The New Church Board Chairman Shut Down My Saturday Pet Food Pantry After 16 Years And Called It A “Liability.” The Night I Went To Clear Out The Fellowship Hall, My Old Basset Hound Would Not Leave One Corner Of The Closet Alone

Every Saturday morning for sixteen years I have loaded the back seat of my Buick with paper sacks, and every Saturday my basset hound Gumbo has sat in the front seat like a deacon and supervised.

We run the pantry out of the fellowship hall at Salem Ridge United Methodist, a white church on a hill outside Loudonville, Ohio, with a gravel lot and a steeple that has needed paint since the first Bush. It started in 2009. A man on my street named Hobart got laid off from the tire plant, and his old collie went thin right alongside him because Hobart was feeding her last. I found out only because the collie turned up on my porch, ribs showing, looking embarrassed. I fed her. Then I got to thinking about how many people in our county were doing what Hobart did, skipping the dog’s supper or their own.

So I asked the church for the use of the hall on Saturday mornings from nine to noon, and I put a folding table by the kitchen door. People brought in the bags of kibble they had over-bought. A feed store in Wooster gave us the dented sacks. Within a year we were feeding about sixty dogs a week and a handful of cats and one very loud pet goose.

I am seventy-two. I managed a school cafeteria for thirty-one years, so I know how to feed a crowd with what is on hand and not run out before the last one in line. My husband Cecil used to carry the heavy sacks until his back quit in 2017, and he died three winters ago. After that, it was me and Gumbo. Ten years old, tricolor, ears like a pair of wet dishrags. He sits by the table, and every dog that comes in gets a sniff from him first. I do not know what he tells them. They all calm down.

The treasurer of our church for thirty-one years was a woman named Esther Brewer. She was ninety pounds and wore a cardigan in July. Esther kept the church books, and she kept the pantry’s little account separate in her own tidy hand, every dollar written down in pencil first and ink after. She died last spring, in her sleep, at eighty-four. We buried her on a Tuesday in the rain, and Gumbo, who is not allowed in the sanctuary, lay down in the church doorway and would not move until the last car left.

I tell you all this so you understand what I mean when I say that nobody was watching the books after that.

The Man Who Took Over

The church board met in May and needed a new chairman, and the treasurer’s job was open too. Nobody wanted both. Norbert Cantrell said he would take both “for now, until we sort things out.”

Norbert is sixty-one. He owns Cantrell Auto Glass out on Route 60, and the way he wears his sleeves rolled to the elbow tells you he wants you to know he works. He was always friendly in the way a man is friendly when he is deciding what you are worth. He called me “young lady” when I was seventy-one and “Miss Thelma” when I turned seventy-two, and neither one ever sounded like respect.

For the first couple of months he left the pantry alone. In August he asked me to “run some numbers” for him on what the pantry cost the church. I said it cost the church a folding table and the electric bill for three hours a week. Esther had paid the bills for the pantry out of its own fund, which came from jar donations, a bake sale every spring, and one very large gift I will get to in a minute.

He wrote that down. He said “interesting” in a voice that told me it wasn’t.

In September the board voted four to three to “pause” Saturday distribution pending an insurance review. I was not told about the meeting. Our pastor, a gentle man named Cyrus Morrow who would rather get a tooth pulled than be in a fight, told me after, looking at his shoes. “Thelma, I think it’s just a pause.”

It was not a pause. On the first Friday in October, Norbert came to the hall while I was marking up sacks for the next morning, and he stood in the kitchen doorway with his arms folded.

“A Liability”

“Miss Thelma,” he said, “I’ve talked to the insurance people. A pet food operation in the fellowship hall is a liability. Animals in a building where we serve funeral lunches. Dogs biting people. Somebody slips on a kibble.”

“Nobody has slipped on kibble in sixteen years, Norbert.”

“That’s luck.” He glanced down at Gumbo, who was lying with his chin on my shoe. “And frankly, that dog shouldn’t be in here either. There’s a smell.”

“He’s a basset hound. He smells like a basset hound.”

“People can feed their own dogs,” Norbert said, and that was the sentence that stayed with me. “We’re a church. We’re not a feed store. I think at your age you’d be glad to put your feet up. I’d like the room cleared out by the end of next week. Sacks, table, all of it. Take your things and go home.”

I stood in my own kitchen, in a hall I had swept every Saturday of my adult life, and I could not find a word. I remember Gumbo getting up and leaning against my calf the way he does when somebody in the room is upset. I remember thinking that I was not going to give that man the satisfaction of watching me cry.

“What about the Brewer money?” I asked.

That was the large gift. Esther had left the pantry thirty-eight thousand dollars in her will. It came to the church in July, through her lawyer in Millersburg, and the letter said plainly that the money was “for the continued feeding of the animals of the county’s hungry, under the care of Thelma Dobbins or her named successor.” I had heard it read aloud at a board meeting. I had cried in front of everybody. It was the one time I did.

“That’s been moved to the general fund,” Norbert said. “For the building. We have some serious needs. The parking lot alone.”

“That money was left for the pantry.”

“It was left to the church,” he said. “I have the paperwork.” He did not smile, and he did not look away either. “Next Friday, Miss Thelma.”

Clearing Out

I did not sleep that night. I called Ruthann Fogle in the morning. Ruthann kept books for the feed store for twenty-two years and sings alto two pews behind me, and she is the only person I know who reads the fine print on a bank statement for fun. I told her about the money.

“Thirty-eight thousand,” she said. “Moved to the general fund. By whom?”

“By the treasurer. Norbert.”

“Who is also the chairman.” She was quiet. “Thelma, in a church that size, that’s one man signing off on his own work. That isn’t illegal. It is just a thing you’d never do on purpose.”

“What do I do?”

“Clear out the room,” she said. “Quietly. And while you do it, look at everything. Esther was never going to leave a mess.”

So that is what I did on Thursday night, a day early, by myself, with a flashlight and Gumbo. I did not want to do it in front of the Saturday regulars. I did not want the Yaegers’ little terrier to come up to the door and find the table gone.

I drove up around seven. The church was dark. I let myself in with the kitchen key, the one on a loop of green yarn Esther gave me in 2010, and I turned on the one light over the stove, and I started stacking the sacks by the door.

We keep the extra supplies in a closet under the back stairs. It is a narrow closet, six feet deep, with a plywood floor and shelving on one side, and it smells of old coffee and cardboard. I carried out about thirty sacks. I was on my fifth trip when I noticed that Gumbo was not behind me.

Where the Dog Went

I found him in the closet, in the far back corner, nose pressed to the baseboard, breathing hard and fast.

“Gumbo, come on, baby. We’ve got to get done.”

He did not turn his head. Gumbo is a dog who can be talked into anything. He will leave a ham. He did not move. He put one big paw on the baseboard and scraped it, and the paw made a hollow sound, which I should have noticed sooner than I did.

“Gumbo.”

He gave a low, long bay, the sound that basset hounds were bred to make across a field. I had heard him do it twice in his life, once at the vet and once at Cecil’s funeral. Then he went back to scratching.

I got down on my knees, which took a while. The baseboard in that corner was a short piece, about a foot long, and when I put my fingers on it I felt that the nails had been pushed in by hand rather than driven. It came away with a little pull. Behind it, in the gap between the wall studs, was a round tin with a blue lid. A Danish butter cookie tin, the kind every grandmother in Ohio keeps buttons in.

On the lid, in pencil, in a hand I would have known anywhere, somebody had written two words. Not my name, and not the church’s. Just the word “Biscuits,” and underneath, a smaller line.

For G. and T.

I sat back on my heels, there on the floor of the closet, and Gumbo put his whole chin on my knee. I thought of all the Saturdays Esther had slipped something into her cardigan pocket while I was busy, and how Gumbo would find her after the line cleared, and she would bend down with her bad knees and put her hand out flat. I had always thought it was a bit of cheese.

Esther’s Tin

I opened it under the light over the stove.

There was one broken half of a dog biscuit on top, so old it had gone gray. Under it there was a spiral notebook with a green cover, the kind we bought for the school office by the case, and a folded sheaf of papers held with a rubber band, and a single sheet of her lined stationery, folded in thirds.

I read the letter first. I have it in my purse still. I will give you the words as near as I can.

“Dear Thelma. If you are reading this, I am either gone or Norbert Cantrell has done what I think he is going to do. In March he asked me to sign the pantry fund over to the building account. He said it was for the roof. I said no, the fund belongs to the pantry. He said it would be easier if I just trusted him. I have known three treasurers’ wives, and I have never trusted a man who said ‘easier.’ So I made copies. Everything is in the book. The notebook is the real record, in pencil and ink, back to 2009. The bank pages are the last six months. I never meant for you to need this. But I have a feeling about that man. I have been wrong about nearly nothing in my life, and I am sorry about the one thing, which is that I won’t be around to see your face. Give Gumbo his biscuit. He has earned it more than either of us. Esther.”

I read it twice. Then I got out my phone, and with my hands shaking, I took pictures of every single page.

What the Pages Said

Ruthann came over at eight that night, in her bathrobe under her coat. She sat at my kitchen table with her reading glasses on and Esther’s notebook open to the last page, and she ran her finger down the figures with her lips moving.

It took her about forty minutes. I made coffee, and then I made more coffee, and Gumbo lay under the table with his head on her foot.

“All right,” she said, finally. She took off her glasses and rubbed the bridge of her nose. “Here is what we have. The church received thirty-eight thousand dollars and some change from Esther’s estate on the eleventh of July. It went into the pantry account, which is what the lawyer’s letter said to do. On the twenty-second of August, there is a transfer out of that account of twenty-nine thousand four hundred dollars. It was signed by one person.”

“Norbert.”

“Norbert. It went to the general fund. And then, on the twenty-sixth of August, a check for twenty-nine thousand and some change goes out of the general fund to a company called N.C. Lot and Drive, for what the memo line calls ‘parking lot resurfacing.'”

“We haven’t resurfaced the lot.”

“No,” Ruthann said. “I drove in on Sunday. Same gravel, same potholes. Thelma, I looked up N.C. Lot and Drive on the Secretary of State site while you were pouring coffee. It was registered in May. Its owner is listed as one Norbert Cantrell, at the address of his auto glass shop.”

I want to tell you I felt triumph. I did not. I felt tired and sick, because I had sat in a pew with that man for four years and I had passed him the peace.

“There’s more,” Ruthann said, quieter. She turned the notebook around. “These are the Saturday sign-in numbers. Esther counted every dog. Look at the last page. Sixty-one dogs the week before she died. Do you know what the church’s insurance premium went up by, since the pantry is such a liability?”

“No.”

“Nothing,” she said. “I called the agent’s office this afternoon, before you rang me back. She said the policy has never excluded animals in the hall. It was never even a question. Nobody at that agency has ever spoken to Norbert about it.”

The Sunday Vote

The congregational meeting was set for Sunday, after the service. Norbert had called it himself, and the notice on the bulletin said, in his wording, “Final approval of facilities repurposing plan.” I had not been told what that was. Ruthann found out by Saturday noon, because she called Pastor Morrow and he, bless him, told her the truth. Norbert planned to move the board to sell the old parsonage next door, which the church had owned since 1952, and to turn the fellowship hall into a rental space for weddings and reunions at four hundred dollars a day. He had a contractor lined up. The contractor’s name, Ruthann said dryly, was also Cantrell.

I thought about going to the sheriff on Friday night. Ruthann talked me out of it, and I am glad she did. “If you call the sheriff, Norbert says it’s a misunderstanding and calls his lawyer,” she said. “If you stand up in front of a hundred and ten members of that church, with Esther’s own handwriting, he can’t say a thing. He can’t even sit down.”

So on Sunday morning I put on the good navy dress and Esther’s green yarn went around my wrist like a bracelet, and I brought Gumbo. He is not allowed in the sanctuary. I knew that. I thought, what are they going to do, throw out a ten-year-old basset hound in front of the congregation?

Norbert stood at the lectern with his sleeves rolled and a folder in his hand, and he talked for twelve minutes about “stewardship” and “tough decisions” and “the reality of our aging building.” He said the pantry had been “a lovely ministry for its time.” He said it with a little nod toward me. Then he said the board would like to move to a vote.

I stood up.

Esther Speaks

I want to say my knees did not shake. They did, so hard I held the back of the pew in front of me. Gumbo sat down on my foot.

“Mr. Chairman,” I said. “I have something to read first. It’s from Esther Brewer.”

It got very still. Somebody coughed. Norbert smiled a little and said, “Thelma, this isn’t the time,” and Pastor Morrow, I will always love him for it, said in his small voice, “Norbert, I believe it is.”

So I read her letter out loud. I read it all, down to the biscuit. When I got to “I have never trusted a man who said ‘easier,'” I heard somebody in the back let out a short laugh, and then somebody else sniffed. When I finished, I held up the green notebook.

“This is the record,” I said. “In pencil and ink. Ruthann Fogle has gone through the last six months. If anyone wants to see it, the pages are on the table at the back.”

Ruthann stood up and said, in her plain alto voice, “Twenty-nine thousand four hundred dollars of the Brewer gift was moved out of the pantry account on August twenty-second. Four days later the same amount was paid out of the general fund to a company called N.C. Lot and Drive, for a parking lot that has not been resurfaced. The Secretary of State lists that company’s owner. I would like Mr. Cantrell to tell us who that is.”

I have never heard a room that quiet. The furnace ticked.

Norbert said, “That is a legitimate contractor. I recused myself.”

“From signing the check?” Ruthann said. “You signed it.”

A man named Wendel Hartsough, who farms eighty acres of corn out past the creek and has not said a word at a church meeting since the Carter administration, stood up in the third row. “Norbert,” he said, slowly, “did you pay yourself out of the dog food money?”

Norbert looked at the folder in his hand as though it might answer for him. He started to say something about “an appearance of impropriety.” Then Gumbo, who had been sitting very politely on my shoe, lifted his chin and let out one long, low bay that went up into the rafters and came back down again.

I will never be able to convince anyone that a dog did that on purpose. But I will tell you that in a church of a hundred and ten people, not one of them looked at Gumbo and laughed.

After the Meeting

Norbert resigned that afternoon, in the parking lot, to Pastor Morrow, standing beside his truck. I was told later that he did not argue. I think he saw the faces.

The district office sent a man down from Columbus the next week, an accountant with a briefcase and a very patient way of asking the same question three times. He spent two days in the church office with Ruthann. By the end of the month there was an audit on file, and a letter from the church’s lawyer to Norbert, and a polite request that he return the twenty-nine thousand four hundred dollars. He sold a boat to do it. It came back to the pantry account in full, every cent, with a note from the district office that the matter would not be referred to the county prosecutor so long as the church saw no further irregularities. Some people were angry about that. I am not sure what I think. I wanted my Saturday back more than I wanted him punished, and I got it.

Pastor Morrow, who I had been quietly angry with, drove out to my house on a Wednesday with a pie from the Mennonite bakery and sat in my kitchen for an hour. “I should have stood up in September,” he said. “I have been afraid of that man since May. I’m sorry, Thelma.” I told him that the Lord’s work gets done by frightened people more often than not, and that he could make it up to me by letting Gumbo have a chair in the hall.

He agreed. The chair is a green vinyl one that used to be in the nursery. Gumbo has never once sat in it.

The Saturday After

We reopened on the third Saturday in October. I did not put up a notice. I did not need to. By eight-fifteen there were twelve cars in the gravel lot, and by nine the line ran out the door and down the steps, men in work boots and women in church coats and a boy of about nineteen with a pit bull puppy under his arm. Hobart came, the man who started it all, with a young beagle on a rope. His collie died in 2016. He did not say anything. He took a sack of kibble and held it against his chest and nodded at me, and that was plenty.

The new treasurer is Ruthann Fogle. She counts the sign-in sheet on Saturday afternoons with Esther’s green notebook open beside her, and she writes the numbers in pencil first and ink after. The Brewer money is in a separate account that requires two signatures, mine and hers. Last month we paid the feed store, and the electric bill, and a vet bill for a farm dog with a thorn in its foot, and nobody had to ask permission.

The parsonage was not sold. The fellowship hall was never rented. The paint on the steeple is still peeling. The parking lot, for the record, is still gravel. Wendel Hartsough showed up one Saturday in November with a tractor and a load of crushed stone and filled the potholes himself, and he would not take a dime.

I keep the cookie tin on the shelf in the kitchen, where I can see it. Esther’s letter is in there, and the broken biscuit, gone gray as a stone, and I do not plan to throw either of them out. On Saturdays, when the line thins, I take one fresh biscuit from the box and I put it in my cardigan pocket. When no one is looking, I bend down with my bad knees and I hold out my hand flat.

Gumbo knows exactly what it is. He takes it as gently as a communion wafer.

I keep wondering how many good things in this world stop because somebody with a title says the word “liability” and everybody else is too polite to ask who it is a liability for. If you know of a small kindness in your own town that someone is trying to shut down, please share this with a friend who might be able to stand up for it. Sometimes all it takes is one person reading a letter out loud.

Now Trending:

• I Was Flying To My Mother’s Hospital Bed When I Saw My Husband Kissing My Best Friend In Row 2. I Didn’t Make A Scene. I Asked The Flight Attendant To Deliver “A Little Gift” To Seats 2A And 2B
• I Was Not Invited To My Son’s Wedding, But They Sent Me The $150,000 Bill, So I Showed Up At The Hotel In A Red Dress
• I Came Home From Two Weeks At My Sister’s And Found Fifteen Strangers Asleep In My Living Room. I Didn’t Shout. I Went Upstairs, Brought Down A Small Urn, And Told My Daughter’s Mother-In-Law To Open It

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family