Off The Record
A Woman Threw My Towel On The Wet Deck And Stole My Lounge Chair On My Birthday Cruise. ‘It Doesn’t Say Your Name Anywhere,’ She Said. Ten Minutes Later She Shot Up Screaming, And The Whole Pool Deck Burst Out Laughing
I was still dripping from the pool when I saw my turquoise towel lying in a puddle on the deck.
My paperback was beside it, face down and soaking up water. My flip-flops had been kicked under the next chair.
And in my lounge chair, the one I had been sitting in since lunch, a young woman was stretched out on her own blue-and-white striped towel with her sunglasses pushed up on her head and one arm tucked behind it.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →“Excuse me,” I said. “That’s my chair.”
She looked me up and down, from my sensible black swim cap to my water shoes.

“Not anymore,” she said.
“My towel was on it. My book was on it.”
“It doesn’t say your name anywhere.” She smiled like she’d won a prize at the fair. “Lady, if you wanted it, you shouldn’t have gotten up.”
Then she pulled her sunglasses down over her eyes and turned her face to the sun.
Around us, the whole pool deck had gone still. A man in a parrot shirt lowered his cheeseburger. Two women in matching visors stopped in the middle of a sentence.
I’m 56 years old. I carried mail for 31 years through Tulsa summers and ice storms and a few dogs who meant business. I have been talked to worse than that.
So I bent down to pick up my towel.
And that’s when I saw what was lying on the deck behind her chair.
My kids handed me the cruise tickets inside a birthday card shaped like a fish
Let me back up.
I’m Brigid Hargis. I retired last spring from the post office after 31 years, most of them on the same route in midtown Tulsa. Eleven miles a day in a blue uniform and the best walking shoes money could buy.
I raised my two kids mostly on my own after their dad left when Arlo was four. Kit is 30 now and cleans teeth at a dental office in Broken Arrow. Arlo is 27 and fixes air conditioners, which in Oklahoma makes him the most popular man in town from May to September.
In August, they took me to dinner at our favorite Mexican place on Memorial Drive for an early birthday and slid a card across the table. It was shaped like a fish.
Inside were two printed pages. A seven-night cruise out of Galveston to Roatán, Belize and Cozumel. One passenger. An ocean-view cabin. Paid in full.
“Mom, you never do anything just for yourself,” Kit said. “So this is just for you.”
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →“You two can’t afford this,” I said.
“We’ve been saving since your retirement party,” Arlo said. “Don’t argue. You’ll lose.”
I cried into my enchiladas. The waiter brought me extra napkins and a free sopapilla with honey.
My birthday fell on the second day of the cruise, a day at sea with no ports. Kit made me promise I would spend it doing absolutely nothing.
“No helping anybody,” she said, pointing her fork at me. “No organizing anybody. Find a chair, read your book and let the world bring you a drink for once.”
It sounded like the easiest promise in the world.
It turned out to be the hardest one I ever made.
For thirty-one years I walked eleven miles a day, and I had no idea how to sit still
Kit and Arlo drove me down to Galveston, eight hours in Arlo’s truck with a cooler of sandwiches and a playlist Kit called “Mom’s Big Escape.”
They hugged me at the terminal like I was going off to war.
“Text us a picture of you in a chair,” Kit said. “A real chair. By a pool.”
The first day on the ship, I walked every deck twice. I found the library, the chapel, the laundry room and the crew elevator, which I was not supposed to use.
I helped a lost couple from Kansas find their muster station. I helped a young mother fold a stroller that had beaten her and her husband both. I told a teenager where the ice cream machine was, and then his little sister, and then about nine of their cousins.
By dinner, my feet hurt worse than they had in my last year on the route.
That night, in my little cabin with the round window, I called Kit.
“Have you sat down yet?” she asked.
“I’m sitting now,” I said.
“On a lounge chair? By a pool? With a book?”
“On my bed. With the TV on.”
She sighed like a mother. “Tomorrow’s your birthday. Promise me. One chair. One afternoon. Nobody else’s problems.”
So I promised again.
I had brought a paperback mystery I bought for a dollar at the Tulsa library sale, the kind with a lighthouse on the cover and a dead sea captain on page three. I had been saving it for this trip since June.
I laid out my turquoise striped towel, my straw sun hat, my water shoes and my sunscreen on the little desk the night before, like a kid on the first day of school.
I went to sleep smiling.
By nine-thirty in the morning, every lounge chair on the pool deck was taken except a row in the front
Nobody had warned me about the chairs.
I came up to the pool deck at nine-thirty on my birthday morning, after a waffle with strawberries and whipped cream, and every lounge chair on both sides of the pool already had a towel on it. A lot of them had no people. Just a towel, a book and a pair of sunglasses holding the spot like orange cones on a highway.
I walked the whole deck twice. Up by the railing, full. By the bar, full. In the shade, full, full and full.
I went back down to my cabin and read on my bed for a while, feeling a little foolish.
After lunch, I tried again. And this time I saw it: a whole row of empty blue lounge chairs right at the front, near the railing, with the ocean sparkling behind them like a postcard.
“Well, look at that,” I said to nobody.
I picked the middle one, spread my towel on it and sat down with my book like I owned the ship.
A woman in a visor two chairs back leaned forward. “You sure you want that one, hon?”
“Why not?” I said. “Best view on the boat.”
She looked at her friend. Her friend looked at her. They both smiled.
“It’s my birthday,” I said, though they hadn’t asked. “I’m 56 today.”
“Well, happy birthday,” they said together, and for some reason that made them both laugh.
I didn’t think a thing of it. I took a picture of my feet on the chair and sent it to Kit. She sent back eleven hearts.
I read three chapters. A steward brought me a lemonade with a pink paper umbrella. The sea captain’s body washed up on the rocks below the lighthouse.
At about twenty to three, I was so hot my sunscreen was sliding off my nose. So I set my book face down on my towel, lined up my flip-flops neatly by the leg of the chair, and went for a swim.
I was gone ten minutes. Maybe eleven.
That’s all it took.
The young woman in my chair had decided it didn’t have my name on it
So there I stood, dripping, while she lay in my chair with her sunglasses on.
I want to be fair to her, the way I would want somebody to be fair to me. She was maybe 30, pretty, with brown hair piled in a messy bun and a plain black one-piece swimsuit. She looked tired around the eyes in a way sunglasses can’t hide.
But she had picked up my towel and dropped it on a wet deck. She had tossed my book. And she had called me lady the way some people say it, like a word you scrape off your shoe.
“Ma’am, you want me to get somebody?” the man in the parrot shirt called over.
“No, thank you,” I said. “I’m fine.”
I crouched down to get my towel out of the puddle.
That’s when I saw the sign.
It was lying flat on the teak behind her chair, where it must have slid off its little metal stand in the wind. It was about the size of a cookie sheet, bright yellow, with a cartoon skull wearing a pirate hat.
I turned it over with one finger.
“SPLASH ZONE,” it said in big red letters. “FRONT ROW. PIRATE FOAM PARTY, 3 P.M. YOU WILL GET WET. YOU WILL GET FOAMED. ARRR.”
I looked up. Right above the front row, mounted on the railing one deck up, were three big black nozzles I had taken for some kind of air vents.
I looked at the clock over the bar. It was 2:49.
I looked at the two women in visors. They were biting their lips.
Now I understood why that whole row had been empty on a packed ship. The regulars knew. I had been about to get foamed myself, on my birthday, in front of everybody.
I stood up with my wet towel and my soggy book, and I smiled at the woman in my chair.
“You’re right,” I said. “Enjoy your chair.”
She smirked and didn’t even look up.
On my way to the towel stand, the activities host asked me if I had seen a volunteer
I didn’t plan anything. I want that on the record.
I was walking to the towel stand to trade my wet towel for a dry one when a young man in a white polo shirt and a black pirate bandana came hurrying past with a clipboard. His name was Marco. He was the cheerful activities host who had taught line dancing the night before, and right then he looked worried.
“Ma’am, have you seen anybody in the front row who wants to be captain?”he asked me. “Every foam party we crown a pirate captain. Best seat in the house. Nobody ever wants to volunteer.”
I looked back over my shoulder at my chair.
Then I looked at Marco.
I thought about Kit telling me not to help anybody. And I decided this didn’t count.
“The young lady in the middle chair of the front row,” I said. “She told me she’d love to be your captain. She’s a little shy about it, so maybe make it a surprise.”
His whole face lit up like Christmas morning.
“Thank you, ma’am!” he said. “You just saved my whole afternoon.”
I took a dry towel and went up the stairs to the upper deck, where there was a little patch of shade by the railing that looked straight down on the pool.
The two women in visors had followed me. One of them was named Darlene. Her sister was Faye. They were retired schoolteachers from Dayton, Ohio, on their fourth cruise together.
“Did you just do what I think you did?” Darlene asked.
“I just answered a young man’s question,” I said.
Faye handed me a fresh lemonade from the bar. “Happy birthday, hon,” she said. “The best seat in the house is up here.”
At 2:58, the music changed.

At three o’clock sharp, the foam cannons opened right over the front row
First, the DJ played a cannon blast so loud the whole deck jumped.
Then Marco grabbed a microphone. “Ladies and gentlemen, it’s three o’clock, and you know what that means!”
The crowd around the pool, the ones who knew, started cheering. Parents pulled their kids back from the front row. Somebody hollered, “Here it comes!”
The woman in my chair didn’t hear any of it. She had earbuds in and her face turned up to the sun.
The three black nozzles above her gave a little cough.
Then they opened.
Foam came pouring out like the whole sky was made of whipped cream. It hit the front row in a thick white wave and kept coming. In about four seconds, my chair, my former chair, disappeared under a mountain of bubbles, and so did she.
There was a pause.
Then the mountain sat straight up.
“WHAT DID YOU DO?!” she screamed.
She was white from head to toe, like a lemon meringue pie. Foam on her sunglasses, foam in her bun, foam dripping off the end of her nose. She was looking right up at me on the upper deck, because she had figured out exactly who to blame.
And the whole pool deck burst out laughing.
The man in the parrot shirt laughed so hard he had to sit down. A little boy in a shark float screamed with joy. Darlene had tears running down her face. Faye had to hold onto the railing.
I’m not proud of it. But I laughed too, until my sides hurt.
Then Marco came running through the foam in his pirate bandana, holding a cardboard pirate hat and an inflatable sword high over his head.
“Everybody, give it up for our volunteer!” he boomed into the microphone. “Your new Captain Foam!”
Then the strangest thing happened, and Captain Foam started to dance
I braced myself for a scene. I figured she would storm off to guest services, or come up those stairs and give me a piece of her mind.
She did neither.
First she grabbed for her phone, which had been sitting on the armrest. It was gone. Her mouth fell open in horror.
Then a steward named Teodoro, a gray-haired man who I later learned had worked that pool deck for eleven years, stepped out of the foam and handed it to her, sealed tight in a zip-top plastic bag.
“I saw it coming, miss,” he said. “I always grab the phones at 2:55.”
She stared at the phone. She stared at Teodoro. Then Marco set the cardboard pirate hat on her foamy head and put the inflatable sword in her hand, and the DJ started a pirate song with a big thumping drum.
And she laughed.
It started as a snort. Then she bent over. Then she was laughing so hard she had to hold onto Marco’s arm to stay standing.
The crew started a conga line through the foam, and they put her at the front of it, waving her sword. Kids followed her. Grandmas followed her. The man in the parrot shirt followed her with his cheeseburger still in his hand.
Faye took about sixty pictures on her phone.
I watched from the upper deck with my lemonade, and somewhere in the middle of it, I stopped feeling clever and started feeling glad for her.
Whatever had put those tired circles under her eyes, she wasn’t thinking about it now.
She was Captain Foam, and she was dancing.
An hour later, she found me at the railing holding two piña coladas
I had found a dry spot on the upper deck and was finally reading my mystery when a shadow fell across the page.
It was her. She was still a little foamy behind the ears, wrapped in a ship’s terry bathrobe, holding two piña coladas with pineapple wedges on the rims.
She held one out to me.
“I’m Dani,” she said. “And I owe you an apology.”
I took the drink. “I’m Brigid. And you might owe me one, but I believe I owe you one too.”
“You told Marco I volunteered.” She sat down in the deck chair next to mine. “He told me. He thinks you’re the nicest lady on the whole ship.”
“Well,” I said, “I mostly am.”
She laughed, and then her face crumpled a little.
“I’m sorry about your towel. And your book. I’m not usually like that.” She looked out at the water. “My boyfriend was supposed to be on this cruise with me. He broke up with me three days before we sailed. By text. I came anyway because the tickets weren’t refundable, and I’ve been mad at the whole world since Galveston.”
“Oh, honey,” I said.
“And then this lady had the one chair I’d been wanting all morning,” she said, “and I just snapped. That’s no excuse.”
“No, it isn’t,” I said. “But it’s a reason. And you just danced in front of four hundred people in a cardboard hat, so I’d say you’ve paid your fine.”
She laughed so hard she snorted piña colada.
We sat there until the sun went down. She was 31, from Houston, and worked as an office manager for a dentist, which got me telling her all about Kit. I told her about my mail route, and about the dog on 41st Street who bit me twice in the summer of 1998 and then followed me home like he was sorry.
Before she went in for dinner, she said, “Can we share that chair tomorrow? You take the mornings. I’ll take the afternoons. Whoever’s swimming, the other one guards it.”
“Deal,” I said. “But we’re sitting in the second row.”
The next morning, a man in a white uniform knocked on my cabin door
At 8:15 on our first port day, there was a knock.
A man in a crisp white uniform stood in the hallway with a small envelope and a big smile. He was from guest services. Behind him, grinning from ear to ear, was Marco.
“Mrs. Hargis,” the man said. “We heard yesterday was your birthday. And we heard you recruited the best pirate captain we’ve ever had.”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I said, and Marco laughed out loud in the hallway.
“Captain Foam’s video has been shown at three crew meetings,” Marco said. “The captain, the real one, wants a copy.”
The envelope held a key card and a little folded map. For the rest of the cruise, they were giving me one of the private cabanas on the top deck, the ones with white curtains, a cushioned daybed and a little fridge full of cold water and cut fruit.
“For the birthday lady,” the man said. “Because you never got to keep your chair.”
I sat down on my bed and cried for the second time that trip, and Marco patted my shoulder like a grandson.
That afternoon, I lay on my cabana daybed in my big straw sun hat, with my mystery and a glass of iced tea and the whole blue ocean spread out in front of me.
I didn’t help anybody. I didn’t organize anybody.
I finished my book. The lighthouse keeper did it.
Dani came up at four with two more piña coladas and a pair of the ship’s chocolate chip cookies wrapped in napkins. We shared that cabana the rest of the week, the way we had promised to share the chair.
In Cozumel, Dani and I found a beach with no lounge chairs at all
On the last port day, we took a taxi to a little beach on the far side of the island.
There were no lounge chairs, just white sand and a palm-roofed shack selling fish tacos and cold drinks out of a cooler. We laid our towels in the sand side by side.
“No chairs to fight over,” Dani said.
“That’s why I picked it,” I said.
She told me she had been thinking about going back to school to become a dental hygienist, like Kit. I told her Kit would talk her ear off about it if she let her. She asked for Kit’s number, and I gave it to her.
We swam out to a buoy and back. She waited on the beach and guarded my towel. Then I guarded hers.
On the ride back to the ship, she leaned her head against the taxi window.
“You know what’s funny?” she said. “I came on this cruise because I didn’t want to be alone. And the one person I was rude to is the one person I haven’t felt alone with.”
I patted her knee. “Life does that,” I said. “Especially on boats.”
That last night, Darlene and Faye found us at dinner and sent me every picture Faye had taken. There was one I liked best of all.
It was Dani in the middle of the foam, in her cardboard pirate hat with her sword in the air, laughing with her whole face. And behind her, up on the deck by the railing, a small woman in a sun hat laughing just as hard.
That was me.
On the last night of the cruise, Marco called Captain Foam up on stage, and she would not go alone
After dinner, everybody packed into the ship’s big theater for the farewell show. There were singers and a juggler and a slideshow of the week set to music.
Near the end, Marco jogged out in his pirate bandana with a microphone.
“Before we say goodbye,” he said, “we have one more award. This week we crowned the greatest pirate captain in the history of this ship. Captain Foam, get up here!”
The whole theater cheered. Dani turned bright red and shook her head.
Then she grabbed my hand.
“Only if my first mate comes too,” she said, loud enough for three rows to hear.
So up we went, a 56-year-old retired mail carrier and a 31-year-old office manager from Houston, up the steps and into the bright lights.
Marco put the cardboard pirate hat back on Dani’s head. Then he pulled a second one out from behind his back and put it on mine.
“And a very happy belated birthday to the lady who found our captain,” he said.
Four hundred people sang “Happy Birthday” to me in a ship’s theater in the middle of the Gulf of Mexico. Darlene and Faye stood on their seats.
Dani leaned into the microphone before we went back down.
“This lady taught me some manners this week,” she said. “And she did it without saying one mean word.”
I didn’t know what to say to that. So I just waved my inflatable sword.

Kit and Arlo met me at the Galveston terminal, and I showed them the picture
They had driven all the way down from Tulsa to pick me up, eight more hours in Arlo’s truck.
“Well?” Kit said, before I had even set my bag down. “Did you sit in a chair? Did you read your book?”
“I sat in a cabana,” I said. “I read the whole book. I made a friend. And I may have started a small foam incident.”
“Mom,” Arlo said slowly. “What did you do?”
I showed them the picture.
They laughed so hard in the parking lot that a security guard came over to make sure everyone was all right. Then I told them the whole story, and they laughed most of the way to Houston.
Kit had the picture printed and framed for Christmas. It hangs in my living room now, right above my reading chair, and every person who comes to my house asks about it.
Dani and I text every week. She started hygiene school in January, and Kit has been helping her study. In the spring, Dani drove up to Tulsa for a weekend, and we all went to the Mexican place on Memorial Drive. She told the foam story to my kids herself, and she told it better than I do.
Next fall, we’re going on a cruise together. Her treat, she says, though I’ll be fighting her for the check.
We already know where we’re sitting.
Second row.
Now Trending:
- My Mother-In-Law Scraped My Dinner Into The Dog Bowl And Said Nobody Had To Feed Me. I Told Her I Was Done Paying For Everyone In My Condo. Then She Whispered, ‘Ask Bram What He Signed Last Month’
- My Drunk Brother Took My 7-Year-Old On His Jet Ski Without A Life Jacket And Came Back Alone, Laughing. When I Reached For My Phone, My Dad Grabbed My Arm And Screamed, “Don’t Get Your Brother Arrested!”
- My Husband Paid Me $50 Million To Divorce Him So His Mistress’s Twins Would Be ‘Legitimate.’ I Signed, Flew Across The Country And Sent Him One Text From The Gate. When I Landed, I Had 43 Missed Calls
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
