on my bed and asked if I really didn’t know why he left
She pulled the chair over, Simon’s chair, and then changed her mind and sat on the edge of my bed instead. She looked tired. She had been up since four.
“First, you are going to be fine,” she said. “You lost a good amount of blood, and we’re going to keep an eye on you, but you did beautifully. And these two are healthy and strong.”
“Where’s Simon?”
She looked at me for a long moment.
“Yes, your husband saw the babies,” she said slowly. “He held them both. He was crying.” She tilted her head. “Rebecca, do you really not know why he left?”
I shook my head. My eyes were already filling up.
“While you were asleep, he came to talk to me,” she said. “He told me something I never expected to hear.”
I gripped the blanket. “Please just tell me. Did he leave because of their faces?”
Dr. Lindqvist reached over and put her hand on top of mine.
“No,” she said. “He left because of his own.”
Simon had been born with the same mark, and his mother spent his childhood trying to erase it
Simon had found her at the nurses’ station about forty minutes after the girls were born. He was white as the wall, she said, and his hands were shaking, and the first thing he asked her was whether it was his fault.
“He asked me if he did this to them,” she said. “If he passed it on.”
She had explained to him what she explained to me. A port-wine stain happens when a small group of blood vessels in the skin forms wider than usual while a baby is developing. It’s most often caused by a random change in a single gene early in pregnancy.
It isn’t caused by anything a mother eats, or does, or worries about. It isn’t caused by anything a father does either.
“Most of the time it doesn’t run in families at all,” she told me. “Sometimes chance just lands on the same family twice. Either way, nobody did this to these girls. I made sure he heard that.”
That was when Simon told her.
He had been born with a port-wine stain across most of his left cheek, from his eye down to his jaw. It looked a lot like Ivy’s.
His mother had been ashamed of it from the day he was born. She kept him out of photographs. When company came over, he was sent to his room to play. At church she sat him on her right side so people would only see the other half of his face.
From the time he was six until he was twelve, she drove him to Minneapolis every few months for laser treatments. The lasers back then hurt badly, and he was little, and nobody asked him if he wanted it. He told the doctor he remembered the smell of it and the ice packs on the car ride home.
By thirteen the mark had faded to a faint uneven patch you could only see in certain light. That was when his mother started letting people take his picture.
“He told me he had never told you,” Dr. Lindqvist said. “He said he had spent his whole adult life trying not to be that boy in the bedroom. And then he held his daughters and looked at their faces, and he said, ‘Nobody is ever going to do that to them.'”
Then he told her he had to go do something he should have done twenty-five years ago. He asked her to tell me he was coming back before sunrise, that it was not about the girls, and that he was bringing something back with him that I needed to see. He had left in such a hurry that his phone died in the car before he even reached the highway. His charger was still plugged into the wall by my bed.

I spent the night holding my daughters and thinking about every photo Simon ever stepped out of
I didn’t sleep much that night. The girls slept in their bassinets beside me, and every time one of them made a sound, I reached over and put my hand on her.
I kept going back over ten years of little things.
The beard. The right side at our wedding. The way he always volunteered to hold the camera.
The basement flood that ruined every baby picture. The school photos where he was always turned just a little.
And the question at the ultrasound, which I had taken as worry. It was worry, but not the kind I had imagined. He hadn’t been afraid of our daughters having marks. He had been afraid of what the world would do to them if they did.
At around two in the morning, Willa woke up and fussed, and I held her up against my shoulder and looked at the little red patch on her forehead in the glow of the monitor.
“Your daddy is coming back,” I told her. “I don’t know where he went, but I know him. He’s coming back.”
The pediatrician had come by that afternoon and looked at both girls. She told me the marks were exactly what Tamsin had said, that Willa’s eye check was clear, and that she’d see us at two weeks. That was the only good news I could hold on to, so I held on to it.
I texted Simon one more time, knowing his phone was dead. “We’re here. We love you. Come home to us.”
Three hours away, my husband stood in his mother’s kitchen and asked for the one picture she hid
Simon told me the rest later, sitting on the edge of my hospital bed with his head down.
He drove three hours north to Eau Claire without stopping. He got to his mother’s house just before dark. Irma opened the door in her housecoat and was so startled to see him that she asked if I had lost the babies.
“They’re here,” he told her. “Two girls. They both have the mark, Mom. Just like I did.”
He said she sat down at her kitchen table and put her hand over her mouth.
“Oh, Simon,” she said. “Oh, those poor things. We’ll find them a good doctor. They can start the treatments early, before they’re old enough to remember.”
That was the moment, he said, when twenty-five years came up out of him all at once.
He told her about every party he spent in his room. Every church service on her right side. Every Christmas card he wasn’t in. The smell of the laser and the ice packs on the way home, and how he would stare out the car window and try to figure out what was so wrong with his face that his own mother couldn’t look at it.
“I was protecting you,” Irma said.
“You were protecting yourself,” Simon said. “And you’re not going to do it to my daughters.”
Then he asked her for the photo.
He had always known there was one. When he was nine he had found it in her cedar chest, under her wedding veil: a hospital picture of him at two days old, with the mark across his cheek, before anyone could hide it. She had caught him looking and taken it away. There had never been a basement flood.
Irma didn’t argue. She went to the bedroom and came back with it and put it in his hand. Then she sat back down at the table and cried, and Simon said that for the first time in his life he didn’t try to make her feel better about it.
He told me later that walking back out to his car, he felt lighter than he had since he was a boy, and also so tired he could barely see.
He slept for two hours in his car at a rest stop outside Wisconsin Dells, and then he drove the rest of the way home to us.
He came back at dawn with grocery-store tulips and a photograph I had never seen
At 5:40 in the morning the door to my room opened.
Simon came in holding a bunch of yellow tulips with the grocery-store price sticker still on the plastic. He had something flat pressed against his chest under his other arm. His eyes were swollen and he hadn’t shaved.
He didn’t say hello. He went straight to the bassinets and knelt down and looked at Willa for a long time, and then at Ivy. He touched Ivy’s cheek with one knuckle, very lightly, the same place his own mark used to be.
Then he stood up and held out the photograph.
It was a faded little picture with rounded corners. A newborn in a hospital blanket, sleeping, with a deep red mark spread across his left cheek from his eye to his jaw.
“That’s me,” he said. “Two days old. It’s the only one.”
I looked at the picture, and then at Ivy, and I started to cry so hard Tamsin came in to check on me.
“I’m sorry I wasn’t here when you woke up,” he said. “I’m sorry I never told you. I didn’t know how to tell anybody.”
“They look like you,” I said.
He laughed and cried at the same time. “They look like me.”
He picked up both girls, one in each arm, and sat down in his chair by my bed. Then he looked straight at me and said something I will never forget.
“They’re going to be in every photo. Every birthday, every Christmas, every school picture, front and center. Nobody is ever going to put them in a bedroom when company comes.”
Tamsin took our first family photo with my phone. Simon looked right into the camera. He didn’t turn his face at all.

We hung my husband’s baby picture right between our daughters’ first photos
When we brought the girls home, the first thing Simon did was take a frame off the shelf in the hallway and put his baby photo in it. We hung it between the girls’ first hospital pictures. Three babies in a row, all with the same rosy color in the same kind of places.
A week later he shaved his beard off completely. You can still see the faint uneven patch on his left cheek in the right light. He doesn’t hide it anymore.
At their two-week checkup, the pediatric dermatologist explained everything again, gently. The marks might darken a little as the girls grow. Laser treatment is something we can talk about someday, if the girls ever want it, for their own reasons and on their own schedule. Until then, the marks are just part of their faces.
Irma called a few times that first year. Simon let it go to voicemail. Then, just after the girls’ first birthday, she wrote him a letter.
Four pages, in her careful handwriting, with no excuses in it at all. She said she had been raised to think a mark like that meant something was wrong with a family, and that she had let that matter more than her son.
Simon read it three times and then called her. He told her she was welcome to see her granddaughters, on one condition: she had to be in the photos with them. She came that Christmas and sat on the couch with a girl on each knee and looked at the camera with her chin up.
Our house is full of pictures now. Simon took more photos in the girls’ first year than I had seen him take in the whole decade before. There is one on the fridge of him asleep on the couch with both girls asleep on his chest, his left cheek turned right up toward the camera.
I took that one. He made me print it.
The girls are five now. They are loud and bossy and they love each other fiercely. Last month, Ivy brought her daddy’s baby picture to kindergarten for show-and-tell.
Her teacher told me that a boy in the class asked her what was on her face.
“It’s my wine spot,” Ivy told him. “My daddy had one too. It means I’m his.”
Now Trending:
- My Daughter-In-Law Kept Telling The Family My Husband And I Were “Losing Track Of Things” Because Money Kept Vanishing From Our Pumpkin Stand’s Honor Box. Then My Grandson’s Trail Camera Caught Our Old Coonhound Wagging His Tail At The Person Taking It
- A Week After Mom Died, My Brother And I Found 28 Packages Stacked Outside Her Apartment Door. She Had Never Ordered Anything Online In Her Life, And One Box Had An Instruction Taped To The Top For The Two Of Us
- While I Spent A Week In The Hospital After A Hard Delivery, My Mother-In-Law Used Our Spare Key To Paint Our Gray House Bubblegum Pink. She Called Me Ungrateful On The Porch, So I Made One Phone Call, And At 6:50 The Next Morning She Was Screaming On Her Own Lawn
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
