Connect with us

My Daughter-In-Law Kept Telling The Family My Husband And I Were “Losing Track Of Things” Because Money Kept Vanishing From Our Pumpkin Stand’s Honor Box. Then My Grandson’s Trail Camera Caught Our Old Coonhound Wagging His Tail At The Person Taking It

Off The Record

My Daughter-In-Law Kept Telling The Family My Husband And I Were “Losing Track Of Things” Because Money Kept Vanishing From Our Pumpkin Stand’s Honor Box. Then My Grandson’s Trail Camera Caught Our Old Coonhound Wagging His Tail At The Person Taking It

Every October for thirty-one years, my husband Burdette has pulled the old hay wagon out to the end of our lane on Bloomfield Road and filled it with pumpkins.

We grow about two acres of them behind the barn, along with gourds and Indian corn and a row of those white pumpkins that the young mothers like to put on their porches now. We don’t sit out there and sell them. We never have. Burdette built a little wooden box with a slot in the lid and a padlock on the front in 1994, and he screwed it to the wagon bed, and he painted a sign that says PUMPKINS $5, GOURDS 3 FOR $1, PAY IN THE BOX, GOD BLESS. People pull off the road, pick out a pumpkin, and put their money through the slot.

You would be amazed how honest people are. Most years we come out ahead of what we sold, because folks round up, or leave a twenty for two pumpkins and drive off. One year somebody left a jar of sorghum molasses on top of the box with a note that said “Short on cash, long on sorghum.” We ate it all winter.

My name is Ivalee Crenshaw. I am seventy-four, and Burdette is seventy-seven, and we have lived on these ninety acres outside Bardstown, Kentucky, for fifty-two years. We raised one son, Gaither, who works at one of the big bourbon warehouses and lives fifteen minutes away in a new subdivision with his wife Tiffani and their boy Rafe, who is sixteen and the best thing that ever happened to either of us.

And then there is Badger.

Badger is a bluetick coonhound. He’s eleven. Burdette hunted him for seven seasons until his ears and his knees both told him to quit, and now Badger spends his October afternoons lying in the grass beside the pumpkin wagon like a watchman who has long since forgotten what he was supposed to be watching for. He bays at every car that pulls off the road. Every single one. Then he goes over and smells their tires and lets them pat his head and comes back and lies down. It’s the closest thing we have to a cash register bell.

The Count Comes Up Short

Every evening at dusk, Burdette walks down the lane with the key on its string around his neck and unlocks the box, and we count the money at the kitchen table. We have done it the same way for thirty-one years. I count the bills and he counts the change and we write it in a spiral notebook along with how many pumpkins are gone from the wagon.

The second week of September, the count came up short.

We’d put out forty-two pumpkins that morning. At dusk there were eighteen left. Twenty-four pumpkins at five dollars is a hundred and twenty dollars, and there was forty-one dollars in the box.

“Well,” Burdette said, “somebody got some cheap pumpkins.”

That happens. Not often, but it happens. We wrote it down and went to bed.

But it happened again three days later. And again the next week. By the end of September, we’d come up short eleven times, and the shortages were getting bigger. One Saturday we sold sixty-one pumpkins and found ninety-three dollars in the box. Burdette went out and looked at the padlock with a flashlight like it might confess.

It wasn’t broken. It wasn’t scratched. The box was locked tight every time.

“You’re Just Losing Track”

We mentioned it at Sunday dinner. That was our mistake, I suppose.

Tiffani set down her fork and gave me a look I didn’t understand yet, and then she gave Gaither another one. “Ivalee,” she said in that soft voice she uses on the cashiers at the grocery store, “are you sure you’re counting right?”

“I’ve been counting money since before you were born, honey.”

“I know you have,” she said. “That’s what worries me.”

I’d like to say I had always gotten along with my daughter-in-law. I’d be lying. Tiffani is a good-looking woman and she keeps a clean house and she has done fine by Rafe, I’ll give her that. But she has always looked at our farm the way some people look at a dresser at a yard sale, like she’s adding up what it would be worth if somebody would just refinish it. When Gaither married her, the first time she walked in my kitchen she asked me how much I thought the land was worth per acre.

After that Sunday, she started calling. Every couple of days. “How was the count last night?” And if I told her it was short, she’d make a little sad noise.

Then she started saying it to other people. My sister in Elizabethtown called me to ask if I was all right, because Tiffani had told her at a baby shower that “Mom and Dad are really starting to lose track of things.” Our preacher’s wife asked me after church if I needed help with my checkbook. Gaither came by on a Tuesday evening by himself and stood in my kitchen with his hands in his pockets, the way he used to when he’d broken something as a boy.

“Mama,” he said, “Tiff thinks maybe it’s time to look at some places.”

“What places?”

“Just places. Maple Grove has those nice apartments in town. You wouldn’t have to mow.”

“I don’t mow, son. Your father mows. He likes to mow.”

“Dad’s seventy-seven.”

“And he still likes to mow.”

A Little Test at the Pharmacy

Tiffani took me to a “memory screening” in the second week of October. That’s what she called it. It was a folding table in the back of the pharmacy on Third Street, and a nice young woman in a white coat asked me to remember three words and draw a clock with the hands at ten past eleven.

I remembered the words. Apple, table, penny. I drew the clock, and I put the numbers on it, and I made the little hand a good deal shorter than the big one so there’d be no confusion.

“That’s perfect, Mrs. Crenshaw,” the young woman said.

In the parking lot, Tiffani was on her phone before I got my seat belt buckled. “She did okay,” she said to someone, “but they say it can come and go.”

They do not say that. Nobody said that. I sat in her nice car with the heated seats and looked out the window at the Dollar General and felt about two feet tall.

When I got home, Burdette was sitting on the porch steps with Badger’s head in his lap. He looked up at me and didn’t have to ask.

“I’m not crazy, Burdette,” I said.

“I know it, Vallie.”

“Somebody’s in that box.”

“I know that too.” He scratched the dog behind the ears. “The question is how.”

Rafe’s Deer Camera

Rafe came over the next Saturday to help his grandpa haul pumpkins up from the patch. He’s a tall, quiet boy who plays trombone in the marching band and eats like a combine, and he has always been easier with us than with anybody else. When I told him about the box, he didn’t laugh, and he didn’t make a sad noise. He just thought about it.

“Grandma,” he said, “you still got that trail camera I gave Grandpa for Christmas?”

He’d given Burdette one of those little camouflage deer cameras two years before, so Burdette could see what was eating the sweet corn. It had been sitting in its box in the hall closet ever since, because Burdette said he already knew what was eating the sweet corn. It was raccoons. It’s always raccoons.

Rafe strapped that camera to the fence post across the lane from the pumpkin wagon, about four feet up, pointed right at the honor box. He showed us how it worked. Anything that moved in front of it, it took a little video. Thirty seconds at a time, day or night.

“Don’t tell anybody it’s there,” he said. “Not Mom, not Dad, not anybody.”

I thought that was an odd thing for him to say. I didn’t think about why.

The Video

We left it up for six days. The count was short on three of them.

Rafe came over the next Sunday afternoon after church, while his parents were at a cookout in their subdivision. He pulled the little memory card out of the camera, put it in his laptop on my kitchen table, and Burdette and I sat on either side of him with our reading glasses on.

There were a hundred and forty little videos. Most of them were what you’d expect. A pickup truck full of high school girls laughing and picking out pumpkins. A young couple with a baby in a sling. An old man I recognized from the feed store, who put a ten through the slot, took one pumpkin, and patted Badger on the head. Badger bayed at every single one of them first, then went over and sniffed their tires.

Then we came to the one from Thursday evening, just after six. It was getting dark. The camera had switched to that grainy gray night picture.

A car pulled off onto the shoulder with its headlights off. You couldn’t see the car well, just the shape of it. A person got out. They had on a long dark coat with the hood up, and they walked straight to the box, not to the pumpkins. They didn’t look at a single pumpkin. They bent over the padlock, and you could see their hands working at it, and then the lid came up.

They took out a handful of bills. Not all of them. Just most. Then they shut the lid and locked it again.

“They’ve got a key,” Burdette said. His voice was rough. “That’s a key, Vallie.”

There are three keys to that padlock. Burdette’s is on a string around his neck. Mine is on my ring. And the spare has hung on the little hook inside our kitchen door, beside the calendar from the funeral home, for thirty-one years.

But that isn’t what made me put my hand over my mouth.

It was Badger.

He didn’t bay. In every one of a hundred and forty videos, that dog bayed at whoever pulled off the road. Not this time. In the gray picture, you could see him get up out of the grass with his tail going. Not a little. His whole back end was going. He trotted right over to the hooded person, and they bent down and gave him something out of their coat pocket, and he flopped over in the grass on his back with his legs in the air like a puppy.

Badger doesn’t roll over for strangers. He doesn’t roll over for the mailman, who has been bringing him a biscuit every day for nine years. He rolls over for Burdette, and for me, and for Rafe.

And for one other person, who has fed him ham from her plate under our dinner table every Sunday for eighteen years, even though I have asked her not to a hundred times.

Rafe closed the laptop. He didn’t say anything. His ears had gone red.

“Honey,” I said, “did you know?”

He shook his head. Then he nodded. Then he said, very quietly, “I thought maybe. She’s had a lot of cash lately. And she’s been getting real mad at Dad about bills.”

A Pumpkin on Every Twenty

I could have called Gaither right then. I could have marched over to that cookout in the subdivision and set the laptop on the picnic table in front of all their neighbors. Burdette wanted to. He stood in the kitchen with his big hands opening and closing, and I’d never seen him so angry in fifty-two years.

But I kept thinking about how it would go. A hooded coat. A gray picture. A dog wagging his tail. I could hear her already. “Ivalee, a lot of people wear dark coats. That dog loves everybody. Are you sure you’re seeing it right?” And I could see my son’s face, not knowing which of us to believe, and choosing the one he had to go home with.

So I did something else.

On Monday morning I went to the bank in town and took out four hundred dollars in twenties. Then I sat at my kitchen table with a blue ballpoint pen and, in the bottom left corner of every bill, so small you’d have to know to look, I drew a little pumpkin. Round, with a stem. I’ve been doodling pumpkins in the margins of church bulletins for forty years. I can do it in my sleep.

Then I made two phone calls.

The first was to my niece Dulcie, my sister’s girl, who owns the hair salon on Stephen Foster Avenue where Tiffani has gotten her hair colored every other Friday for six years. The second was to Myrtis Haines, who has been a teller at our bank since 1981, and who taught Sunday school with me for twenty of those years.

I told each of them the same thing. “If you see a twenty with a little blue pumpkin drawn in the corner, I want you to call me, and I want you to remember who handed it to you.”

Every evening that week, before dusk, I put two of my marked twenties into the honor box. Burdette went down after dark and counted. Monday they were there. Tuesday they were gone. Thursday they were gone again, along with sixty dollars of the pumpkin money.

Friday afternoon at a quarter to four, Dulcie called. She was whispering.

“Aunt Vallie,” she said. “She just paid. Cut and color and a tip. Eighty-five dollars. Three of them have your pumpkin.”

On Monday morning, Myrtis called too. Tiffani had come through the drive-up window and deposited three hundred and forty dollars in cash into a credit card account in her own name only. Myrtis had kept the twenties in her drawer the way I’d asked. Four of them had a little blue pumpkin in the corner.

The Maple Grove Brochure

Thanksgiving was at our house that year. It always is. Burdette smoked the turkey, and I made the dressing and the sweet potatoes and the chess pie, and Gaither and Tiffani and Rafe came at noon like always.

We were having pie when Tiffani reached into her big leather purse and brought out a glossy folder and set it on the table between the chess pie and the whipped cream.

“I know this is hard,” she said, putting her hand on mine. “But Gaither and I have been talking. And we think it’s time you two thought seriously about Maple Grove. They have a two-bedroom opening in January. I talked to my friend Sabra Garrity, she’s a realtor, and she says the farm would list really well in the spring. We’d help you with all of it.”

Gaither was looking at his plate.

“You’ve been losing money from that box for two months, Ivalee,” Tiffani said, gently, so gently. “You’ve been confused. It’s not your fault. It happens to everybody.”

I patted her hand. Then I took it off mine.

I got up and went to the drawer under the telephone, where I keep the spiral notebook with thirty-one years of pumpkin counts in it, and I brought back the notebook, and an envelope, and Rafe’s laptop, which he had left with me the week before for this exact purpose.

I opened the envelope and laid seven twenty-dollar bills on the white tablecloth in a row, right on top of the Maple Grove brochure. Three from Dulcie’s register. Four from Myrtis’s drawer.

“Gaither,” I said, “would you look at the bottom left-hand corner of those for me?”

He picked one up. He held it close to his face. He’d been doodling pumpkins on my church bulletins with me since he was four years old, sitting in the pew in his little clip-on tie. He knew that pumpkin as well as he knew my handwriting.

“Mama, this is your pumpkin.”

“It is,” I said. “I drew one on every twenty I put in that box the week before last. Those three came out of your wife’s purse at Dulcie’s salon. Those four, she paid onto a credit card at the bank that you don’t know about.”

Then I opened the laptop, and Rafe reached over without being asked and pressed play, and we all watched the hooded coat walk up to the honor box in the gray light, and the key go into the padlock, and an old bluetick coonhound come up out of the grass with his whole back end wagging and roll over on his back in the weeds for the one person in Nelson County who always brought him ham.

Under the table, Badger thumped his tail on the floor.

What She Owed

Tiffani didn’t cry at first. She said the bills could have come from anywhere. She said she’d bought pumpkins herself and given them change. She said the video could be anybody. And then Rafe said, very quietly, “Mom, that’s the coat Dad got you for Christmas,” and she stopped.

It came out in pieces after that, mostly to Gaither, in our front room with the door half shut. She had run up forty-seven thousand dollars on three credit cards he didn’t know existed. Clothes, furniture for the new house, a trip to Destin with her girlfriends that she’d told him her sister paid for. The companies were calling her at work. She’d been taking a few hundred from our box every week to keep the minimum payments from going under.

But it wasn’t really about the pumpkin money. Two hundred dollars a week wasn’t going to fix forty-seven thousand. She’d figured that if she could get us into Maple Grove and get the farm sold, Gaither would get what she called “his share” early, and she could pay it all off before he ever knew. And the easiest way to get two old people to give up their land was to convince everybody, including themselves, that they couldn’t count anymore.

She’d used our own spare key. She’d taken it off the hook by the kitchen door one Sunday in August while I was making gravy, had a copy made at the hardware store, and hung it back before dessert.

Gaither came out of the front room looking twenty years older. He sat down across from his father and didn’t say anything for a long time.

“I believed her, Dad,” he said finally. “I’m sorry. I really believed her.”

Burdette looked at him for a while. Then he said, “Well. You’ve got a lot of pumpkins to haul next year.”

Next October

We didn’t call the sheriff. I want to be honest about that, because some people have told me we should have. Gaither paid back every dollar of the pumpkin money out of his own paycheck, and he and Tiffani sat down with a credit counselor in Louisville, and she sold the furniture and got a second job at the outlet mall on weekends. They are still married. I don’t know what happens behind their door. That’s their business now, and I’d like it to stay that way.

But I made one condition, and I said it at my own kitchen table with my son sitting there.

“Next October,” I said, “on Saturdays, you’re going to sit at that pumpkin stand, Tiffani. In a lawn chair beside the wagon. All day. And you’re going to watch how people put their money in that box when they think nobody’s looking.”

She did it, too. Every Saturday last fall, from nine to dusk, in a lawn chair beside the wagon with Badger lying at her feet. The first Saturday she sat with her arms crossed and her sunglasses on and didn’t say a word to anybody. By the third one she was helping young mothers pick out white pumpkins and telling them which ones would last until Thanksgiving. On the last Saturday in October, a man in a feed cap left a fifty for two pumpkins, tipped his hat, and drove off before she could make change, and she stood there holding the bill and crying, and I don’t think it was about the money.

Rafe took the trail camera back down. Burdette put a new padlock on the box and hung the only spare key around my neck on a string to match his.

Badger still bays at every car that pulls off the road. And when Tiffani comes for Sunday dinner, he still rolls over on his back and waits for his ham. Dogs don’t hold grudges. I’ve thought a lot about that this year. I’m not sure whether it’s the best thing about them or the most foolish.

But I know he wagged for her because she was family. And I know she counted on that. She thought nobody would ever look twice at a happy old dog.

She forgot that I always count.

If you’ve ever had someone try to convince you that you were the one getting things wrong, I hope this one stays with you a while. And if you know an older couple still running a little stand by the road on the honor system, stop and buy a pumpkin this year. Then pass this story along to somebody who still believes in that box.

Now Trending:

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family

Continue Reading

Jason is a writer and storyteller who focuses on the human side of the stories — moments of kindness, resilience, family, and the turning points that quietly change a life. He writes to inform, engage, and inspire, and believes the best stories are the ones that make readers feel less alone.