The Vacation Rental Host Canceled My Week At The Lake Twelve Hours Before Check-In Because She “Didn’t Realize The Dog Was Coming,” Even Though I’d Already Paid The $75 Pet Fee. Then Her Father Called From The Cabin And Asked What Brand Of Food He Eats

My name is Lottie Fairbairn. I am sixty-seven years old, and I live in Jefferson City, Missouri, in the house my husband Paxton and I bought in 1989. Paxton died three years ago in April. His heart stopped while he was carrying a bag of mulch in from the driveway. I mention it so you understand why the lake in October mattered as much as it did.

October 12th would have been our fortieth anniversary.

We were married at the courthouse on a Tuesday because we did not want to wait until Saturday. The next year we went to the Lake of the Ozarks and sat on a borrowed dock with our feet in the water and said we would do that every October if we could. We did it most years. Money was tight in the nineties. But we went enough times that the lake, for me, is a kind of calendar.

We always brought the dog we had at the time. The last of those dogs is Sorrel.

Sorrel is a yellow Labrador, twelve years old, with a white chin and a tail that still knocks coffee cups off the low table if you are not paying attention. He was Paxton’s dog the way a certain chair is a person’s chair. After Paxton died, Sorrel slept in the hallway outside the bedroom for six months. Then one night he came in and got on the rug on my side, and he has slept there since.

He is healthy. He is slower on the stairs and he climbs into the back seat instead of jumping, but he eats and he walks and he still believes every body of water was put there for him personally.

I booked the cabin in August so that I would not talk myself out of it.

The Cabin I Booked in August

It was a small oak cabin near Camdenton, on a slope above a quiet cut of the lake, with a screen porch facing the water. The listing showed a rust-colored metal roof, a gravel drive, two rockers on the porch, and a kitchen with old butcher-block counters. It slept four, which was three more than I needed. It allowed one dog. The pet fee was $75.00.

The week’s rent was $1,185.00.

I read the listing four times. I looked at the photographs of the porch the longest. I could see myself there in the morning with a mug and Sorrel lying on the boards where the sun came through the screen. I messaged the host, Brielle Vodden, on August 14th, at 9:22 in the morning.

“I would like to book the week of October 11th through the 18th,” I wrote. “It would have been my fortieth anniversary. I would be bringing my older Lab, Sorrel. He is house-trained and quiet. Please let me know if that is all right.”

She wrote back in eleven minutes. “So sorry for your loss! Dog is fine, just pay the pet fee at booking. Cabin is beautiful that week. Leaves should be turning!”

I paid through the site that same morning. $1,185.00 for the week, $75.00 for the pet fee, $94.80 in service fees, $1,354.80 total. I printed the confirmation and clipped it to the refrigerator with a magnet shaped like a catfish, which Paxton bought at a bait shop in 2004 and which I have never been able to throw away.

All through September I got ready in small ways. I bought a new plaid throw for the car, $22.64 on sale, and asked the neighbor two doors down to take in my mail. By the first of October the suitcase was open on the spare bed, and Sorrel’s duffel was zipped beside it: his bowl, his leash, a worn tennis ball, and a bag of his chicken-and-rice kibble, $46.99 for the twenty-four-pound bag.

I told him we were going to the lake. He does not know the word, but he knows the duffel.

On October 10th I filled the tank, $41.37, and laid my driving clothes out on the chair. Check-in was at 4:00 the next afternoon. Camdenton is a little under two hours from my driveway. I planned to stop once, at the place where Paxton always bought ice and a soda, because the habit is a kind of company.

Twelve Hours Before Check-In

The message came at 4:06 in the morning on October 11th. I know the time because the phone lit up the ceiling and I had to put on my glasses to read it.

It was from Brielle Vodden.

“Hi Lottie! So sorry for the late notice, I didn’t realize the dog was coming and my boyfriend’s family needs the cabin this week after all. I can issue a partial refund. I’ll need to keep the pet fee for the trouble. Hope you understand!”

I sat up in bed. Sorrel lifted his head from the rug and looked at me, waiting to see if this was a getting-up.

I read it again. Then I opened the original thread from August and looked at my own words. I would be bringing my older Lab, Sorrel. And her reply. Dog is fine, just pay the pet fee at booking.

I had paid the pet fee.

I typed with my thumbs, which I do slowly.

“I told you about the dog in August, when I booked. I paid the $75 pet fee the same day. This trip is for my anniversary. Please do not cancel.”

She answered at 7:19, after I had given up on sleep and made coffee and fed Sorrel at the regular time.

“I really am sorry!! The listing is under my management and I have to prioritize family this week. Partial refund of the rent is already processing, minus one night and the cleaning fee. Pet fee is nonrefundable since I had to rearrange. The cabin just isn’t set up for a dog the way I thought. I didn’t realize the dog was coming until I double-checked the messages. Safe travels if you find something else!”

There is a particular cruelty in a cheerful exclamation point. I sat at my kitchen table and did the math on the back of an envelope. She was keeping $248.00 of the rent plus the entire $75.00 pet fee, twelve hours before I was supposed to leave, after I had packed, after I had arranged the mail, after I had told a dead man I was going back to the lake for him.

I am not a person who writes angry messages. I wrote, “I am very disappointed. I paid the pet fee in good faith.” And then I put the phone face down.

Sorrel came and set his chin on my knee. I scratched the place he likes, behind the left ear, and I cried in a quiet way that did not alarm him.

What I Did With the Packed Bags

I thought about booking another cabin. Everything decent on the lake was taken, or cost more than I could spend on a day’s notice. One place allowed dogs and was free, a brown A-frame forty minutes farther on, $1,640.00 for the week, which I do not have sitting around for other people’s last-minute decisions.

Paxton would have said, “We’ll figure it out, Lot.” He called me Lot when he was trying to make a thing smaller than it was. I said it out loud in the kitchen, just to hear it, and it did not make the thing smaller.

I did not know what I was going to do with October 12th. That was the day that worried me, more than the cabin, more than the money. I had planned to be on a screen porch, telling Paxton about the year I had had. Without the porch I was just going to be in this house, where his chair is still at an angle to the television.

I lay down on the couch at three, which I almost never do in the afternoon, and Sorrel got up beside me even though he is not supposed to, and I let him.

A Number I Didn’t Recognize

The phone rang at 6:42 that evening. I almost did not answer. I thought it might be Brielle again, with another exclamation point. The number was a Missouri cell I did not know, a different prefix than hers.

I answered anyway. I am of the generation that still thinks a ringing phone might be important.

“Is this Lottie Fairbairn?” a man said. He had an older voice, careful, as if he were reading my name off a piece of paper.

“Yes.”

“My name is Piers Vodden. I believe you booked my cabin near Camdenton for this week.”

I sat up. Sorrel slid off the couch with an offended sound.

“I did,” I said. “The host canceled this morning.” I did not say “your daughter” yet, because I did not know that part for certain, and because I try not to put family trouble onto a stranger.

“I know,” he said. “That is why I am calling. I own the cabin. Brielle manages the listing for me. I have been staying with my sister for a few days after a checkup, nothing dramatic, and I only just saw the cancellation on the shared email. I am sitting on the porch right now, Mrs. Fairbairn, and there is nobody else’s family here. There is a squirrel and there is me.”

I did not speak for a second.

“She told me her boyfriend’s family needed the cabin,” I said.

He was quiet too, and in that quiet I heard something like a man choosing his words so he would not say the ones he first thought of.

“I am sorry she told you that,” he said. “I am sorry she canceled on you twelve hours before check-in. I read your original message, the one from August, about your anniversary and about your dog. I also saw that you paid the pet fee. The cabin has always allowed a dog. That was my rule when I listed it. It is still my rule.”

“She said she didn’t realize the dog was coming.”

“She realized it in August,” he said. “I can see the message.”

A cardinal knocked against the kitchen window, the same foolish one who has been doing that since summer. I watched him do it while I held the phone.

“I would like you to come,” Piers said. “If you still want to. Check-in can be whenever you get here tomorrow. I will have the place ready. And I would like to ask you something practical, if you don’t mind.”

“All right.”

“What brand of food does he eat?” he said. “I can pick some up in town so you don’t have to unload a whole bag for a week, or so you have extra if you need it. I don’t want him stuck with whatever I guess at.”

I told him the chicken-and-rice kind, the bag with the yellow stripe. He repeated it back to me. He did not say it was adorable. He did not use an exclamation point. He just wrote it down, I think, and then he gave me the gate code in case he was down at the dock when I arrived.

I hung up and looked at Sorrel.

“We’re going,” I said.

He wagged once, and then again, as if the second time was for Paxton.

A Water Bowl on the Boards

I left Jefferson City at 7:15 the next morning, October 12th, our anniversary. The trees along the highway were just past their peak, bronze and rust and a leftover green. I stopped at Paxton’s ice-and-soda place and bought a bottle of orange soda I did not particularly want, $1.89, because what I had wanted was the stopping.

Sorrel rode in the back seat on his blanket. He slept most of the way. When we turned off toward the water he sat up and put his nose to the glass and made the low sound he makes for lakes and rivers.

The cabin was at the end of a gravel drive, oak trees on both sides, the rust-colored roof exactly as it had been in the photographs. A blue pickup was parked to the left. On the screen porch, visible as soon as I got out of the car, a man was standing next to a metal water bowl.

The bowl was already filled.

Piers Vodden was in his seventies, I would guess, lean, in a flannel shirt and work boots, with a neatly trimmed white beard and a pair of glasses pushed up on his head. He raised a hand and came down the steps.

“You must be Lottie,” he said. “And that will be Sorrel.”

Sorrel got down from the back seat with his careful climb and went to the man without any fuss, which he does not do with everyone. Piers let him sniff, then scratched his chest, then looked up at me.

“Happy anniversary,” he said, quietly. “I hope that isn’t the wrong thing to say.”

“It isn’t,” I said.

“There’s water on the porch,” he said. “I boiled it first, because I don’t know how particular he is. And I got the food. Same kind you said, yellow stripe. It’s in the kitchen in a tin so the raccoons don’t get ambitious.”

“Come see the porch,” he said.

The boards were worn smooth. The two rockers were there, with faded cushions. The water bowl sat by the door, heavy enough that it would not tip if a Lab checked it with his paw, which Sorrel immediately did. The screen smelled like lake and old oak and a little bit of oil soap, as if someone had washed the floor that morning.

Piers set my suitcase inside. He would not let me carry it up the steps. Sorrel went in, made a slow loop of the main room, and came back to the porch as if he had decided this was the correct station.

“I owe you an apology that isn’t mine to give,” Piers said. “I will give it anyway. You should not have been canceled. You should not have been told the dog was a surprise. And you should not have been charged for the trouble of a trouble we made.”

He took an envelope out of his shirt pocket and set it on the little table between the rockers.

“That is the week’s rent and the pet fee,” he said. “All of it. I already reversed what the site was going to send you in pieces so you are not waiting on their timeline. This is cash, which I know is old-fashioned. Count it when you want. It should be $1,260.00, the rent plus the seventy-five.”

I stared at the envelope.

“I can’t take that,” I said. “I am staying. That would mean I stay for free.”

“Yes,” he said. “That is the idea. It is an apology, not a coupon. The week is yours. The cabin is better with a dog on the porch. That was true when my kids were young and it is true this morning.”

What He Wrote Down

We sat on the porch for a little while. He asked about the drive. I asked about his checkup, enough to be polite, and he said the doctor had been boring, which he seemed to consider a good review. His sister lived half an hour away. He had seen the shared listing email on her kitchen tablet after supper and had driven over last night.

“I called Brielle from this porch,” he said. “I will not repeat her end of it. I told her I was calling you. I told her the boyfriend’s family was not a reason I recognized, since I am the owner and I was sitting here looking at an empty driveway.”

He rubbed his thumb along the arm of the rocker.

“She is not a cruel person,” he said. “She is a person who gets nervous about wear and tear and then tells herself a story that makes her nerves look like policy. I have done a version of that in my life. It does not make what she did all right.”

From his other pocket he took a folded piece of paper, plain copy paper, with writing in a steady hand.

“I am putting this in the house binder,” he said. “And I am putting a copy with the listing documents she cannot edit without me. It says the cabin allows one dog, the pet fee is $75.00 and is collected only when a dog is actually coming, and the owner, me, is the only person who can cancel a reservation that was made in good faith. She manages the calendar. She does not override this.”

He let me read it. There was nothing fancy in the language. It looked like a man who had kept farm records or church minutes. At the bottom he had signed his name and dated it October 12th.

“She cannot override it?” I said.

“Not unless she has learned how to change my signature,” he said. “Which I doubt.”

He stood, slow in the knees. “I will get out of your anniversary. There are extra blankets in the hall closet. The dock chair is steadier than it looks. Town is twelve minutes if you forgot anything. I live down the county road if you need a hand. I’ll come by tomorrow only if you want me to. Otherwise I will leave you the lake.”

“Thank you,” I said, and it came out thinner than I meant.

He went down the steps, stopped to let Sorrel sniff his hand again, and drove off in the blue pickup. I sat in the left-hand rocker with the envelope under my palm and Sorrel already stretched out in the bar of sun that fell across the boards, and I told Paxton I had made it.

I did not tell him everything yet. There would be time.

The Second Day

I slept with the windows cracked. In the morning I made coffee in a percolator that took me a minute to figure out and carried it to the porch. A thin mist sat on the water until about nine. I walked Sorrel down to the dock and he waded in up to his chest and stood there looking satisfied, as if he had signed a lease.

Around eleven I heard a car in the drive.

I thought it might be Piers. It was a small gray car, and the woman who got out was in her thirties, with sunglasses she took off and put back on and then took off again, as if she could not decide how visible she wanted to be.

“Mrs. Fairbairn?” she said. “I’m Brielle. I… my father said I should come in person.”

I stayed on the porch. I did not hurry down the steps. Sorrel stood beside me and wagged once, because he is kinder than the situation.

“I am sorry,” she said. She said it to the railing first, and then to me. “I shouldn’t have canceled. I shouldn’t have said I didn’t realize the dog was coming. I did realize. I got nervous about hair and scratches and my boyfriend’s parents talking about staying, which was a conversation, not a booking, and I took the easy reservation to undo. Yours. That was wrong.”

“You kept the pet fee,” I said. “For the trouble.”

She winced. “I know. My father told me. He already made it right, I think. I brought this anyway.” She held up a bakery bag, the paper kind. “It’s just muffins. I didn’t know if you ate muffins. It isn’t enough. I know that.”

“Come up,” I said.

She came up and sat on the top step, not in the other rocker. She set the bag on the porch. Sorrel inspected it and, finding no meat, returned to his sun.

“My father wrote a rule,” she said. “I read it. I understand it. I won’t do this again.” She looked at Sorrel. “He’s a nice dog. I don’t know why I made him into a problem. He isn’t a problem.”

“No,” I said. “He isn’t.”

We did not become friends over muffins. She stayed twelve minutes. She told me the oven runs hot, which I had already discovered. She said happy anniversary in a clumsy way, and I accepted it in a clumsy way, and she drove off down the gravel with her sunglasses on again.

The Week We Kept

I stayed the whole week.

I walked the shoreline in the mornings with Sorrel. I sat on the dock in the aluminum chair and read the same page of my book four times, which was fine, because I had not come to the lake to finish a book. I told Paxton about the cancellation, about the phone call, and about a man who asked what brand of food our dog ate as if that were the most obvious next question in the world.

On Thursday evening Piers drove by and lifted a hand from the pickup without stopping, which was exactly the right amount of neighbor. On Friday I went into town and bought a small bag of the same kibble so I could leave the tin replenished. It cost $18.27. I left a note on the butcher-block counter: Thank you. The water bowl was a kindness I will not forget. Lottie and Sorrel.

The written rule was already in the binder when I first looked, slipped into the front sleeve, Piers’s signature at the bottom. I photographed it, because a person who has been canceled twelve hours before check-in learns to keep copies.

Sunday morning I packed. Sorrel climbed into the back seat and lay down on his blanket as if he had done this commute his whole life. I stood on the porch for a last minute with my hand on the screen door. The lake was bright. The two rockers were still. The water bowl was empty because I had rinsed it and set it upside down.

“All right,” I said, to Paxton, to the week, to nobody.

I drove back to Jefferson City with the window cracked and Sorrel snoring, and when I unlocked my own door the house smelled like dust and dish soap and the ghost of the mulch Paxton never finished spreading. I put the catfish magnet back over a new paper, the printed rule I had copied at the library for twenty cents, and I gave Sorrel his supper in his regular bowl.

He ate it. Then he got on the rug on my side of the bed, even though it was too early, and waited for me to catch up.

I keep thinking about the question Piers asked me on the phone, before he had even seen us. What brand of food does he eat. Not, is the dog a problem. Not, can you leave him home. Just: what does he eat, so I can pick some up in town.

If a canceled reservation has ever landed on you like a door shutting, or if you have ever filled a water bowl before the guests even turned into the drive, maybe send this on. Somewhere a screen porch is holding two rockers and a patch of sun just the size of an old yellow dog.

Now Trending:

• My Parents Converted My Childhood Bedroom Into A Home Gym The Week I Told Them I Was Pregnant And Said There Was “No Room For A Baby At Our Age.” Then My Aunt Sent A Photo Of Her Spare Room With My Old Yellow Desk Already Back Against The Wall
• The Antique Dealer My Daughter Hired Set My Late Husband’s Dog Crate Out By The Curb With The Rest Of The “Junk.” Before Trash Pickup, The Mail Carrier Knocked Holding The Crate And A Letter That Had Been Taped Under The Tray
• The New Owner Of The Coin Laundry Followed Me Into The Parking Lot And Yelled That My Old Dog Made His Business Look “Low Class.” Then A Woman Folding A Sheet Inside Stepped Out Holding A Badge And Asked Him To Say That Again

Please let us know your thoughts and SHARE this story with your Friends and Family