Off The Record
The Gas Station Clerk Told My 77-Year-Old Husband His Lottery Ticket Was A Loser And Dropped It In The Trash. Two Weeks Later The Clerk Claimed $1.3 Million, And The Lottery Investigator Wanted To Know Why The Winning Ticket Had Tooth Marks In It
My husband Orvis has played the same six numbers in the Ohio lottery since the spring of 1994.
Four, for the month we met. Eleven, for the day. Nineteen, for the year he was drafted, minus the 1900. Twenty-three, for the house number on Sunfish Creek Road where we raised our girl. Thirty-six, for the bushels per acre his daddy’s corn made the year it finally rained right. And forty-one, which he has never once explained to me, and I quit asking around 1998.
Two dollars on Wednesday and two dollars on Saturday. In thirty-one years that comes to something over six thousand dollars, and I know that because I did the math one night at the kitchen table and showed it to him, and he looked at the figure a long time and said, “Well, Thelda, it’s cheaper than bowling.”
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →He has won a few times. Forty dollars once. A hundred and twelve dollars the summer our well pump went out, which he still talks about like he found the Ark of the Covenant.
My name is Thelda Eppley. I am seventy-three years old. Orvis is seventy-seven. We live on forty acres outside Woodsfield, in Monroe County, Ohio, down in the hill country along the river where the roads were laid out by cows and never improved. Orvis worked thirty-four years at the aluminum plant at Hannibal and came home every night smelling like hot metal. I cut hair in a little shop on Main Street for most of my life, and if you were born in this county before 1990, I have probably given you a bowl cut.
We have one daughter, Pansy, who teaches middle school band in Columbus and calls every Sunday after church.
And we have Brute.

A Boxer Who Carries Paper
Brute is a fawn boxer with a white chest and a white face that was not always white. He is ten years old. He weighs sixty-eight pounds and is afraid of the vacuum cleaner, thunder, and our neighbor’s barn cat, who is about the size of a bread loaf. Orvis named him Brute as a joke, and the joke has held up for ten years.
Before Brute we had another boxer named Hondo, and Orvis taught Hondo to carry the newspaper from the end of the lane. When Hondo got old, Brute came along as a puppy and learned it by watching. Then one Saturday about eight years ago, Orvis bought his lottery ticket at Swafford’s Fuel and Grocery out on the state route, and on a whim he handed the ticket down to Brute in the parking lot and said, “Carry that to the truck.”
Brute carried it to the truck. He held it in his front teeth as gentle as you would hold an egg, jumped up on the bench seat, and sat there with it in his mouth like a cigar until Orvis said, “Give.” Then he let go of it in Orvis’s hand.
After that it was a ritual. Every Wednesday and every Saturday, Orvis went in, bought his ticket, came back out, and handed it to Brute. Brute carried it from the door to the truck, every time, with the whole parking lot watching. People would pull in just to see it. Truckers took pictures. Lennie Swafford, who has owned that store since 1979, kept a jar of dog biscuits on the counter that he called the Brute Fund.
Here is the thing I want you to remember, because it matters later. A boxer’s front teeth are not built for carrying paper. Every ticket that dog ever carried came out with two little dents along the left edge, about an inch and a half apart. Not holes, exactly. Pinches. You could feel them with your thumb.
Orvis never threw a losing ticket away. Not in thirty-one years. He kept them in Maxwell House coffee cans in the basement, a can for every year, with a strip of masking tape on the lid. I used to complain about it. I don’t anymore.
The New Man Behind the Counter
Last winter Lennie Swafford had his hip replaced and went to stay with his son in Marietta to heal up. He left the store to his stepdaughter’s husband, a man named Jarrett Kizer.
Jarrett was about thirty-four. He came from somewhere up near Cambridge and had married into the Swafford family three or four years before. He wore his hair shaved on the sides and long on top, and he called every woman over sixty “young lady,” which I have never in my life cared for. He had ideas about the store. He took out Lennie’s coffee pot and the two chairs where the old men sat, and put in an energy drink cooler and a machine that sold vape cartridges.
He did not care for Brute.
The first time Orvis came in with the dog behind him, Jarrett said dogs weren’t allowed past the door anymore. So Brute waited on the mat. Then Jarrett said the dog couldn’t wait on the mat either because it “blocked the flow.” So Brute waited in the truck, and Orvis carried the ticket out and handed it to him through the window, and Brute held it from the window to the bench seat, which is about three feet. Orvis said it still counted.
Jarrett also moved the Brute Fund jar behind the counter and then it disappeared altogether.
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →“That boy,” Orvis said one night, “would charge a man for the air in his tires.”
Monday Morning, January 12th
Orvis’s eyes are not what they were. He can drive fine in daylight and he can see a deer at three hundred yards, but small print swims on him. So for years he never checked his own numbers in the paper. He let the store do it. You hand the clerk your old ticket, the clerk scans it on the lottery machine, and the little screen tells you whether you won anything. Lennie used to read it out loud and make a show of it. “Not this week, Orvis. The Lord is building your character.”
The Saturday drawing on January 10th was a cold one. We’d had six inches of snow on the Thursday and it had frozen hard on top. Orvis bought his ticket that Saturday afternoon same as always, gave it to Brute in the truck, and Brute held it all the way home on the seat.
On Monday morning, January 12th, Orvis drove back to Swafford’s for coffee filters and a can of Prince Albert and to check his Saturday ticket. I was with him that day, because I needed stamps. I stayed in the truck with Brute and the heater on.
I watched through the window. I saw Orvis hand the ticket across the counter. I saw Jarrett scan it under the red light. And I saw Jarrett look down at the screen of that lottery machine a second longer than you would look at anything. Then he looked up and said something, and Orvis shrugged, and Jarrett dropped the ticket under the counter where the trash can was.
Orvis came out with his coffee filters and climbed in and said, “Nothing this time. The Lord’s still building my character.”
I didn’t think a thing about it. I want to be honest about that. I sat right there and watched it happen and thought nothing.
The Numbers on the Radio
Twelve days later I was in my kitchen canning the last of the venison chili, and the radio was on WOMP out of Bellaire, and the news man said that a Classic Lotto jackpot worth one point three million dollars had been sold at a gas station in Monroe County for the January 10th drawing. He said it was the first jackpot ticket sold in the county since 2006. Then he said the winning numbers.
Four. Eleven. Nineteen. Twenty-three. Thirty-six. Forty-one.
I put the ladle down. I turned the burner off. I walked out to the shop where Orvis was sharpening a chain on the bench grinder, and I didn’t say a word, I just reached over and pulled the plug out of the wall.
He looked at me like I’d lost my mind. I said the numbers to him, one at a time.
He sat down on an upturned bucket. He said, “Swafford’s?”
I said, “Swafford’s.”
He said, “Thelda, I bought one ticket that Saturday.”
Six Thousand Dollars and a Pinch Mark
We drove straight to the store. Jarrett was behind the counter eating sunflower seeds.
Orvis said, “Son, I believe you made a mistake on my ticket a couple of Mondays ago.”
Jarrett didn’t even blink. He said, “Mr. Eppley, that machine reads the ticket. I don’t. If it said you didn’t win, you didn’t win.” He spit a shell into a paper cup. “And I sure don’t remember you bringing in any ticket that week. Weren’t the roads iced over?”
I said, “I was sitting in that truck. I watched you drop it under the counter.”
He smiled at me. “Young lady, you were sitting in a truck forty feet away through a dirty windshield.”
Two days later the Ohio Lottery announced that the January 10th jackpot had been claimed. The winner had asked for privacy, which the law allows in some cases, but this is Monroe County. By Friday everybody knew it was Jarrett Kizer.
His wife, Ashtyn, posted a picture on Facebook of the two of them holding up a big cardboard check at the regional lottery office in Cambridge. She wrote underneath, “When you play the same numbers for years and God finally says yes!!! Haters stay quiet.”
Jarrett told anybody who would listen that the numbers were his own. His mother’s birthday, his wedding date, his lucky number from high school football. He said old man Eppley had been coming in for years playing “some numbers,” and now he was trying to cash in on a young family’s good fortune because he was jealous.
And some people believed him. That’s the part I wasn’t ready for.
What It Feels Like to Be Called Greedy at Seventy-Three
You live in one place your whole life, and you think people know you.
Then a woman I’d given a perm to every six weeks for nineteen years stopped me in the aisle at the IGA and said, “Thelda, I’m surprised at the two of you. That boy has a baby on the way.”
Our pastor, who I’d known since he was in diapers, came by the house and sat on the edge of our couch and said maybe we ought to “pray about letting it go,” because “money divides people.” Orvis asked him whether he’d let it go if somebody walked off with the offering plate. The pastor didn’t stay for pie.
Somebody wrote GREEDY OLD on our mailbox in silver paint marker. The rest of the word didn’t fit.
Ashtyn Kizer posted that we were “elderly people being manipulated” and that our daughter must have put us up to it. Pansy saw that one in Columbus and called me crying.
The hardest part was Orvis himself. He started second-guessing. He’d sit at the kitchen table at night with Brute’s head on his knee and say, “Maybe I didn’t play that Saturday. Maybe I’m mixing it up with the Wednesday.” I’d say, “You played it. I saw the dog carry it home.” And he’d say, “The dog carries one every time, Thelda. How would you know which one?”
He was right about that. How would I know which one?
The Coffee Cans in the Basement
It was Brute who made me think of it, though he didn’t mean anything by it.
One evening Orvis had his old ticket from Wednesday on the table, the one he’d bought at the Marathon in Woodsfield because he wouldn’t set foot in Swafford’s anymore. Brute had carried it. And I picked it up to throw it away, and my thumb ran across those two little pinches on the left edge, an inch and a half apart, and I stopped.
I went down in the basement and got the coffee can for 2019. Then 2021. Then 2024. I dumped them out on the kitchen table, hundreds and hundreds of losing tickets, and I started picking them up one at a time.
Every single one from the last eight years had the same two pinches in the same place. Brute’s front teeth. You could lay one ticket on top of another and the marks lined up like they’d been punched by a machine.
The ones from before Brute had marks too, but different. Hondo’s teeth were set wider.
I said, “Orvis. Where is the winning ticket right now?”
He said, “In Jarrett Kizer’s bank, I’d guess.”
I said, “No. A ticket that big, they keep. They have to.” I had read that somewhere, and I turned out to be half right.
A Phone Call to Cleveland
Pansy found the phone number for the Ohio Lottery’s security division and I called it the next morning. I got a recording, then a young man, then a woman named Joletta Faucette who said she was an investigator and asked me to start from the beginning.
I started from the beginning. I told her about the numbers and the thirty-one years. I told her about Monday the 12th and the trash can. She listened without interrupting, which in my experience is a rare thing in a person whose job is listening.
Then I told her about the dog.
There was a long quiet on the line. I thought she’d hung up. Then she said, “Mrs. Eppley, I want you to do something for me. Don’t post about this anywhere. Don’t talk to Mr. Kizer again. And would you be willing to box up some of those old tickets and send them to me?”
I said, “Honey, I’ll drive them up there myself.”
She said that wouldn’t be necessary. Two days later she drove down from Cleveland, three and a half hours, in a gray state car with a heater that didn’t work, and sat at my kitchen table in her coat.

Brute’s Audition
Ms. Faucette was about fifty, small and neat, with her hair pulled back so tight it looked like it hurt. She did not drink coffee. She drank a glass of tap water and said it was the best water she’d had in a year, which is because we’re on a spring.
She looked through the coffee cans for an hour with a little magnifying loupe like a jeweler’s. She measured the pinch marks with a plastic ruler and wrote things down. She didn’t tell us anything.
Then she asked if Brute would carry something for her.
Orvis took one of the blank sheets from my recipe pad, tore it the size of a ticket, and handed it down to Brute. “Carry it to the truck.” Brute looked at the woman, looked at Orvis, took the slip in his front teeth, walked out the kitchen door and across the frozen yard to the pickup, and stood by the door until Orvis opened it, then hopped on the seat and sat there like a deacon.
Orvis said, “Give.” Brute gave.
Ms. Faucette took the slip with a pair of tweezers, slid it into a little plastic sleeve, measured it, and held it next to a 2022 ticket from the coffee can.
She didn’t smile. She just nodded once, and wrote something, and said, “Thank you, Mr. Brute.”
On her way out she stopped at the door and said, “Mrs. Eppley, I can’t discuss an open claim. But I will tell you that the payment on that ticket has not been released. And I will tell you that I’ve been doing this job twenty-two years and I have never once had a winner bring me a ticket with tooth marks on it.”
The Machine Remembers
We found out the rest later, partly from Ms. Faucette and partly from the prosecutor in Woodsfield, and partly from Lennie Swafford, who came home from Marietta early on a walker to sort it out.
Here is what Jarrett Kizer didn’t know about the lottery machine on his own counter. Every time a ticket is scanned, the terminal sends a record to the lottery’s central computer. The record shows which store, which terminal, the exact second, and which ticket. And when a ticket over a certain amount is scanned, the machine plays a little chime and shows a message on the clerk’s screen telling him the winner has to claim it at a lottery office.
The record showed that the winning ticket from January 10th was scanned at Swafford’s terminal at 7:42 and 16 seconds on the morning of Monday, January 12th.
Jarrett had told the lottery, in writing, on his claim form, that he discovered he had won when he heard the numbers on the radio on January 24th, and that he checked the ticket himself at home against the newspaper and never scanned it anywhere.
So why was it scanned on his own counter at 7:42 on a Monday morning, twelve days before he says he knew?
And who was standing at that counter at 7:42 that Monday? Lennie Swafford had a camera behind the register. Jarrett had told people it had been broken since Christmas. It had not been broken since Christmas. Lennie had it hooked to a little recorder in the back office, which Jarrett never looked at because he never went back there except to smoke.
The tape showed Orvis in his green coat and his red cap handing a ticket across. It showed Jarrett scanning it, then staring at the screen. It showed him say something to Orvis, and shake his head, and drop his hand below the counter. It did not show the ticket going in the trash. It showed it going into the front pocket of his flannel shirt.
And it showed one more thing. When Orvis walked out, Jarrett took the ticket back out of his pocket, looked at it, and turned around and looked right out the window at our truck. At me. At Brute, sitting on the seat with his ears up.
What the Tooth Marks Were For
I asked Ms. Faucette later why the dog’s teeth mattered so much, if the machine had it on record anyway.
She said, “Because nobody would have pulled the record.” She explained that the lottery pays out thousands of claims a year. When someone shows up with a ticket and the right ID and the claim checks out, they pay it. Nobody goes digging through terminal logs unless something makes them dig.
“A man calls up and says the clerk stole his ticket,” she said. “We get that call every month. Usually it’s a man who didn’t buy a ticket. But a woman calls up and says the winning ticket has two marks on the left edge an inch and a half apart, and nobody outside that building has ever seen the ticket, and then I go look at it in the vault and there they are? That makes me dig.”
She said the pinch marks on the winning ticket matched Brute’s to within half a millimeter. She said the lab people in Columbus had a good laugh about it, and then they wrote it up very seriously.

Jarrett Kizer at the Courthouse
Jarrett was charged with theft and with filing a false claim with the lottery commission. It came out at the hearing that he’d already spent forty thousand dollars he didn’t have, on the strength of the check he thought was coming. A new truck on payments. A deposit on a lot over by Clarington.
He stood up in court in a borrowed tie and said he was sorry. He didn’t look at us. Ashtyn didn’t come.
He pled out. He’ll be on probation for a long time and he’ll pay back the lottery’s costs. Lennie Swafford fired him from the store in front of the energy drink cooler, which I’m told he then unplugged with his cane.
I have not made my peace with Jarrett Kizer, and I don’t think I’m required to yet. But I’ll say this. I think he thought he was stealing from a half-blind old man who wouldn’t know. I don’t think he thought for one second about the dog. Nobody ever does.
The Check, and Who Brought It
The Ohio Lottery paid Orvis in April. After taxes and taking the lump sum, it came to a little over seven hundred thousand dollars, which is less than one point three million but a good deal more than a hundred and twelve.
Ms. Faucette drove down from Cleveland again with the paperwork. This time she drank coffee.
The woman from the IGA aisle came out to the house with a pound cake and stood on the porch and couldn’t get the words out, so I took the cake and said, “I know,” and that was the end of that. Our pastor preached a sermon in May on the eighth commandment and never once looked at our pew. I’ve decided that was his apology.
We did not buy a boat or move to Florida. We put a new metal roof on the house and paid off the note on Pansy’s little house in Columbus, and Orvis bought the forty acres across Sunfish Creek he has wanted since 1981 so nobody can ever build a vape shop on it. We sent a check to the county dog shelter in Brute’s name, and they put up a plaque on the new kennel building that says BRUTE WING, which Orvis drives by more often than he needs to.
And we put money aside for the Brute Fund jar, which is back on Lennie’s counter, full.
Saturday Afternoon at Swafford’s
Orvis still plays the numbers. Four, eleven, nineteen, twenty-three, thirty-six, forty-one. Two dollars on Wednesday and two on Saturday. I asked him why, since lightning doesn’t strike twice, and he said it isn’t about the lightning.
Lennie lets Brute back in the store now. He walks right up to the counter on his old stiff legs, and Lennie hands the ticket down to him personally and says, “Carry that to the truck, sir,” and the whole store watches him do it.
The coffee cans are still in the basement. There’s one for this year on the shelf, half full. When Orvis gets his losing ticket back, he hands it to me, and I run my thumb along the left edge before I put it in the can. Two little pinches, an inch and a half apart.
And I finally asked him about the forty-one. I figured after all this he owed me.
He said, “That’s how old I’ll be when I finally pay off the farm.” He paid it off at fifty-three. He said he never changed the number because a man shouldn’t change his luck just because he was wrong about the math.
If you know an older couple whose word got doubted because somebody younger talked faster, maybe pass this along to them. And if you’ve got a dog who does one silly little thing the same way every single day, pay attention to it. You never know what it’s keeping track of.
Now Trending:
- I Rushed Home To Tell My Husband About My $24 Million Inheritance, But He And His Mother Were Waiting On The Driveway With Divorce Papers And My Packed Suitcases
- I Was A Surrogate At 22 And Never Held My Baby. Five Years Later The New CEO Knocked On My Door With A Little Boy And A Yellowed Envelope
- A Man In An Expensive Tie Shamed A Broke Teenager Over $4.87 At The Grocery Store. Then A 72-Year-Old Veteran Slammed His Cane On The Floor
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
