Off The Record
The Roofer Took Our $14,800 Deposit After The Hailstorm And Never Came Back. When We Asked For It, He Swore Our Old Dog Had Bitten Him And Threatened To Sue Us For $60,000, Until Our Vet Asked The Judge To Look Inside The Dog’s Mouth
The hail came through on a Tuesday night in the middle of May, and it sounded like somebody emptying a truckload of gravel onto the house. Lavern and I sat up in bed in the dark and held hands like teenagers at a scary movie. Our old dog Brisket crawled all the way under the bed, which he had not been able to fit under since about 2016, and we had to lift the mattress off the frame in the morning to get him out.
We have lived in that little white house outside Neosho, Missouri, since 1979. Lavern is seventy-six and worked thirty-eight years at the feed mill. I am seventy-three and spent twenty-nine years behind the counter at the post office in town, so I know nearly everybody in Newton County by their middle initial and their package habits. We are not rich people, but we are paid-off people, and to us that has always felt like the same thing.
When the sun came up that Wednesday, the yard was white with ice the size of marbles and buckeyes, and our roof looked like a cookie sheet somebody had beaten with a hammer. There were shingles in the ditch. There was a hole the size of a dinner plate over the back bedroom.
Subscribers read every story ad-free, and every subscription helps us publish more of them. First month is $0.99, then $1.99. Cancel anytime.
Read ad-free for $0.99 →By nine o’clock that morning, a man was knocking on our door.

A Very Nice Young Man
His name was Dusty Hensarling, and he was the nicest young man I have ever been robbed by.
He had a clean white pickup with a magnetic sign on the door and a clipboard and a smile that went all the way up to his eyes. He said he was working storms all over the four-state area. He said he’d already signed up six houses on our road, which turned out to be true, and that if we got on his list today, he could have a crew out in two weeks.
“Ma’am, you don’t want to wait on this,” he said. “Every roofer in the state is headed this way. In a month you won’t be able to get a shingle for love or money.”
He climbed up on the roof and took pictures and came back down shaking his head. He sat at our kitchen table with a cup of my coffee and wrote up an estimate for twenty-nine thousand six hundred dollars. He said the insurance would pay most of it once the adjuster came. He said all he needed today was half, so he could lock in his materials before the price went up.
Brisket sat on the kitchen floor the whole time with his head on Dusty’s boot. Brisket is a black-and-tan shepherd mix with one ear that stands up and one that flops over like a bent page. Lavern found him as a puppy in a cardboard box behind the sale barn in Granby in 2013. He is thirteen now and has never in his life met a person he didn’t want to lean on.
“Good old boy,” Dusty said, and rubbed his ears. “I got a dog at home just like him.”
Lavern wrote the check. Fourteen thousand eight hundred dollars, out of the savings account we keep for the funeral home and the furnace. Dusty shook his hand, tipped his cap to me, and backed his clean white pickup out of our drive.
That was the last time either of us saw him until we were standing in a courtroom.
The Blue Tarp
Two weeks went by. Then three. Lavern called the number on the estimate every morning after breakfast. At first it rang and went to a voicemail that said, “You’ve reached Hensarling Roofing and Restoration, we’re out serving our customers.” Later it didn’t even ring.
Our neighbor Purvis Kimbro, who is eighty and used to climb power poles for the electric co-op, came over with his grandson and a blue tarp and some two-by-fours and nailed it down over the worst of the roof so we wouldn’t get rained on in the back bedroom. That tarp is in every picture of our house from that summer. Purvis said, “Oleta, I hate to tell you, but you’re not the only one.” The widow down on Route V had paid Dusty nine thousand. A young couple near Seneca had paid him twelve. Nobody had seen a crew.
I wrote Dusty a letter. I am good at letters. I asked him, politely, to either do the work he’d been paid for or return the deposit within thirty days. I sent it certified, the way I’d sold certified mail to a thousand other people, and I watched the little green card come back signed by somebody with a scrawl.
Thirty days went by. Then I filed in small claims court at the courthouse in Neosho. It cost thirty-some dollars. I thought that would be the end of it. I thought a man like that would just pay rather than come in front of a judge.
I was wrong about that, too.
A Letter From a Lawyer
Subscribers get every story on Daily Positive with no ads, no pop-ups, no "watch an ad to continue." $0.99 for your first month, or $9.99 for the whole year.
Go ad-free for $0.99 →Three weeks after I filed, we got a letter on heavy cream paper from a lawyer in Springfield named Mack Fultz.
I read it standing at the mailbox, and then I read it again sitting in the truck with the door open because my knees wouldn’t hold me.
It said that on the day of the estimate, May 13, our dog had “attacked Mr. Hensarling without provocation” as he walked back to his truck, biting him on the back of his right calf. It said he had been treated at an urgent care clinic and missed weeks of work. There were copies of two photographs. One showed the back of a man’s leg with two dark puncture marks and some purple bruising. The other showed a receipt from an urgent care in Springfield.
It said that if we did not drop our claim and sign the enclosed release, Mr. Hensarling would file suit against us for sixty thousand dollars in medical costs, lost wages and pain and suffering. And it said they would also “petition the county to have the animal declared dangerous and dealt with accordingly.”
I sat in the truck and looked across the yard at Brisket. He was lying in the shade of the porch with his tongue hanging out the side of his mouth, the way it always does now, watching a robin.
Dealt with accordingly.
Gaylene Drives Up
Our daughter Gaylene lives in Frisco, Texas, outside Dallas. She is forty-eight and works in human resources for a company that sells software to other companies that sell software, and she has been trying to get us to sell the house and move into her basement apartment since Lavern turned seventy.
I didn’t mean to tell her about the letter. But she called that Sunday and could hear in my voice that something was wrong, and she pulled it out of me the way she used to pull splinters.
She drove up the next weekend. Five and a half hours. She walked into our kitchen, looked up at the water stain on the ceiling, looked out the window at the tarp, and sat down at the table with her hands folded like she was about to fire somebody.
“Mom. Dad. Sign the release.”
“We are not signing anything,” Lavern said.
“Daddy, it’s his word against yours. He’s got photos. He’s got a doctor’s bill. You’ve got a dog who’s thirteen years old. If a judge decides that dog is dangerous, they’ll take him. Is that what you want? For fourteen thousand dollars?”
“It’s fourteen thousand eight hundred,” I said, “and the dog didn’t bite him.”
“How do you know? Were you watching every second?”
I wasn’t, as it happens. I had gone to get Dusty a second cup of coffee in a to-go cup when he left, and Lavern had been in the bathroom. For about a minute and a half, Brisket had been alone in the yard with that man.
Gaylene saw me hesitate, and her face changed. She reached across the table and took my hand.
“Mom, listen to me,” she said, and her voice went soft. “This is what I’ve been afraid of. You two out here alone with a hole in the roof and some crook taking your money and now lawyers. You don’t have to fight this. Let it go. Come down to Frisco. My HOA allows one dog under thirty pounds. We’d find Brisket a good home somewhere with a big yard, a farm or something, he’d love it.”
Lavern stood up from the table without a word, went out on the porch and sat down next to the dog. He stayed out there till dark.
What Brisket Can’t Do
That night I couldn’t sleep, so I got up and sat at the kitchen table with the lawyer’s letter and a cup of decaf. Brisket came padding in from the living room, the way he does when he hears a chair scrape after midnight, and laid his head on my knee. I scratched his ears. He yawned one of his enormous old-dog yawns, the kind that makes a little squeak at the top.
And I looked straight into his mouth.
There is nothing in there. Pink gums and a long tongue, and that’s all.
I’d forgotten. That is the honest truth. It had been so long that I had stopped thinking about it, the way you stop thinking about your husband’s hearing aids or the crack in the windshield. Four years earlier, in the spring of 2022, Brisket’s teeth had gone bad all at once, the way old dogs’ sometimes do, and our vet, Dr. Anjali Mehra, had to pull every one of them. Forty-two teeth. She sent us home with a bag of soft food and said he’d do better without them, and he did. He gained back his weight. His tongue has hung out the left side of his mouth ever since, and he gums his food like an old man at a fish fry.
He has not been able to bite a slice of bread since 2022, much less a grown man’s leg through a pair of work jeans.
I sat there with my hand on his head and laughed out loud in the dark kitchen until Lavern came out in his undershirt to see if I’d lost my mind.
Dr. Mehra
Dr. Mehra has been our vet since she bought the clinic on the Granby highway in 2009. She is a small, fierce woman in her fifties who wears her reading glasses on top of her head and has, I am fairly sure, never once been late for anything. When I called her office Monday morning and told the girl at the desk what it was about, Dr. Mehra called me back on her lunch break.
“Read me the date again,” she said.
“May thirteenth.”
“And the wounds. Describe them.”
I described the photo. Two dark punctures on the back of a calf, maybe an inch and a half apart, with bruising.
There was a long quiet on the line. Then Dr. Mehra said, in a voice I had never heard her use, “Mrs. Raskin, I have the dental X-rays from March of 2022 and the extraction notes, and I have a photograph of that dog’s mouth from his last checkup in April. Would you like me to bring them to court?”
“Would you?”
“I’ll close the clinic for the morning,” she said. “I have been waiting my whole career for somebody to try this.”
Gaylene Calls Back
I called Gaylene that evening and told her.
She didn’t say anything for a while. Then she said, “Mom, are you sure? All of them?”
“Every one. You can come look.”
“Then why didn’t you tell me that on Saturday?”
“Because I’d forgotten,” I said. “And because you didn’t ask about the dog. You asked about the roof and the money and the lawyer and whether your father and I were too old to live by ourselves. You never once asked about Brisket.”
That was harder than I meant it. I heard her breathe in sharp on the other end of the line.
“I’m coming to the hearing,” she said finally.
“You don’t have to.”
“I know I don’t have to,” Gaylene said. “That’s why I’m coming.”
Associate Circuit Court
The hearing was on a Thursday morning in October at the Newton County courthouse, a big limestone building where I’d paid probably fifty years of property taxes. Judge Pearline Ogletree had the small courtroom on the second floor. She is about sixty, with short gray hair and a voice that could stop traffic. I have sold her stamps for years. She always buys the flags.
Dusty Hensarling sat at the other table in a pressed blue shirt and his clean smile, next to Mack Fultz from Springfield, who had a leather briefcase and good shoes. Dusty didn’t look at us once. Gaylene sat behind me and Lavern. Purvis Kimbro came, and the widow from Route V, and that young couple from Seneca, who sat in the back row holding hands.
And Brisket came too. Lavern had asked the bailiff, a nice young man named Kyler, whether a dog could wait in the hallway, and Kyler had looked at him and at Brisket and said, “Sir, I believe that dog can sit right by your chair.”
Mr. Fultz went first. He told the judge that his client had suffered a serious and painful dog bite while performing a free courtesy inspection for an elderly couple, and that any money he had received had been spent in good faith on materials before he was “forced off the job by his injuries.” He put the photo of the leg on an easel. He handed up the urgent care receipt. He had Dusty stand up and pull up his pant leg to show a little white scar on his calf.
“That dog,” Dusty said, pointing at Brisket, “came up behind me and took hold of my leg and would not let go. I thought he was going to drag me down.”
Brisket, hearing someone point at him, lifted his head off the floor, thumped his tail twice, and lay back down.
“Would You Look Inside His Mouth?”
When it was our turn, I stood up, and my voice shook a little. I said I wasn’t a lawyer, and I’d brought our veterinarian, and I asked if she could speak.
Dr. Mehra walked up to the front with a manila folder under her arm. She gave her name and her license number and said she had been Brisket’s doctor for thirteen years. Then she laid two X-rays on the judge’s bench, and a printed page of surgery notes, and a color photograph.
“Your Honor,” she said, “on March 9, 2022, I performed a full-mouth extraction on this dog under anesthesia. Forty-two teeth. Every one. These are the films from before and after. This is a photograph of his mouth taken at his wellness exam this April, one month before the alleged bite. As you can see, there are no teeth in it. There have been no teeth in it for four and a half years.”
The courtroom went so quiet I could hear the radiator ticking.
Mr. Fultz stood up. “Your Honor, with respect, photographs can be…”
“Would the court like to look inside his mouth?” Dr. Mehra asked. “He’s right here. He doesn’t mind. He likes people.”
Judge Ogletree looked at her for a long moment over her glasses. Then she said, “Mr. Raskin, would you bring your dog up here, please.”
Lavern walked Brisket up to the bench. The judge came down the two steps in her black robe, bent over, and Dr. Mehra crouched beside the dog and gently lifted his upper lip with her thumb, and then the lower. Brisket stood there wagging. Then, because he is who he is, he yawned. A big one, with the squeak at the top.
Pink gums. A long tongue. Nothing else.
Somebody in the back row laughed and then covered their mouth.

The Date on the Receipt
Judge Ogletree went back up to her chair and sat down. She picked up the urgent care receipt Mr. Fultz had handed her and looked at it for a long time. Then she put on a second pair of glasses over the first ones.
“Mr. Hensarling,” she said. “What day did the hailstorm come through Neosho?”
Dusty glanced at his lawyer. “May. The middle of May.”
“May twelfth,” said Judge Ogletree. “I remember because it took out my greenhouse. You testified you were bitten on the thirteenth. This receipt is dated April twenty-second.”
Nobody said anything.
“That is three weeks,” the judge said, “before you ever set foot on the Raskins’ property, and three weeks before there was any hail to sell anybody a roof for.”
Mr. Fultz leaned over and said something in his client’s ear. Dusty’s face had gone a color I can only describe as uncooked. He said something about a mix-up with the paperwork. He said his wife handled the receipts. He said a lot of things very fast.
Then Purvis Kimbro stood up in the back of the courtroom, which you are not supposed to do, and said, “Your Honor, if it helps, I’ve got three more families out here he took money from. And a fellow up near Monett who says that same dog bite story was used on him last summer, only that time it was a Labrador.”
Judge Ogletree told Purvis to sit down. But she wrote something on her pad first.
What the Judge Said
She ruled from the bench. Full return of the fourteen thousand eight hundred dollars, plus court costs, within thirty days. She dismissed the counterclaim about the bite with what she called “considerable prejudice.” Then she said she was referring the matter, and the receipt, and the names of everybody sitting in the back row, to the county prosecutor and the attorney general’s consumer protection office.
Then she looked down at Brisket, who had gone back to sleep under Lavern’s chair with his tongue out on the floor.
“And for the record,” Judge Ogletree said, “this court finds that the animal is not dangerous. This court finds that the animal is, if anything, a very good boy.”
Mr. Fultz packed up his leather briefcase without looking at his client. Out in the hallway, I heard him say, quite clearly, “You told me the dog had teeth.”
Gaylene on the Courthouse Steps
Gaylene waited for us on the courthouse steps. She had been crying, and she is not a crier. She works in human resources. She fires people for a living.
She knelt down on the limestone in her good slacks and took Brisket’s old gray face in both hands.
“I’m sorry,” she told him. Then she stood up and said it to me, and then to her father. “I’m sorry. I was so scared something would happen to you out here that I didn’t even listen. I was ready to give away Daddy’s dog so I could feel better.”
“You were scared,” Lavern said. “We get scared too.”
“I know,” she said. “That’s the part I keep forgetting.”

Under a New Roof
The money came back in twenty-six days, in a cashier’s check from Mr. Fultz’s office. I suspect he had decided to get it off his hands. The widow on Route V and the couple from Seneca got theirs back that winter, after the attorney general’s office got involved. Dusty Hensarling, I heard from a woman who buys stamps in bulk, has a court date in the next county over and another one across the line in Arkansas.
Purvis’s grandson put the new roof on in November with two friends from his church and charged us for the shingles and a pot of chili. It is a good roof. It doesn’t leak.
Gaylene comes up every month now instead of every Christmas. She doesn’t talk about the basement apartment. Last visit, she sat out on the porch with her father and Brisket and a bag of the soft treats the dog likes, feeding him one at a time and watching him gum them.
“He really can’t bite anything,” she said, amazed.
“He never wanted to,” Lavern said. “That’s the part the roofer didn’t know.”
Storm season is coming back around before you know it, and men like Dusty follow the hail. If you have parents or grandparents living on their own, please share this with them, and tell them to never pay a stranger at the door. And if you ever need a witness who can’t tell a lie, check whether the family dog has his teeth.
Now Trending:
- Not One Of My Six Children Came To My 60th Birthday Dinner. At 9 P.M. A Police Officer Knocked With A Note From My Son
- My Sister Borrowed My Old Golden Retriever For “A Quiet Weekend” Four Times This Fall. The Last Time She Brought Him Home, There Was Rice In His Fur, And The Next Morning A Bride I’d Never Met Sent Me A Photo Of Him Walking Down The Aisle
- The Bus Driver We Trusted For Four Years Shouted At Me To Keep My Distance, Slammed The Doors And Drove Off With My Daughter. Then The Deputy Asked Me If I Had Seen The Man Standing Behind Me
Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family
